- •Lecture 9: monopoly, oligopoly and competition
- •1. Monopoly
- •How Monopoly Is Maintained: Barriers to Entry
- •3. Legal barriers to entry.
- •2. Perfect Competition
- •1. Both buyers and sellers are price takers.
- •2. No influence.
- •3. The number of firms is large.
- •4. No barriers to entry.
- •5. Homogeneous product.
- •6. Instantaneous exit and entry.
- •7. Complete information.
- •8. Profit-maximizing entrepreneurial firms.
- •3. Imperfect Competition
- •Monopolistic Competition
- •Price Discrimination
- •Examples of Monopolistically Competitive Markets
- •4. Oligopoly
- •Concentration ratios
- •The Competitive Spectrum
- •1. Cartel
- •Forming a Cartel: Directions and Difficulties
- •Cartels and Technological Change
- •2. Implicit Price Collusion
- •3. Price war
- •4. The Contestable Market Model
- •Comparison of the Contestable Market Model and the Cartel Model
- •Other Oligopoly Models
- •1) Price leadership
- •2) Price Rigidity: The Kinked Demand Curve Model
- •3) Entry-Limit Pricing
- •Advertising under Oligopoly
- •Summary:
Cartels and Technological Change
Even if all firms in the industry cooperate, other firms, unless they are prevented from doing so, can always enter the market with a technologically superior new product at the same price or with the same good at a lower price. It is important to remember that technological changes are constantly occurring, and that a successful cartel with high profits will provide incentives for significant technological change, which can eliminate demand for its monopolized product. For example, record players gave way to cassettes and cassettes are giving way to CDs. Technologies are constantly changing, and as they do, industries, and the goods produced must change.
2. Implicit Price Collusion
In other cases the various firms meet, sometimes only by happenstance, at the golf course or at a trade association gathering, and arrive at a collective decision. In yet other cases the firms engage in implicit collusion—multiple firms make the same pricing decisions even though they have not explicitly consulted with one another.
Implicit price collusion, in which firms just happen to charge the same price but didn't meet to discuss price strategy, isn't against the law. Oligopolies often operate as close to the fine edge of the law as they can. For example, many oligopolistic industries allow a price leader to set the price, and then the others follow suit. The airline and steel industries take that route. Firms just happen to charge the same price or very close to the same price.
It isn't only in major industries that you see such implicit collusion. In small towns, you'll notice that most independent carpenters charge the same price. There’s no explicit collusion, but were a carpenter to offer to work for less than the others, she would feel unwelcome at the local breakfast restaurant. She would feel the pressure of the invisible handshake (social pressure).
3. Price war
A price war is a bout of continual price cutting by rival firms in a market. It's one of many possible consequences of oligopolistic rivalry. Price wars are great for consumers but bad for the profits of sellers.
4. The Contestable Market Model
The contestable market model is a model of oligopoly in which barriers to entry and barriers to exit, not the structure of the industry, determine a firm's price and output decisions. Thus, it places the emphasis on entry and exit conditions, and says that the price that an oligopoly will charge will exceed the cost of production and be dependent only on the entry and exit barriers to new firms. The higher the barriers, the more the price exceeds cost. If there are no barriers to entry or exit the price an oligopolist sets will be equivalent to the competitive price. Thus, an industry that structurally looks like an oligopoly could set highly competitive prices and output levels.
In a contestable market, even low profits will encourage new entrants. As the new entrants come in, supply increases and price falls to eliminate profits. Oligopolistic firms selling in such a market know they can gain little in the long run from using their monopoly power to raise prices. If they do raise prices, a new firm (such as a foreign supplier) may enter the market. The new firm can eventually become a major supplier, thus reducing the existing firm’s market share.
