Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
1я половина книги.doc
Скачиваний:
8
Добавлен:
01.04.2025
Размер:
1 Мб
Скачать
☆

200 The Handbook of Blended Learning

relationships necessary for faculty to accept the involvement of staff experts in the design and delivery of their courses; in effect, it builds confidence, shared knowl­edge, understanding of the role of instructional designers, and overall rapport.

The final session is the Faculty Showcase, where each instructor presents a module of the course he or she is redesigning to an audience consisting of fellow faculty, department chairs, deans, and CDWS staff, with an occasional visit by the university's provost or president. Although these presentations are brief, they clearly reveal the degree of transformation the faculty members have experienced. After faculty members have completed IDL6543, they continue to work with their as­signed instructional designer to complete development of their initial course. When the online course is completed, instructional designers review it for quality before it is offered online.

During the first semester a new blended course is offered, the instructor has access to his or her instructional designer and production staff to resolve any last-minute problems or brush up on any skills needed to deliver the course. As faculty become more familiar with the tools and techniques necessary to develop online courses, they are encouraged to take greater responsibility for ongoing course maintenance activities. Many individuals initially choose the "full-service" option of having staff design, develop, and produce their courses, then later shift to a "self-service" model with increased personal responsibility.

The transformative nature of the UCF blended model results in a sense of continuous improvement in course design. For example, the design of the "Exploring Wines of the World" course was modified with the completion of a new hospitality management laboratory—classroom environment. This facility allowed the instructor to fulfill his initial plan to integrate the classroom and lab­oratory experiences fully. Both lecture and wine tasting could then occur simul­taneously in a class so that students tasted a wine immediately after it was described, and discussion could occur. Online activities—exercises, quizzes, and modules—reinforced what was covered in class. The professor reports that this integration of activities will be enhanced in the future.

We find that this continuous incremental model of improvement is common in these blended courses as faculty become comfortable with the model and new and improved resources become available. Faculty find the flexibility of this modal­ity allows them to use instructional resources and techniques they might noi have had access to in a pure face-to-face or fully online modality. They are further encouraged by positive student perception of the course and improved student performance.

For many institutions, the initial engagement in online learning consisted of fully online courses and programs offered to distant students. With blended

Blended Learning Enters the Mainstream

201

learning, the focus is on the institution's mainstream students, faculty, and academic programs. The differences in approach and impact can be signifi­cant. Internally directed initiatives require greater emphasis on systemic ap­proaches, attendance to issues of campus and faculty culture, and increasing requirements for student business and academic support services to be acces­sible online.

Some Demographics for Blended Learning

The blended online course model has the potential to yield significant classroom space efficiencies. However, a review of blended course scheduling practices indicated this was not occurring as expected. While the university's scheduling guidelines en­able sharing traditional Tuesday-Thursday and Monday-Wednesday-Friday time slots and alternate week (for example, every other Monday) offerings, some faculty have developed highly flexible instructional patterns using the blended model. Other instructors may have a preplanned but irregular on-again, off-again class meeting schedule, and some take advantage of real-time progress and learning assessment and develop their reduced seat-time strategies on a week-to-week basis throughout the term.

Scheduling personnel continually works toward a goal of having a high per­centage of sections matched with other companion classes sharing the same room and block schedule time. The percentage of blended class sections that are matched and share classroom space and block schedule time slots grew from 24 percent in fall 2002 to 42 percent in fall 2004.

Outcomes for Blended Learning

A recent program sponsored by the EDUCAUSE National Learning Infra­structure Initiative (National Learning Infrastructure Initiative, 2003) on trans­formative assessment (ТА) has led to new thinking on the manner in which we conceptualize and use data-based information regarding teaching and learn­ing through technology. Considering evaluation in three phases (administra­tive, progressive, and transformative), the National Learning Infrastructure Initiative suggests that assessment is a fundamental component of higher ed­ucation transformation. Simultaneously, the Sloan-C Consortium has devel­oped a model for assessing quality education in asynchronous learning networks (Moore, 2002).

202

The Handbook of Blended Learning

Two important elements of the Sloan pillar framework involve learning effectiveness and student satisfaction. Learning effectiveness concentrates on assessing whether technology-based instruction produces comparable or supe­rior learning outcomes when compared to face-to-face environments. Student satisfaction considers how well learners adapt and thrive in technology-enhanced learning environments. In addition to asynchronous learning net­works, these elements form an effective underpinning for evaluating blended learning. At the University of Central Florida, evaluation procedures encom­pass the two national initiatives, producing a protocol that is consistent with the blended learning metaphor—a mixture of face-to-face and online learn­ing. (For more information on the blended learning impact evaluation at UCF conducted by the Research Initiative for Teaching Effectiveness, see h ttp: // rite, ucf.edu.)

Learning Effectiveness

At UCF, we use a declassification strategy to determine learning effectiveness with grades. By declassification, we mean reducing grades to a binary format that defines success in a course. Grade distributions vary widely across depart­ments for reasons that reflect differences in instructional and assessment philoso­phies, as well as accepted academic norms. This causes difficulty comparin, A's, B's, C's, and so on across departments in a way that reflects the impact of blended learning. The declassification approach attempts to mitigate these idio­syncratic differences by sacrificing some specificity to gain reliability. The process is straightforward: an A, B, or С grade is considered success, while any other grades—D, F, W, or I—are classified as nonsuccess. Obviously, the deci­sion about where to define the cut-off point between success and nonsuccess is arbitrary. Another important variable in learning effectiveness is the withdrawal rate of students enrolled in blended courses compared to roughly compara­ble face-to-face and fully online courses.

Figure 14.2 shows the success rates for the spring 2003 semester for the three UCF colleges housing the majority of Web courses: Arts and Sciences (CAS . Health and Public Affairs (COHPA), and Education (СОЕ). Success rates vary bj college for all disciplines, but the trend is for blended courses to produce succe^-rates equal to or higher than their face-to-face and fully online counterparts.

Figure 14.3 illustrates the college comparisons for withdrawal rates in tl: various modalities. As with success rates, withdrawal rates vary across the col­leges, with the СОЕ typically showing the lowest attrition. Overall, the with­drawal rates for blended courses are generally comparable to those ifl face-to-face sections.

204

The Handbook of Blended Learning

FIGURE 14.4. STUDENT SATISFACTION WITH BLENDED LEARNING (Л/ = 473).

Blended Learning as a Transformative Construct in Higher Education

The blended environment serves as a prototype for universities of the future. Fully online initiatives are a phenomenon separate from the academy— essentially advocating deemphasis of traditional approaches and teaching strate­gies. However, the blended format coalesces Web-based and face-to-face instruction into an entirely new model that holds the potential to transform both teaching and learning.

Blended teaching and learning responds to what Oblinger (2003) and Wendover (2002) define as the new-generation learners (millennials). These stu­dents, born after 1980, have grown up with what other generations view as new technologies. They are connected (mostly to each other) and proficient in the use of communicative technology, often viewing what transpires in college classrooms as slow moving and uninteresting. Wendover (2002) describes a classroom sce­nario where four generations are present (matures, baby boomers, generation-Xers, and millennials). He suggests that matures' and boomers' preferred mode of communication is prolonged discussion. The generation-X students simph want to move on with it, while the millennials are quite content to sit and watch the goings on.

Our findings at UGF show that younger students are less satisfied with their online experience, with the millennials being the least satisfied of the generational

Blended Learning Enters the Mainstream

205

groups. An important caution is that blended learning is not strictly an instruc­tional phenomenon. All aspects of the university must be involved in a systemic way—colleges, departments, faculty, support services, and infrastructure—to en­able student and faculty success in the online environment. When those ele­ments are in place and functioning effectively, blended learning can produce satisfied and high-achieving students, professionally satisfied faculty, opportunities for innovative and responsive program design, more efficient and effective use of facilities, and improved relationships with the community. The blended learning model has the potential to transform. It can change online learning from some­thing the institution does to something the institution is, and it can lead to fun­damental changes in the way instructors teach and students learn, strategies for delivering services, and space needs and new resource use efficiencies. Blended learning, in the context of the academy, is a complex system that will inevitably have both positive and negative side effects. The task ahead of us is to better un­derstand the dynamics of blended learning so that we can optimize its impact on our institutions, faculty, and students.

References

Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2003). Sizing the opportunity: The quality and extent of online education in the United States, 2002-2003. Needham, MA: Sloan-C.

Ashby, С. М. (2002). Distance education: Growth in distance education programs and implications for federal education policy. Washington, DC: U.S. General Accounting Office.

Dziuban, C, Hartman J., & Moskal, P. D. (2004, March 30). Blended learning. ECAR Research Bulletin, 7. Retrieved August 1, 2004, from http://www.educause.edu/ecar/.

Dziuban, C, Hartman, J., Moskal, P., Sorg, S., & Truman, B. (2004). Three ALN modalities: An institutional perspective. In J. Bourne &J. C. Moore (Eds.), Elements of quality online education: Into the mainstream (pp. 127-148). Needham, MA: Sloan Center for Online Education.

Dziuban, C. D., Moskal, P., Juge, E, Truman-Davis, В., Sorg, S. & Hartman, J. (2000).

Developing a web-based instructional program in a metropolitan university. Unpublished manuscript, University of Central Florida.

EDUCAUSE. (2003). The pocket guide to U.S. higher education. Retrieved June 29, 2004, from http://www.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/PUB2201 .pdf.

Green, К. С (2003). Campus computing 2003. Encino, CA: Campus Computing Project. Avail­able online from http://www.campuscomputing.net.

Hanley, G. L. (2001). Designing and delivering instructional technology. In C. Barone & P. Hagner (Eds.), Technology-enhanced teaching and learning (pp. 57-64). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Hartman, J. L., Dziuban, C. D, & Moskal, P. (2000). Faculty satisfaction in ALNs: A depen­dent or independent variable? In J. Bourne (Ed.), Online education: Learning effectiveness and faculty satisfaction (pp. 151-172). Nashville, TN: Center for Asynchronous Learning Networks.

CHAPTER FIFTEEN

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]