Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
UNITS 1, 2 The History, Origin and Principles o...docx
Скачиваний:
1
Добавлен:
01.05.2025
Размер:
267 Кб
Скачать
☆
  1. Discretionary; 2) to exceed; 3) to enhance; 4) to construe; 5) to withhold; 6) to encroach; 7) to usurp; 8) incentive

  1. to seize and hold (a position, office, power, etc.) by force or without legal right; to use without authority or right; employ wrongfully; to commit forcible or illegal seizure of an office, power, etc.; to encroach; to seize, take over, or appropriate without authority;

  2. available to be decided according to one’s own judgment; voluntary, arbitrary;

  1. to hold back;  to refrain from giving or granting; to restrain, check;

  2. to go beyond the limit or bounds of; to overstep, transcend;

  3. to give the meaning or intention of; to deduce by inference or interpretation;  to arrange or combine (words, phrases, etc.) syntactically; explain; interpret; infer;

  4. to advance beyond proper, established, or usual limits; make gradual inroads;

to usurp;

  1. to increase or improve in value, quality, desirability, or attractiveness; to raise to a higher degree; to intensify; magnify;

  2. something that encourages a person to do something or to work harder; encouragement,impetus, impulse, incitement, instigation, momentum, motivation,provocation, stimulant, stimulus;

2

b) Use the above words in the following sentences:

  1. Evidence that racial hatred was a motivation for a crime may be taken into account, and criminal sentence may be … because the defendant intentionally selected his victim on account of the victim’s race.

  2. “The Sixth Amendment … from federal courts, in all criminal proceedings, the power and authority to deprive an accused of his life or liberty unless he has or waives the assistance of counsel.”

  3. An act punishable by a fine of not more than $1,000 or imprisonment for not more than six months is a misdemeanor, which can be tried without indictment, even though the punishment … that specified in the statutory definition of ‘‘petty offenses.’’

  4. The Court, in upholding the power of federal judges to appoint private counsel to prosecute contempt of court actions, rejected the assertion that the judiciary … executive power in appointing such counsel.

  5. “Where the subject matter requires a uniform system as between the States, the power controlling it is vested exclusively in Congress, and cannot … by the State.”

  6. When a speech generates a perceived threat to public safety, the easiest police response may be to remove a speaker; yet, in such a case, opponents would have … to become violent if their actions would justify police action against a speaker, with serious consequences for the First Amendment freedom.

  7. In 1793, the Court unanimously refused to grant the request of President Washington and Secretary of State Jefferson … the treaties and laws of the United States pertaining to questions of international law arising out of the wars of the French Revolution.

  8. The actual exercise of appellate jurisdiction by the Supreme Court is one characterized by significant statutory discretion. Such … flexibility is not the rule for all other federal courts.

c) Translate the following sentences:

  1. The right to petition creates incentives and protections for individuals and groups to communicate, act politically, and seek political change – by conveying citizens’ opinions directly to governing officials, placing issues on the political agenda, and pressuring government to respond to political problems.

  2. State governments frequently offer tax reductions to businesses as an incentive to locate or to remain within the state. Some scholars warn that states are engaged in a “race to the bottom” as each one offers greater incentives, thereby reducing the tax revenues that fund government services.

  3. Certain state tax incentive programs have been found to violate the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution, which is intended to create a free trade area between and among the states.

  4. A tax incentive violates the commerce clause when it has the effect of providing lower tax rates to in-state businesses than those imposed on out-of-state ventures. Because such tax incentives do not directly conflict with congressional legislation under the commerce clause, they are said to violate the “dormant” or “negative” commerce clause.

  5. Although the Sentencing Commission was given significant discretionary authority “to determine the relative severity of federal crimes, to determine which crimes have been punished too leniently and which too severely,” Congress also gave the Commission extensive guidance in the Act, and did not confer authority to create new crimes or to enact a federal death penalty for any offense.

  6. During the 1980s, the courts were no more receptive to suits, many by Members of Congress, seeking to obtain a declaration of the President’s powers. The political question doctrine as well as certain discretionary authorities were relied on.

  7. Because conviction requires a two-thirds vote, this means that removal can occur only as a result of a two-thirds vote. Unlike removal, disqualification from office is a discretionary judgment, and there is no explicit constitutional linkage to the two-thirds vote on conviction. The Senate has determined that disqualification may be accomplished by a simple majority vote.

  8. The Marshall Court also invoked the supremacy clause to enhance national supremacy with respect to the states. In McCulloch v. Maryland, the Court ruled that a state tax on the Bank of the United States violated the supremacy clause.

  9. Even if the first trial is not completed, a second prosecution may be grossly unfair. It increases the financial and emotional burden on the accused, prolongs the period in which he is stigmatized by an unresolved accusation of wrongdoing, and may even enhance the risk that an innocent defendant may be convicted. Consequently, as a general rule, the prosecutor is entitled to one, and only one, opportunity to require an accused to stand trial.’’

  10. Due process tends to secure equality of law in the sense that it makes a required minimum of protection for every one’s right of life, liberty and property, which the Congress or the legislature may not withhold.

  11. The City of New York filed a lawsuit challenging Nixon’s refusal to spend appropriated monies for projects he did not support, and the Supreme Court ruled that presidents had no constitutional authority to withhold funds allotted by law.

  12. In collecting personal income taxes, most States require employers to deduct and withhold the tax from the wages of employees.

  13. Under a written constitution, which is law and is binding on government, the practice of judicial review raises questions of the relationship between constitutional interpretation and the Constitution – the law which is construed.

  14. The Ninth Amendment, which states that the “enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people,” clearly recognized that individuals had a list of natural rights that the government could not restrict.

  15. An ordinance making it a criminal offense for three or more persons to assemble on a sidewalk and conduct themselves in a manner annoying to passers-by was found impermissibly vague and void on its face because it encroached on the freedom of assembly.

  16. The courts ensure that the administration of the law neither unduly encroaches upon nor curtails the liberties of those being regulated.

  17. Critics argued that the Court had gone too far in striking down laws as unconstitutional. An ethic of judicial self-restraint no longer seemed operative, and the Supreme Court seemed to its critics to be usurping the powers of the elected legislatures by means of judicial subjectivism and thus looking to find ways to rationalize results that a majority on the Court held desirable.

  18. Section 2 of the Twenty-first Amendment of the U.S. Constitution grants states the power to set minimum drinking ages, and it is unconstitutional for the federal government to usurp this power with a condition on its funding.

  19. “The test may be stated as follows: what are the purpose and the primary effect of the enactment? If either is the advancement or inhibition of religion then the enactment exceeds the scope of legislative power as circumscribed by the Constitution.”

  20. A defendant who is prosecuted in a single proceeding for multiple petty offenses, however, does not have a constitutional right to a jury trial, even if the aggregate of sentences authorized for the offense exceeds six months.

TASK II. a) Choose the heading in the text under which the following passages fall; Justify your choice:

A. Separation of Personnel:

The Constitution requires different personnel (different people) in each of the three branches of the national government. The Constitution prohibits the practice of the same persons simultaneously holding office in two or more branches of the government. Before an officeholder in one branch of the national government can legally take office in another branch, he must first resign the office he is currently holding.

Examples of the application of this constitutional rule include the following:

An incumbent U.S. Senator runs for and is elected President. Before he can be inaugurated as President and assume the office, he must first resign his seat in the U.S. Senate.

The President wants to appoint a particular U.S. Representative to an important post in the Cabinet – say, Secretary of the Treasury. The President makes the appointment and the Senate confirms it. Before the Representative can take the executive office to which he has been appointed, he must resign his seat in the U.S. House of Representatives.

A U.S. Supreme Court justice, due to advanced age and declining health, announces his resignation, thereby creating a vacancy on the Court. The President appoints his Attorney General to fill the vacancy and the Senate confirms the appointment. Before the Attorney General can join the Supreme Court, he must resign his executive office – the office of Attorney General of the U.S.A.

B. Terms of Office Fixed, or Specified, in the Constitution.

The U.S. Constitution specifies the terms of office of national legislators, the chief executive, and members of the federal judiciary. The Constitution specifies two-year terms for U.S. Representatives, six-year terms for U.S. Senators, a four-year term for the President, and terms during good behavior for all federal judges.

What is the significance of this arrangement? The personnel in one branch of the government cannot be removed from office (before their terms expire) simply because they lose the support and favor of another branch. For example, the President does not have to resign his office if he loses the confidence or support of a simple majority (50.1 percent) in either house of Congress, or even in both houses.

C. Separate and Independent Election of the Chief Executive.

The Constitution mandates election of the President separately from and independently of the legislative branch. Every four years, congressional elections and the election of presidential electors are held at the same time and in the same polling places. However, the congressional elections on the one hand and the election of presidential electors on the other are entirely different sets of elections. The success of a presidential candidate at the polls is not dependent upon the success of his political party's candidates for seats in Congress. One party's candidate for President can win the presidential election, while the opposing party wins a majority of the seats in either one or both houses of Congress.

D. Coordinate Organs of Government:

The Constitution makes the three governmental branches coordinate organs of government. That is, they are constitutionally equal to each other in rank. No branch of the national government is constitutionally subordinate to another branch. In particular, neither of the two elective branches of government is subordinate to the other. Each elective organ – legislature or chief executive – is responsible (accountable, or answerable) to its own constituency, not to another elective organ of government.

TASK III. Match the following headings to the texts below:

  1. How the U.S. Courts Can Check and Restrain Congress and the President.

  2. How Congress Can Check and Restrain the President.

  3. How Congress Can Check and Restrain the U.S. Courts.

  4. How the President Can Check and Restrain Congress.

  5. How the President Can Check and Restrain the U.S. Courts.

a.  The President shares the national legislative authority with the two chambers of Congress. A legislative bill passed by the Senate and House of Representatives cannot become law without the President's consent and signature, unless, after the President has vetoed the bill and returned it to Congress, each of the two chambers, on a vote of reconsideration, marshals a two-thirds vote to pass the bill over the President's veto.

The President's power to veto national legislation is a very potent check on the power of Congress. The presidential veto is made potent by the utter difficulty of getting a two-thirds vote in the two houses of Congress to override the veto. For all practical purposes, the President is a third house of the national legislature.

b. Obviously, the power of Congress to override a presidential veto is a rather weak check on the President. However, there are other, more potent checks available that enable Congress to thwart and restrain the President. Congress can refuse to pass a a legislative bill desired by the President. Most importantly, Congress can refuse to appropriate funds requested by the President or any of the executive branch departments or agencies.

The Senate, deciding and deciding alone, without the necessity of House concurrence, can exercise some potent checks and restraints on presidential power. The Senate can refuse to confirm a presidential appointment and thereby prevent it from going into effect. One third of the Senate, plus one additional Senator, can block ratification of a treaty submitted by the President.

If extraordinary action is deemed necessary, Congress can institute impeachment proceedings against the President. In impeachment proceedings, the House of Representatives, by simple majority vote, brings an impeachment charge against the President. The Senate tries the President on the impeachment charge. If the Senate produces at least a two-thirds vote to convict the President of the crime or other act of misbehavior with which he is charged, he is removed from office and permanently barred from again holding any government office under the U.S. Constitution.

        c. Congress can check the federal courts by enacting laws which increase the size (membership) of the Supreme Court and reduce the Court's appellate jurisdiction and which change the number and jurisdiction of the lower federal courts.

The Senate can confirm or reject federal judges appointed by the President and thereby impact upon the membership and political philosophy of the federal judiciary.

When extraordinary action is deemed necessary, Congress can institute impeachment proceedings against federal judges, including Supreme Court justices.

        d. The President can join the two houses of Congress in checking and restraining the federal courts. How? By consenting to and signing congressional legislation increasing the size of the Supreme Court, reducing its appellate jurisdiction, and changing the number and jurisdiction of the lower federal courts.

When vacancies on the U.S. Courts occur, the President appoints federal judges, subject to Senate confirmation. In exercising this power, the President may have an impact upon the membership and political philosophy of the federal courts. However, this is not a strong check on the federal judiciary. Federal judges serve during good behavior and therefore enjoy the benefit of judicial independence. Once a judge has been appointed and the Senate has confirmed the appointment, the President has no control over the judge's decisions. A judge is answerable neither to the chief executive nor to the legislature for his decisions in cases coming before his court.

        e. The federal courts, through exercise of the power of judicial review, can check and restrain Congress and the President.

A federal court can declare unconstitutional and null and void a statute enacted by Congress. That is, the court can decline to uphold and enforce a congressional statute on the grounds that the statute is contrary to the U.S. Constitution.

A federal court can invalidate – i.e., set aside, declare illegal and of no force and effect -- a decision or action of the President or another federal executive officer on the grounds that the decision or action violates the Constitution or a federal statute.

TASK IV. a) Read and translate the following passages; Use them to define constitutional gov­ernment, limited government, republican government:

  1. On the inner workings of the Court, social scientists long have argued that political creatures inhabit the Court, that justices are not simply neutral arbiters of the law. Since 1789, the beginning of constitutional gov­ernment in the United States, those who have ascended to the bench have come from the political institutions of government or, at the very least, have affiliated with particular political parties.

  2. Former Supreme Court justice Thurgood Marshall, in reflecting during the bicentennial in 1987 on the Constitution and its opening three words remarked: “I do not believe that the meaning of the Constitution was forever “fixed” at the Philadelphia Convention. Nor do I find the wisdom, foresight, and sense of justice exhibited by the Framers particularly profound. To the contrary, the government they devised was defective from the start, requiring several amendments, a civil war, and momentous social transformation to attain the system of constitutional government, and its respect for the individual freedoms and human rights, we hold as fundamental today.

  3. Locke’s arguments in favor of individual rights, property, limited government, and the right of the people to hold their governors accountable to them, including through the threat of rebellion, appealed to the American founding generation, influencing not only the drafting of the Declaration of Independence, but also the Constitution.

  4. Modern writers, like English philosophers John Locke (1632–1704) and William Blackstone (1723–80), offered elaborate theories based on natural law, and both Locke and Blackstone influenced many American thinkers on matters relating to natural law, natural rights, individualism, the right of revolution, and the need for limited government.

  5. Locke explicitly linked the concept of natural law with advocacy of limited government and the right of revolution.

  6. In the United States, republicanism denotes limited government in the form of representative democracy. Citizens elect representatives who govern on their behalf, but within the constraints of the rule of law. Republican governments have nonhereditary leadership for fixed terms, are dependent upon the will of the people, and aim at promoting the collective public interest.

  7. Alexander Hamilton, in Federalist 84, described the prohibition of titles of nobility as being “the cornerstone of republican government,” noting that “so long as they are excluded there can never be serious danger that the government will be any other than that of the people.” In Federalist 85, Hamilton listed the prohibition as being among “the additional securities to republican government, to liberty, and to property.”

b) Describe the type of government existing in your country.

TASK V. a) Use bicameralism, unicameral, bicameral in the following sentences;

b) Translate the passages:

  1. The framers’ goal was to protect liberty, preserve popular government, and limit the threats of what we would now call the tyranny of the majority and the Constitution would secure these goals by setting up an elaborate machine that would use checks and balances, separation of powers, … , federalism, and self-interest to check political power.

  2. … is the principle that describes the division of power in the U.S. legislative branch between the House of Representatives and the Senate. … is provided for in Article I of the U.S. Constitution and is one of the many checks placed upon legislative power.

  3. … describes any legislature composed of two distinct chambers. The chambers, or houses, are often differentiated on the basis of their constituencies or method(s) of election or selection. A so-called lower house is normally directly elected by the general voting-age population, while the upper house may be appointed, directly elected, or indirectly elected. … , in the U.S. Constitution, provides for checks and balances of legislative authority by dividing its powers between the two houses, requiring concurrence in the passage of legislation while assigning unique authority to one chamber or the other, for example, ratification of treaties, confirmation of appointments, and origination of revenue bills.

  4. The governments of many countries utilize … parliaments, though some democratic nations operate under a … (single chamber) parliament, an example being the Knesset in Israel.

  5. The lengths of members’ terms differ by chamber, with lower-house delegates serving shorter terms (normally two years) and upper-house delegates serving longer ones (normally four to six years). When applied to governments in the United States, the U.S. Congress and 49 of the 50 states operate with … legislatures. Only Nebraska maintains a … legislature, a feature it implemented in 1937, championed by U.S. senator George W. Norris. The vast majority of local governments in the United States – cities, towns, boroughs, school districts, etc., – employ … bodies, such as city councils, boards, or commissions.

  6. Dividing a parliament into two chambers establishes an internal check on legislative powers. To pass a law, both chambers must agree on exactly the same language, which requires compromise between the houses, thereby greatly reducing extremist legislation. Critics of … legislatures argue that they are inefficient and easily stalemated by partisan politics.

  7. The … tradition in the United States may be traced to the British Parliament, which itself is a … institution. As each of the thirteen colonies in America established its government, many adopted the English model, although several, such as Pennsylvania, opted for a … body. The first U.S. constitution – the Articles of Confederation – created a … legislature in which each state, regardless of the size of its population or delegation to the congress, received one vote.

c) Describe the national legislature in your country.

TASK VI. Read the text to justify or question the existence of bicameralism:

Scholars have made a number of arguments to explain the emergence of bicameral legislatures. One of the most common arguments for the emergence of bicameralism in Britain and its American colonies is that it helped to preserve “mixed governments,” to ensure that upper class elements of society were protected (Wood, 1969; Tsebelis and Money, 1997). In such settings, bicameralism allowed the upper chamber, dominated by aristocrats, to have a veto on policy. More generally, an explicit role of some bicameral systems has been the protection of some minority who is overrepresented in the upper chamber.

A second rationale for bicameralism is the preservation of federalism. The United States, Germany, and other federal systems use a bicameral system in order to ensure the representation of the interests of individual states and provinces, as well as the population of the country. Under “federal bicameralism”, the lower house is typically apportioned on the basis of population, while the upper house is divided amongst the regional units. Some countries, such as the United States, provide equal representation for the states regardless of their population or geographic size, while others, like the Federal Republic of Germany, unequally apportion the upper chamber by providing additional representation to the larger units.

TASK VII. Discuss the text and add, if possible, any other issues arising from the doctrine:

Major issues under the doctrine of separation of powers

The major purpose of the doctrine of separation of powers is maintaining the constitutional allocation of powers. Consequently, its chief concerns are whether some branch is improperly exercising powers the Constitution has assigned to another branch; whether one branch is improperly inhibiting another branch’s legitimate exercise of its powers; and whether one or another branch is improperly enhancing power at the expense of another branch.

There are two major problems in this area of constitutional law. The first is that the Constitution does not define the powers that it confers on the branches of government. While perhaps everyone might agree on what is central to legislative or executive or judicial action, there are cases involving governmental activities difficult to characterize under these headings. The second problem arises out of the so-called fourth branch of government, the administrative agencies. Many administrative agencies exercise legislative, executive, and judicial powers, and there have been difficulties incorporating them into a rigorous scheme of separation of powers.

TASK VIII. Read the text to describe Madison’s concerns about the new Constitution:

For Madison the immediate and pressing question was whether the newly proposed Constitution would indeed make for safe government. There were, he confessed to Jefferson (no. 22), reasons to fault the plan. Though it represented an advance over the Articles of Confederation – "a Confederacy of independent States" – it still was not more than "a feudal system of republics." As such it was not adequate to secure the federal government against the encroachments of the states nor "to prevent instability and injustice in the legislation of the States." The remedy for Madison lay in a congressional power to veto state laws, a proposal he had steadfastly fought for in the Philadelphia Convention but to no avail. "It may be asked how private rights will be more secure under the Guardianship of the General Government than under the State Governments, since they are both founded on the republican principle which refers the ultimate decision to the will of the majority." Madison found the answer to that question in the very extent of the republic: its sheer size and heterogeneity made possible the benign application of that "reprobated axiom of tyranny," divide and rule. But if a large republic made it difficult for "oppressive combinations" to form, so too did it make it difficult for "a defensive concert" against administrative tyranny. Here the Constitution ought to be scrutinized to see whether the government it established has "sufficiently controlled itself, from setting up an interest adverse to that of the entire Society." Further detailed evidence of what Madison took to be the ingredients of a sufficiently controlled government may be gathered from his close critique of Jefferson's draft of a constitution for Virginia, observations written for the would-be founding fathers of Kentucky (no. 25).

TASK IX. Provide your arguments to agree or disagree with former Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall:

The Constitution of today is very different from the one written by the framers.

The document of 1787 was born of the politics of the times. It was a constitution written for an agrarian society fearful of central power. It was a constitution that provided for slavery and failed to guarantee explicitly the right to vote, and it was a document produced in an era well before the advent of the Internet, cell phones, cars, airplanes, and nuclear bombs. Moreover, as the historian Richard Hofstadter contended in The American Political Tradition, the men who wrote the Constitution went to Philadelphia with value-laden assumptions about human nature and theories of politics and economics that may be very different from the ones that many of us hold today. – Former Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall, (1987)

Richard Hofstadter (1916 – 1970) – an American historian and public intellectual of the mid-20th century. 

78

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]