- •Introduction
- •1 The acquisition of skills and experience in sport in terms of sports psychology
- •2 Superability
- •3 Stages of skill acquisition
- •4 The information-processing approach to skills
- •5 Memory
- •6 Theories of motor learning
- •7 Expert performance
- •8 Enhancing skill and expertise: the role of practice
- •Literature
6 Theories of motor learning
Whereas R. Anderson’s theory provides a good overview of the processes of memory, there are also theories addressing the more specific issue of the storage and retrieval of motor skills. Two theories have emerged as particularly significant: closed loop theory and schema theory.
J. Adams proposed a closed loop theory stating that two separate types of information are stored and interact to bring about the motor response. The memory trace contains the information needed to initiate the movement or movements. The perceptual trace contains the information as to what the movement should feel like if it is performed correctly. Once the movement begins, information from the muscles is fed back to the perceptual trace. If it does not match the memory of what the movement should feel like, this information is passed on to a central control centre, which amends the movement accordingly. Muscle movement is regulated by a closed feedback loop, involving the two types of stored information. The closed loop approach would explain well the familiar experience in which a person commences a technique, such as a tennis serve or a golf drive, and immediately becomes aware that it is not going to be successful. It certainly seems likely that both types of information proposed by J. Adams are indeed stored. However, as R. Schmidt pointed out, some motor responses are simply too quick to involve a feedback loop to perfect the movement. Closed loops are thus not universal in motor skills [2].
R. Schmidt proposed schema theory, an alternative approach to that of J. Adams. A schema is a packet of information containing all the possessed information in relation to one subject. Most cognitive psychologists support the notion that knowledge is stored in schemas. R. Schmidt went further and proposed that motor skills are stored in schemas as well. R. Schmidt proposed that when a man performs an action he stores four types of information. The initial conditions include any information about the environment in which the action was performed, the position and state of the body, and the circumstances in which that action was performed. Certain aspects of the movement, such as its speed, force and direction, are also stored. R. Schmidt’s third type of recorded information concerns the results of the action. Clearly, if a man is to plan, he needs to know what actions will have what effects. Finally, a man stores the sensory consequences of the action, that is, how it felt. Each action that is practised will generate two schemas, a recall schema, which contains the information needed to reproduce the movement, and a recognition schema, which compares the movements generated with those expected from past experience of performing the action. Recognition schemas are similar to J. Adams’ perceptual traces. There are two principal differences between schema theory and closed loop theory. Firstly, schema theory does not suggest a feedback loop; thus, the recognition schema does not automatically provide feedback to the recall schema. Secondly, unlike J. Adams’ memory traces, a schema as proposed by R. Schmidt corresponds to a single movement, not merely a movement in a single situation in a single sport. Thus, the skill of sprinting has a single schema that can be activated in a variety sporting situations, from track athletics to cricket and rugby. Like closed loop theory, schema theory can explain how a man can sense when a move is going awry. The great virtue of schema theory, as opposed to closed loop theory, is its cognitive economy. A general principle of cognitive psychology is that if a man could have developed two ways of performing a cognitive process, the chances are that he has evolved the simpler, more efficient system. Because schemas are generalised and can be activated in a variety of situations, they use considerably less processing capacity than perceptual traces, one of which would need to be constructed for every action in every sport. Most contemporary psychologists therefore broadly support schema theory [2].
