- •Intellectual property on the internet: a survey of issues
- •Introduction
- •I. The internet and the development of the digital society
- •World Online Population
- •Cost of Internet Access
- •Developments in Means of Internet Access
- •Percentage of Individuals Purchasing Goods and Services over the Internet
- •Online Activities
- •Value of Commercial Transactions on the Internet
- •Percentage of Online Commercial Transactions Compared to Overall Commerce
- •Categories of Goods Purchased on the Internet
- •Distribution of Internet Sales between National and International Markets
- •II. The migration of intellectual property to the internet
- •III. (a) copyright and related rights
- •(I) introduction to digital copyright
- •(II) the wipo internet treaties
- •(A) Scope of Rights
- •(B) Enforcement and Management of Rights
- •(C) Status of the wipo Internet Treaties
- •(III) emerging copyright issues
- •(A) Scope of Copyright Protection in the Digital Environment
- •(B) Liability of Internet Service Providers
- •(C) Rights of Performers in a Digital Environment
- •(D) Rights of Digital Broadcasters
- •(E) Linking of Copyright Information Online
- •(F) Protection of Databases
- •(G) Peer-to-Peer File Sharing – Napster
- •(IV) licensing and rights management in the digital arena (a) Licensing and Collective Management of Rights
- •(B) Digital Rights Management
- •(C) Trends in Licensing and Rights Management
- •III. (b) trademarks and other rights in distinctive signs
- •(I) importance of trademarks online
- •(II) developments in use of trademarks online
- •(A) Use of Trademarks as Meta Tags
- •(B) Sale of Trademarks as Keywords
- •(D) Mousetrapping
- •(E) Linking and framing
- •(III) principle of territoriality and use of trademarks online
- •(A) Acquisition of Trademark Rights Through Use of a Sign on the Internet
- •(B) Infringement of Trademark Rights Through Use of a Sign on the Internet
- •(C) Acceptable Unauthorized Use
- •(D) Global Effect of Injunctions
- •(E) Enabling Co-existence of Rights on the Internet
- •(IV) wipo joint recommendation on protection of marks on the internet
- •(V) wipo joint recommendation on well-known marks
- •(VI) unfair competition
- •(A) Interactive Marketing Practices
- •(B) Transparency and Privacy Concerns
- •(C) National Versus International Standards of “Unfair” Marketing Practices
- •(D) Trade Secrets
- •III. (c) domain names
- •(I) introduction to domain names
- •(II) recent developments concerning domain names and intellectual property (a) New gTlDs
- •(B) Multilingual Domain Names
- •(C) Keywords
- •(D) Multiple Roots
- •(E) Creation of the Generic Top-Level Domain .Eu
- •(F) icann Reform
- •(G) World Implementation of the Enum Protocol
- •(III) wipo programs
- •(A) wipo Arbitration and Mediation Center
- •(B) Second wipo Internet Domain Name Process
- •(C) wipo Cooperation Program for ccTlDs
- •III. (d) patents
- •(I) patents in the digital environment
- •(A) Business Method Patents
- •(B) Software Patents
- •(C) Prior Art Effect
- •(D) Enforcement of Rights
- •(II) wipo programs
- •IV. The role of private international law and alternative dispute resolution
- •(I) private international law, intellectual property and the internet (a) What is Private International Law?
- •(B) Private International Law and the Internet
- •(C) Sources of Private International Law
- •(D) Private International Law, Harmonization and Intellectual Property
- •(E) Jurisdiction and Applicable Law in Intellectual Property Disputes
- •(II) alternative dispute resolution (a) What are the Methods of Alternative Dispute Resolution?
- •(B) The wipo Arbitration and Mediation Center
- •(C) General Characteristics of adr
- •(D) adr in e-Commerce
- •(E) adr, e‑Commerce and Intellectual Property
- •(F) adr and Legal Systems
- •(G) adr Limits and Challenges
- •(H) An Example: The wipo udrp Experience
- •(I) New Developments in adr
- •V. Issues for developing countries in the digital environment
- •(I) introduction
- •(II) ‘digital bridges’ over the digital divide
- •(III) access and participation in the digital economy
- •(IV) opportunities and challenges
- •(V) differential e-development
- •The Geography of Technological Innovation and Achievement undp Human Development Report 2001
- •(VII) wipo’s digital agenda in developing countries
- •(VIII) museums and images of cultural heritage online
- •(IX) traditional knowledge databases and digital libraries
- •VI. Digital delivery of intellectual property services
- •(I) developments in national intellectual property offices (a) Traditional Intellectual Property Office Administration
- •(B) Use of New Information Technology Systems in ip Offices
- •Japan Patent Office – Processing of Patent Applications
- •(II) wipo services
- •(A) wiponet
- •(B) The pct Treaty and Procedure
- •(C) The Madrid Agreement and Electronic Systems
- •(D) The Hague Agreement and Electronic Systems
- •VII. The wipo digital agenda
(II) wipo programs
255 WIPO has been addressing a number of issues in this area. Firstly, the Standing Committee on the Law of Patents (SCP) studied the desirability and feasibility of harmonizing rules concerning the patent law implications of the disclosure of technical information on the Internet, such as its impact on patentability.378 The discussion revealed that most of the countries recognize the prior art effect of information disclosed on the Internet under the general rules and practices applicable to the determination of prior art.379 Without any international harmonization with respect to the definition of prior art, it is apparent that the practices concerning the determination of the contents and timing of disclosures on the Internet vary from one Office to the other. Against this backdrop, the SCP agreed that in the first instance, it was necessary to establish general principles concerning prior art that would also cover the disclosure of information on the Internet under the Substantive Patent Law Treaty (SPLT). The Committee would, at a later stage, consider the need to establish special provisions specific to Internet disclosures in the Practice Guidelines under the SPLT.380
256 Secondly, the Patent Law Treaty (PLT) and the accompanying Regulations, which were adopted in June 2000, contain provisions for harmonization of the formal requirements concerning patent applications and patents which are applied by the industrial property offices of States and regional industrial property organizations.381 In relation to new methods for electronic administration, Article 8 and Rules 8 and 9 of the PLT and its Regulations, in particular, provide general rules relating to the filing of communications in electronic form or by electronic means using digital signatures, incorporating the requirements with respect to electronic filing under the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT).382
257 Thirdly, following the adoption of the PLT, the SCP initiated work on harmonization of substantive patent law in November 2000, namely, negotiations of the draft SPLT. The draft SPLT focuses, in principle, on issues of relevance for the grant of patents and validity of patents, such as the definitions of prior art, novelty, inventive step/non-obviousness and industrial applicability/utility, the drafting and interpretation of claims, the requirement of sufficient disclosure and patentable subject matter.383 Although still at an early stage of the negotiation, the SCP expressed its will to achieve deep harmonization, i.e., harmonization of legislation as well as of practices regarding the core issues of patentability and validity of patents.
IV. The role of private international law and alternative dispute resolution
258 The traditional method of resolving legal conflict - court litigation - is largely organized on a territorial basis. Each country has its own courts, which may be called upon to rule upon disputes falling under their jurisdiction, mostly on the basis of the application of local laws. This territorially based dispute resolution model faces a number of challenges when applied to disputes arising on the Internet, where activity occurs with little regard for physical boundaries. In the intellectual property context, if an entity uses a sign on the Internet in which it has secured trademark rights in its country of establishment, but which can be accessed by users anywhere in the world, does the entity run the risk of infringing rights in other jurisdictions? The laws of which jurisdictions should be relied upon to determine whether such infringement has occurred? And which courts should have jurisdiction to determine this?
259 Much attention has been brought in recent years to private international law and alternative dispute resolution as means of alleviating these complex issues that the Internet poses. The following sections of this Survey discuss the relationship between these branches of the law and intellectual property and how they can contribute to enhancing its protection on the Internet.
