- •Schubert, Franz (Peter)
- •1. Life.
- •(I) Background and childhood.
- •(II) The adolescent composer.
- •(III) Finding a career.
- •(IV) The miracle years.
- •(V) Independence.
- •(VI) Travel.
- •(VII) The professional composer.
- •(VIII) Crisis.
- •(IX) Despair and resolve.
- •(X) Respite: the summer of 1825.
- •(XI) Return to reality.
- •(XII) Beginnings and the end (1828).
- •(XIII) Schubert's character and the reception of his works.
- •2. Works.
- •(I) Songs.
- •(II) Partsongs and choruses.
- •(III) Sacred music.
- •(IV) Dramatic music.
- •(V) Piano music.
- •(VI) Chamber music.
- •(VII) Orchestral music.
- •(VIII) Schubert's style and influence.
(IX) Despair and resolve.
It is unclear to what extent medical care dominated Schubert's life over the next six years. Several friends refer to hospitalization (presumably at the Vienna general hospital) in 1823, which may have occurred in April/May or perhaps in the summer months of June/July, when red, pea-sized papules may have covered much of Schubert's body. Hospital conditions were unsanitary and often posed more threat to the patient than home care. In April Schubert was probably well enough to pass a few weeks with Schober and Josef Kupelwieser at the Bruchmann family's summer residence in Hütteldorf. By the end of July he was able to travel with Vogl on their annual trip to Steyr and Linz. Schubert wrote to Schober that he was ‘constantly in touch’ with his physician, Dr August von Schaeffer. During the stay at Steyr, however, Schubert apparently took ill; the liberal politician Anton Doblhoff wrote to Schober some months later that he ‘found him [Schubert] seriously ill at the time’. Schubert's illness, and possibly his lifestyle, led to reclusiveness. During this summer Beethoven's nephew Karl, visiting his uncle in Baden where the composer was engrossed in his Ninth Symphony, wrote in a conversation book that ‘they greatly praise Schubert, but it is said that he hides himself’. By the end of July Schubert was feeling well enough to perform with Vogl some of his songs for the Hartmann family in Linz. He and Vogl returned to Steyr for most of August. But his anxiety and foreboding persisted. In a letter to Schober from 14 August, Schubert wrote that ‘I correspond busily with Schaeffer and am fairly well. Whether I shall ever quite recover I am inclined to doubt’. In that same month Schober left Vienna for Breslau in the apparent hope of succeeding as an actor; he did not return to Vienna for two years. Returning once again to Linz at the end of August, Schubert and Vogl were both inducted as honorary members of the Linz Musical Society, complementing the Diploma of Honour that Schubert had received from the Styrian Music Society in December of 1822. When he returned to Vienna in September he took up lodgings with Josef Huber, a civil servant known as ‘tall Huber’. By now he was apparently suffering the symptoms of secondary syphilis, most visible from a papular rash that required him to shave his head. Now under the care of Dr Josef Bernhardt, his treatment (possibly again in hospital) was probably little more than a strict diet. Unlike Schaeffer, Bernhardt grew close to the Schubert circle; he and Schwind agreed to use the intimate Du form of address, and it may have extended to Schubert as well. By the year's end Schubert's health had rebounded once again; he was able, for example, to participate in a Schubertiad at Bruchmann's on 11 November. Two days earlier, Schwind wrote to Schober that ‘Schubert is better, and it will not be long before he goes about with his own hair again, which had to be shorn owing to the rash. He wears a very cosy wig’. At this same time the reading parties, suspended since Schober's departure, resumed at the painter Ludwig Mohn's.
Perhaps most remarkable about this year is that in spite of life-threatening crises, Schubert's productivity maintained the pace and quality of previous years. Indeed, it could be argued that a sharpened sense of his own mortality would spur Schubert to even greater achievements. In March and April he completed his eighth opera, the Singspiel Die Verschworenen, based on a libretto by Ignaz Castelli. In his preface Castelli could not resist a boast: ‘The German composer's complaint is usually this: “Indeed, we should gladly set operas to music, if only you would supply us with the librettos!” Here is one, gentlemen!’. Although it has proved to be Schubert's most frequently staged opera, the composer could not persuade the management of the Kärntnertortheater to perform it. The censors' suspicion that the title signalled seditious intentions led to a name change, Der häusliche Krieg. But the first, makeshift performance, with only piano accompaniment, did not take place until two years after Schubert's death. Between May and October the composer completed an even more ambitious project, Fierrabras, based on a libretto by Schubert's friend Josef Kupelwieser. Between 1821 and 1823 Kupelwieser was the secretary to the Kärntnertortheater, a circumstance that Schubert believed would facilitate the work's performance. But even with director Barbaia's purported interest in staging German operas, Fierrabras fared no better than Der häusliche Krieg. When Weber's Euryanthe, a heroic German opera commissioned by Barbaia, flopped, Schubert wrote on 30 November to Schober: ‘Weber's Euryanthe turned out wretchedly and its bad reception was quite justified, in my opinion. These circumstances … leave me scarcely any hope for my own opera’. Schubert may even have shared his reservations with Weber himself, leading to a greatly cooled relationship between the two composers. In spite of these discouragements, the two operas did not exhaust Schubert's dramatic output for the year. Around the beginning of December he was persuaded by Kupelwieser to provide incidental music to Helmina von Chézy's play Rosamunde, Fürstin von Zypern (d797), to be presented as a benefit for the actress Emilie Neumann, with whom Kupelwieser was in love. The première on 20 December suggests that Schubert had only a few weeks to complete his work; one confirmation of his tight schedule is his use in several numbers of previously composed music. Remarkably, Rosamunde proved to be one of his most unified dramatic works. In the two months before he composed Rosamunde Schubert was hard at work on the pathbreaking song cycle, Die schöne Müllerin, assembled from poems by Wilhelm Müller. During at least some of this time Schubert was probably hospitalized (and his head shaved); he may have indeed composed part of the tragic cycle while in hospital. Müller's cycle had its origins in an 1815–16 Berlin Liederspiel, a kind of party game in which group members take on different parts; Müller's narrative thread may include autobiographical elements. In addition to the protagonists, the dramatic role of the mill stream is reflected especially in Schubert's highly original accompaniments. To portray the full scope of feelings that climax in the young miller's drowning, Schubert employs everything from the folklike strophic form of the opening of Das Wandern to the through-composed mania of Eifersucht und Stolz. How Schubert became acquainted with the work of the Prussian poet Müller is unknown, but he found him congenial enough to return to him in 1827 for the poems for his next, and arguably greatest, song cycle, Winterreise. In February Schubert completed the Piano Sonata in A minor, d784, whose compact structure encompasses an explosive emotional range and novel keyboard techniques. 1823 also witnessed the publication of the ‘Wanderer’ Fantasy (d760) and more than a dozen important songs, including Auf dem Wasser zu singen (d774), Frühlingsglaube (d686), Gruppe aus dem Tartarus (d583) and Sei mir gegrüsst (d741). As he approached the first anniversary of his illness, Schubert had grappled repeatedly with depression and despair but maintained extraordinary resolve.
The year 1824 confirmed many changes in Schubert's life. Many of his best friends – among them Spaun, Stadler, Kenner, Schober and Kupelwieser – were now absent from Vienna either temporarily or permanently. Regular contact with Franz von Bruchmann, a troubled son of nobility, and with Schwind filled only part of the void. Bruchmann, who latter described the years 1823–6 as the most difficult of his life, shared with Schober a restless, often undisciplined, search for identity. He was drawn to the early Romantic outpourings of the Schlegel brothers, August and Friedrich. Schubert's relationship to Bruchmann may have extended back to the Stadkonvikt years; Bruchmann was also educated at a Piarist school and was associated with the unfortunate Johann Senn. Free of financial worries, he never trained for a profession, becoming a Redemptorist in 1826. The Bruchmann family hosted several Schubertiads between 1822 and 1824. But Schubert's strained friendship with Bruchmann ended abruptly around March 1825 when Bruchmann discovered his sister Justina's secret engagement with Schober. Bruchmann seems to have intervened in efforts that led to the breaking off of the engagement. Schwind, who had acted as an intermediary, and Schubert both turned against him, and there is no evidence that they ever had contact again. Regarding the talented Schwind, Schubert wrote to Kupelwieser in March that ‘thus, joyless and friendless, I should pass my days, did not Schwind visit me now and again and turn on me a ray of those sweet days of the past’. In spite of Schwind's impressive credentials, he and Schubert were not enough to sustain the reading parties and Schubertiads that had migrated recently to Ludwig Mohn's. After a Schubertiad on 19 January, all activities were discontinued by April. In the same letter to Kupelwieser, Schubert writes that ‘our society [reading circle], as you probably know already, has done itself to death because of an infusion of that rough chorus of beer drinkers and sausage eaters, for its dissolution is due in a couple of days, though I had hardly attended myself since your departure’.
Not all of Schubert's works from these months, however, were in a tragic vein. In February he had been commissioned by Count Ferdinand Troyer, a fine amateur clarinettist, to compose a chamber work incorporating the clarinet. Possibly in consultation with Troyer, Schubert modelled his work after Beethoven's equally youthful Septet, adding only another violin to create an ensemble of string quartet, double bass, clarinet, horn and bassoon. The sunny tone of the six-movement Octet in F major (d803) carries scarcely a whiff of despair. In the spring première at Count Troyer's, the count played the clarinet part himself. The particular ensemble can be seen as a chamber orchestra; in his same March letter to Kupelwieser, Schubert confided his compositional plans: ‘I seem once again to have composed two operas for nothing [Die Verschworenen and Fierrabras]. … Of songs I have not written many new ones, but I have tried my hand at several instrumental works, for I wrote two quartets … and an octet, and I want to write another quartet; in fact I intend to pave my way towards a grand symphony in this manner’. Schubert had finally given up on any possibility of making it as an opera composer. Although instrumental music enjoyed a prestige below that of opera, Schubert may have been further stimulated in this direction by his attendance at the première on 7 May 1824 of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony. To be sure, much of the programme was choral, including three movements from the Missa solemnis and the choral finale of the symphony itself. But it was both Vienna's and Schubert's first opportunity to hear a new Beethoven symphony in more than a decade, and Schubert cannot have failed to be moved by the sight of the ageing composer having to be turned around for a bow. Beethoven's means of creation, which generally involved starting with a modest idea (this can be said of the ‘Joy’ theme itself) that is raised by stages to sublimity, would have intrigued Schubert but not provided a model he could emulate.
After his 27th birthday at the end of January 1824, Schubert's health once again took a turn for the worse. Even though in February Schwind reported to Schober that Schubert had discarded his wig, the composer was confined to Huber's house as more symptoms of secondary syphilis descended on him in the form of ‘lesions of the mouth and throat’, aching bones, and, later, pains in his left arm that prevented him from playing the piano. Some time in February Dr Bernhardt introduced a new treatment, which in Schubert's time simply meant a new (and medically benign) diet. This one consisted of alternating days of pork cutlets and a dish called panada that combined flour, water, breadcrumbs and milk. Generous portions of tea and frequent baths completed the regimen. Taking advantage on the last day of March of the opportunity to ‘wholly pour out my soul to someone’, Schubert wrote to Kupelwieser:
I find myself to be the most unhappy and wretched creature in the world. Imagine a man whose health will never be right again, and who in sheer despair continually makes things worse and worse instead of better; imagine a man, I say, whose most brilliant hopes have perished, to whom the felicity of love and friendship have nothing to offer but pain at best, whom enthusiasm (at least of the stimulating variety) for all things beautiful threatens to forsake, and I ask you, is he not a miserable, unhappy being? ‘My peace is gone, my heart is sore, I shall find it nevermore’. I might as well sing every day now, for upon retiring to bed each night I hope that I may not wake again, and each morning only recalls yesterday's grief.
In response to his despair he kept an occasional journal; writing in March he appealed to the one thing whose loss would be even more devastating than his physical afflictions: ‘O imagination! thou greatest treasure of man, thou inexhaustible wellspring from which artists as well as savants drink! O remain with us still, by however few thou are acknowledged and revered …’. Schubert can only have drawn great comfort from the circumstance that his imagination had not deserted him, for in the months from January to March 1824 he completed the Variations on Trockne Blumen for flute and piano (d802); the String Quartet in A minor (d804); the String Quarter in D minor (d810), ‘Death and the Maiden’ – the latter two among the greatest works in the chamber music repertory – and several songs to texts by Mayrhofer. Both of the quartets are marked by such a degree of pathos and poignancy that it is impossible not to presume a direct connection between Schubert's life and this music. In a highly unusual notebook entry from March Schubert seems to make the connection himself: ‘What I produce is due to my understanding of music and to my sorrows’. One can only imagine the pleasure bordering on awe with which the Schuppanzigh Quartet (led by Vienna's most celebrated violinist) gave the first performance of the A minor Quartet on 14 March at the Musikverein.
Given Schubert's questionable health throughout the early months of the year, it is surprising that he agreed, after a six-year absence, to another lengthy summer sojourn in Zseliz as the music tutor to the two daughters of Count Johann Esterházy. He left Vienna for Zseliz on 25 May, less than three weeks after attending the première of Beethoven's Ninth. Aged 16 and 12 during Schubert's first tour, Marie von Esterházy was now 22 and Caroline 18. The second stay does not seem to have proved nearly as gratifying to Schubert as the first. He wrote in September to Schober, ‘Now I sit here alone in the depths of the Hungarian countryside, to which I unfortunately allowed myself to be enticed a second time, without having a single person with whom I could speak a sensible word’. It is a challenge to reconcile these words with testimony from two of Schubert's friends and acquaintances concerning his interest in Caroline. Baron Schönstein, who visited Zseliz again for two weeks that summer, remarked in 1857 about the ‘poetic flame that sprang up in [Schubert's] heart … for that he loved her [Caroline] must have been clear from a remark of Schubert's – his only declaration in words. Once, namely, when she reproached Schubert in fun for having dedicated no composition to her, he replied “What is the point? Everything is dedicated to you anyway”’. In an 1869 reminiscence the not always reliable Eduard von Bauernfeld wrote that Schubert was ‘head over heels in love with one of his pupils, a young Countess Esterházy’. In a letter to Schwind of August 1824 Schubert himself remarked that ‘I often long damnably for Vienna, in spite of the certain, attractive star’. As is the case with Therese Grob, nothing more specific can be traced directly to Schubert.
Perhaps as a homage to the high level of musicianship exhibited by his two pupils (who, according to Schönstein, needed coaching more than teaching), Schubert took up where he had left off in 1818, creating a trio of undisputed masterpieces for piano duet: the Sonata in C (d812; dubbed the ‘Grand Duo’ by its publisher Diabelli), the Variations in A on an original theme (d813), and most of the six Grandes marches (d819). In Schubert's time music for piano four hands was not simply a convenient vehicle for arrangements of orchestral works and opera overtures (although Schubert arranged four of his own overtures in just this way). Rather, it was a form of music-making of considerable social significance that permitted its executants a semi-public form of physical and emotional intimacy unequalled by any other form of social intercourse. Two generations earlier Mozart had succeeded in raising music for piano duet to a level above most domestic forms; but it was Schubert who took it to a level where it stood shoulder to shoulder with the prestigious genres of the sonata, string quartet and symphony. If Schubert performed any of the Zseliz works with either of the Esterházy daughters then they must have been accomplished keyboard players, for both the primo and the secondo parts are equally demanding. The rapidity with which Schubert could compose a multi-voice work with ten individually set stanzas and piano accompaniment is related by Schönstein: ‘One morning in September 1824 … Countess Esterházy invited Meister Schubert during breakfast … to set to music for our four voices a poem of which she was particularly fond … Gebet [‘Prayer’, by Friedrich de la Motte Fouqué]. Schubert read it, smiled inwardly … took the book and retired immediately in order to compose. In the evening of the same day we were already trying through the finished song at the piano from the manuscript’. In this same month, however, Schubert felt sufficiently alienated from the goings on at Zseliz (and, according to Schönstein, feared that he had taken poison) to entreat Schönstein to accompany him back to Vienna a full two months before the Esterházys' return. It is again difficult to reconcile his abrupt and premature departure with the posthumous reports of his deeply held love for Caroline. On his return to Vienna Schubert moved briefly – probably for financial reasons – for one last time into the Schubert family home in the Rossau. To be sure, it was the only place he ever lived in that contained a piano; Schubert never bought, leased or borrowed a piano of his own.
The only composition of any note during the remainder of 1824 was the Sonata for arpeggione and piano (d821); the arpeggione, a kind of bowed guitar, was invented in Vienna in 1814. It enjoyed only a brief vogue; and when the sonata was published in 1871 it already included an alternative cello part. How Schubert came into contact with the inventor Stauffer or his instrument is not known, but it shows the composer to have been friendly to new sounds. A compelling performance on an arpeggione today, although rare, shows that Schubert grasped immediately the instrument's plaintive, speaking quality. The soprano Anna Milder-Hauptman wrote at the end of the year offering to advance Schubert's operatic cause in Berlin. But when Schubert sent Alfonso und Estrella she rejected it, averring that she preferred a role for ‘a queen, a mother or a peasant’. Nonetheless, in June 1825 she performed Erlkönig and the second Suleika song (d717) in a public concert in Berlin, and Schubert later dedicated Der Hirt auf dem Felsen (d965) to her. The publications of 1824, although not voluminous, are substantial. They include the String Quartet in A minor, the only one of Schubert's string quartets to be published in his lifetime; the vocal quartet Gondelfahrer (d809); the song An den Tod (d518), Axa's Romanze from Rosamunde (d797/3b); and the song cycle Die schöne Müllerin, which was issued in three parts (February, March and August). He also contributed, as he had in 1822, to a collection of shorter piano pieces published for the holidays by Sauer & Leidesdorf. These later became nos.3 and 6 from his popular collection of Moments musicaux (d780). Schubert may have spent part of January 1825 in hospital, presumably undergoing treatment once again for secondary-stage manifestations of syphilis.
Schubert, Franz, §1: Life
