- •Metaethics: where our ethical principles come from (for example, Social construction? Will of God?) and what they mean
- •Applied Ethics: examining specific areas (for example, business ethics) and specific controversial issues (for example, abortion, capital punishment)
- •1) Difficulty of proving Supernatural Existence
- •2) Religious people can be immoral.
- •4) Different religions promote different ethical systems.
- •In Aristotle’s ethics (arete) is “excellences of various types.”
- •Virtue ethics is about character (agent-centered)
- •1) Psychological egoism:
- •2) Ethical egoism
- •Values of Traditional Society:
- •Impartiality and equality
- •Intensity
- •In other words with his/her choice man is setting an example of what he/she thinks is the right thing to do
- •Niccolò Machiavelli
- •Is the corporation a moral agent?
- •Favored by just cause advocates: legally.
- •Favored by at-will advocates: through the promotion of a vibrant labor market in which jobs are frequently created and readily available.
- •It can create a climate of support for attitudes that harm women
- •Issues in Euthanasia:
- •Voluntariness and Non-consequentialism
- •Bioethics: stem cell research
- •1953: Watson and Crick determine the molecular structure of dna
- •2000: Human Genome Project
- •Individuals with rare genetic disorders
- •In 1992 in Orlando, Florida, 5% of the drivers were black or Hispanic, but they accounted for 70% of those who were stopped and searched.
- •Information, computer and roboethics
- •Intellectual property
- •Isaac Asimov’s Laws of Robotics (1942, I Robot):
- •56 Nations are developing robotic weapons
It can create a climate of support for attitudes that harm women
Sex discrimination
Environmental Ethics: is the discipline that studies the moral relationship of human beings to, and also the value and moral status of, the environment and its nonhuman contents
Anthropocentrism:
A human-centered perspective: humans only (or mainly) have intrinsic value
Nature or environment has no value in itself: the value of nature is measured by how it affects human beings
Human Environmental Impact:
Four examples:
Global Warming
Ozone Depletion
Waste Disposal and Pollution
Wilderness Preservation
Global Warming:
Greenhouse Effect: the burning of fossil fuels (by industry, automobile exhaust…) spread into the atmosphere gases that prevent the sun’s infrared rays from radiating back into space. The trapped solar radiation contributes to increased air temperature.
Possible Solutions:
Better public transportation
Alternative Sources of power (such as bio-fuel, wind, solar. What about nuclear?)
Carbon Tax
Ozone Depletion: this is a gas present in the upper reaches of the stratosphere that protects us from the damaging effects of excessive ultraviolet radiation from the sun, which causes for example skin cancer.
Waste Disposal and Pollution:
We produce an enormous amount of garbage every day, but where do we put it? Usually we don’t want to live nearby a dump,
E-waste (outdated cell phones, TVs and computers) containing a huge amount of toxins
Air and water pollution produced by industries and automobiles causing serious health problems like allergies and tumors
Possible solutions:
Recycling
Reduction of emissions through strict legislation
Problems:
Costs
Developing countries
Wilderness Preservation:
John Muir opposed utilitarian policies
Destroying nature is destroying God’s work; he founded the Sierra Club – an environmental organization;
Nature deserves to exist for its own sake, regardless of its usefulness for human beings
Ecocentrism: a set of theories promoting the idea that not only humans have intrinsic value
Humans should not disturb natural processes; wildlife are natural (let them happen), hence regenerating
Humans should not make profits from natural things (trees); cutting trees, especially large trees, is wrong, trees have the same right to live as humans
An Ecosystem: is a “whole of interacting parts within a circumscribed locale”, it has:
Integrity (a unit of interdependent elements combining to make a whole with a unique character)
Stability (it changes only gradually)
Beauty (harmony and well-ordered form, or unity in diversity)
Arne Naess: a holistic view of nature. It requires that any intrusion in nature in order to change it requires a justification
Sustainable Development: the quality of not being harmful to the environment or depleting natural resources, and thereby supporting long- term ecological balance
Problem: The conflict between economic reasons in developing countries and environmental issues
Animal Rights:
Sentience: Jeremy Bentham said that in order to think about the ethical status of animals we do not need to ask whether they can speak, but whether they can suffer. Obviously the answer is positive, animals can suffer, and we can also add that they have emotions
Laws against cruelty
Should we only be bound by the idea of not causing pain? For example, not being cruel with animals just for the pleasure of being cruel
Obviously animals cannot claim to have rights, but also future generations cannot claim they have rightsà not moral actors, but moral patients
The idea of rights for animals may be derived from the fact that animals have interests: not to respect the interests of animals has been defined as “Speciesism” by Peter Singer
Bioethics
Model I: Interdisciplinary bioethics
Bioethics investigates ethical issues arising in the life sciences (medicine, health care, genetics, biology, biotechnology, ecology) through multi-disciplinary enquiry
Model II: Philosophical bioethics
Bioethics investigates ethical issues arising in the life science by applying the principles of moral philosophy to these issues
