Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
! grinblatt titman financial markets and corpor...doc
Скачиваний:
2
Добавлен:
01.04.2025
Размер:
12 Мб
Скачать
☆

10.7 Summary and Conclusions

This chapter focused on the project selection decision.Since projects have cash ows that occur in the future, it isimportant to have a selection technique that accounts forthe greater interest earning capability of cash that arrivessooner. The best way of taking the time value of moneyinto account is to study carefully how investors value ex-isting portfolios of securities with cash ows that are simi-lar to the cash ows of the project.

In assessing investment projects, the net present valuerule properly accounts for the time value of money and iseasy to implement when the future cash ows are riskless.The net present value rule also is useful for evaluatingrisky cash ows, as will be seen in later chapters, and it iseasily modied to account for various capital constraints.The internal rate of return rule, the other major alternative,also accounts for the time value of money, but it is toofraught with ambiguities to be used appropriately except inspecial circumstances.

Despite this, the IRRrule is still widely used. We have nogood explanation for this. It may be that practitioners preferto think about rates of return rather than about present valueswhen making decisions. However, the net protability rate,a variation on the net present value rule, is couched in termsof the rate of return and is not as popular as the IRR.

Many businesses, aware of the problems inherent inmultiple internal rates of return, have adopted proceduresthat “correct” the aws in the IRR-based capital allocationcriterion. One correction of this type is to compute an in-ternal rate of return by rst computing the sum of the dis-counted future negative cash ows at the hurdle rate andthen adding this to the initial cash ow. The adjusted IRRisthen computed as the rate that makes this sum plus the dis-counted value of all future positive cash ows (discountedat the adjusted IRR) equal to zero. Another correction ndsthe “internal rate of return” for the project as if only twocash ows existed: an initial cash ow and a cash ow atthe terminal date of the project that is equivalent in value tothe future cash ows of the project.

These methods are not really internal rate of returnmethods, but merely variations of the net protability rate(a different way of expressing the net present value crite-rion). These adaptations work ne in the absence of partic-ular constraints; however, it is easy to misuse these meth-ods when such constraints exist. For example, the methodthat computes the value of future cash ows at the project’sterminal date essentially spreads the rate of return from thenet protability rate over the life of the project. However,if capital is constrained only in the early stages of a project,this method is unfairly biased toward shorter-term projects.

If may be that rms tend to be overly optimistic aboutthe cash ows that stem from a project. In this case, rmsusing the net present value rule would favor longer-termprojects more than rms using the IRRrule or its adapta-tions. The bias of the net present value rule in favoringlonger-term projects occurs because each additional yearof overly optimistic cash ows would increase the net pres-ent value. However, we think that using an inappropriaterule is a poor way to correct the tendency of a rm’s em-ployees to exaggerate cash ow estimates.

Firms use other rules and rules of thumb to evaluate in-vestments. In contrast to the internal rate of return method,which can be justied under some circumstances, the pay-back and accounting rate of return methods are not sounddecision criteria. Specically, payback and accountingrates of return are based on accounting concepts. Unlikethe IRRand NPVrules, they do not adjust for the timevalue of money. As a result, they are being used less andless for evaluating major investments. That obviously infe-rior rules, like payback and accounting rate of return, areused at all for major decision making suggests to us that thecommonly used IRRrule contains no hidden virtue thatmakes it superior to NPV.We suspect that IRRrules, likethe accounting-based rules, persist because of habits orignorance and over time, we expect to see the use of IRRdiminish.

Key Concepts

Result

10.1:

The wealth maximizing net present value

initiating the project—is the same as the

criterion is that:

discounted value of all present and future

cash ows of the project.

•All projects with positive net present

Result 10.3:Given a set of investment projects, each

values should be accepted.

with positive NPV,one should select the

•All projects with negative net present

project with the largest positive NPVif

values should be rejected.

allowed to adopt only one of the projects.

Result

10.2:

For a project with riskless cash ows, the

Result 10.4:The discounted value of the stream of

NPV—that is, the market value of the

EVAs of a project is the same as the net

project’s tracking portfolio less the cost of

present value of the project.

Grinblatt734Titman: Financial

III. Valuing Real Assets

10. Investing in Risk734Free

© The McGraw734Hill

Markets and Corporate

Projects

Companies, 2002

Strategy, Second Edition

360Part IIIValuing Real Assets

Result

10.5:

The appropriate hurdle rate for

of return exceeds the hurdle rate(s). A

comparison with the IRRis that which

project with an early cash ow stream

makes the sum of the discounted future

should only be adopted if the hurdle

cash ows of the project equal to the

rate(s) exceed the internal rate of return of

selling price of the tracking portfolio of

the project.

the futurecash ows.

Result 10.7:The project with the largest IRRis

Result

10.6:

(The appropriate internal rate of return

generally not the project with the highest

rule.) In the absence of constraints, a

NPVand thus is not the best among a set

project with a later cash ow stream

of mutually exclusive projects.

should be adopted only if its internal rate

Key Terms

accounting rate of return358

internal rate of return method345

capital budgeting330

later cash ow stream345

capital constraints338

mutually exclusive projects330

costs of capital333

net present value (NPV)331

discounted cash ow332

net present value (NPV) criterion330

discounted cash ow (DCF) method330

net protability rate339

early cash ow stream345

numerical iteration345

economic depreciation341

payback method358

Economic Value Added (EVA)330

protability index338

equivalent annual benet341

return on assets358

hurdle rate345

term structure of interest rates (yield curve)330

internal rate of return (IRR)345

Exercises

10.1.Your rm has recently reached an expansion phasec.Assume now that you can expand without

and is seeking possible new geographic regions toregional saturation. With the budget constraint in

market the newly patented chemical compoundpart b,which region is optimal?

Glupto. The ve regional projections are as follows:10.2.The Wheatena Company is considering the

purchase of a new milling machine. What purchase

price makes the NPVof the project zero? Base your

Cash Flows (in $millions)analysis on the following facts:

Years from

•The new milling machine will reduce

Now:012345

operating expenses by exactly $20,000 per

Northeast951520253030year for 10 years. Each of these cash ow

Midwest751520202530reductions takes place at the end of the year.

Southeast601015202025•The old milling machine is now 5 years old

and has 10 years of scheduled life remaining.

West Coast35510101515

•The old milling machine was purchased for

Southwest20556610

$45,000 and has a current market value of

Zero-coupon$20,000.

yields (%)6.5%7%7%7.5%8%

•There are no taxes or ination.

•The risk-free rate is 10 percent.

a.

Which regions would be protable to the rm?

Exercises 10.3–10.6 make use of the following information.

Which of the ve is the most protable?

b.

If current budgeting can support a $100 million

Small Corp. is investigating a possible new project,

expenditure in year 0, what combination of

project X, which would affect corporate cash ow

regions is optimal?

as follows:

Grinblatt736Titman: Financial

III. Valuing Real Assets

10. Investing in Risk736Free

© The McGraw736Hill

Markets and Corporate

Projects

Companies, 2002

Strategy, Second Edition

Chapter 10

Investing in Risk-Free Projects

361

d.Based on the hurdle rate calculated and a

Cash Flows (in $) of Small Corp. comparison with the IRR,should Small Corp.

without Project X in Yearundertake the project?

e.If the sign of each cash ow were reversed, how

012345

would the hurdle rate and project IRRchange?

150175185185195200How would Small Corp.’s decision change?

Why?

Cash Flows (in $) of Small Corp.

10.7.As a regional managing director of Finco, a U.S.-

with Project X in Year

based investment company, your mandate is to

012345scour the Midwest in search of promising

investment opportunities and to recommend one

110165200205210213

projectto corporate headquarters in Los Angeles.

Your analysts have screened thousands of

prospective ventures and passed on the following10.3.Respond to parts athrough d.

four projects for your nal review:

a.What are the incremental cash ows associated

with Small Corp.’s undertaking project X? Are

these inows or outows, costs or revenue?

b.What is the PVof project X under a at termCash Flows (in $millions)

structure of 8 percent, compounded annually,Years from

Now:012345

irrespective of maturity?

c.Under these assumptions, what is the hurdle

Project 1401010151520

rate? Without further calculation, determine

Project 22555101515

whether the IRRfor project X is higher or lower

Project 3205551015

than the hurdle rate. (Hint:Use part b.)

d.Why might a at rate structure be unrealistic?Project 41533661310.4.Describe the equivalent tracking portfolio for

Zero-coupon

project X, giving long and short positions and

yields (%)—5%5%6%6%5%

amounts, under a at term structure of 8 percent,

compounded annually. Conceptually, why are we

interested in tracking project X’s cash ows with aa.Calculate the NPV,hurdle rate, and IRRfor each

portfolio of marketable securities?project. Which project appears most promising?

b.Determine NPVs using pairwise project10.5.Let B price per $100 of face value of a zero-

t

comparisons to verify your decision from part a.

coupon bond maturing at year t.Then, if

c.How would your answer change if all projects

B $94.00, B $88.20, B $81.50,

123

could be scaled and you have a year 0 budget

B $76.00, and B $73.00, implying that the

45

constraint of $50 million? (Hint:Calculate

term structure of interest rates is no longer at:

protability indexes.)

a.Determine zero-coupon rates for years 1 through

5 to the nearest .01 percent.10.8.ABC Metalworks wants to determine which model

b.Let’s now reconsider the tracking portfolio insheetcutter to purchase. Three choices are available,

exercise 10.4. What is the cost or revenue(1) machine 1 costs the least but must be replaced

associated with such a tracking portfolio at datethe most frequently, (2) machine 2 has average cost

0 under the new term structure?and average lifespan, and (3) machine 3 costs the

c.What is the NPVof project X under the newmost but needs only infrequent replacement.

term structure?Assume all three machines meet production quality

d.How are your answers to parts band crelated?and volume standards. Annual maintenance is

inversely proportional to the purchase price (that is,10.6.Consider the cash ows associated with

the cheaper machine requires higher maintenance),

undertaking project X.

and machine replacement, being instantaneous, will

a.Is this an early or later cash ow stream?

not disrupt production.

b.Based on the term structure of interest rates in

exercise 10.5, what is the hurdle rate? What

does such a hurdle rate represent?

c.Calculate the IRRfor project X.

Grinblatt738Titman: Financial

III. Valuing Real Assets

10. Investing in Risk738Free

© The McGraw738Hill

Markets and Corporate

Projects

Companies, 2002

Strategy, Second Edition

362Part IIIValuing Real Assets

before the technology would require replacement;

MachineMachineMachine

with level-B technology, the rm could generate a

123

cash ow of $1.7 million for three years, after

which the technology would require replacement.

Initial cost

$2,000$3,200$4,500

Investco is interested in a six-year planning

Annual

horizon. Assume the following about discount rates:

maintenance

$ 400$ 300$ 200

Life span

2 years

3 years

4 years

Zero-Coupon Yields forYear

a.Under a at discount rate assumption of 5

123456

percent per year, calculate the NPVfor each

machine.

5%5.5%6%6%6.5%7%

b.Which machine makes the most sense for cost-

efcient production?

c.How does your answer to part bchange under a

a.What is the nearest terminal date that is

at 6 percent discount rate assumption? Why?

concurrent for both packages? What are the

associated cash ows for each package or

10.9.

Investco, a West Coast research company, must

sequence of packages?

decide on the level of computer technology it will

b.What is the optimal decision, given Investco’s

buy for its analysis department. Package A, a

planning horizon?

midlevel technology, would cost $2.5 million for

c.At approximately what alternative package B

rmwide installation, while package B, a higher-

price would Investco be indifferent between the

level technology, would cost $3.5 million.

two packages?

Equipped with A-level technology, the rm could

generate a cash ow of $1.5 million for two years

References and Additional Readings

Brealey, Richard, and Stewart Myers. Principles of

Pindyck, Robert S., and Daniel L. Rubinfeld.

Corporate Finance.6th ed. Burr Ridge, IL:

Econometric Models and Economic Forecasts.3d ed.

McGraw-Hill, 2000.

New York: McGraw-Hill, 1991.

Cantor, David G., and Steven A. Lippman. “Investment

Ross, Stephen; Randolph Westereld; and Jeffrey Jaffe.

Selection with Imperfect Capital Markets.”

Corporate Finance.6th ed. Burr Ridge, IL:

Econometrica51, no. 4 (1983), pp.1121–44.

McGraw-Hill, 2000.

Hirshleifer, Jack. Investment, Interest, and Capital.

Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1970.

Grinblatt740Titman: Financial

III. Valuing Real Assets

10. Investing in Risk740Free

© The McGraw740Hill

Markets and Corporate

Projects

Companies, 2002

Strategy, Second Edition

Chapter 10

Investing in Risk-Free Projects

363

APPENDIX10A

THETERMSTRUCTUREOFINTERESTRATES

The term structure of interest rates, or yield curve, mentioned earlier in the chapter, is the pat-

tern of yields to maturity for riskless bonds of all maturities. In the United States, for example,

the yields from U.S. Treasury securities usually dene the term structure. While Treasury secu-

rities of all maturities do not always exist, the concept of a term structure is so important to cor-

porate nance and investment management that rates are computed between the existing matu-

rities by interpolating the rates.