Pacemakers, hourglasses and oscillators
An early researcher who caught my undergraduate imagination was Janet Harker of Cambridge, UK. From 1954 to 1956, Harker published papers in British journals on factors influencing diurnal rhythms in the locomotor activity of the cockroach Periplaneta americana (Harker 1954, 1956). She had been the first to show the participation of the endocrine system in the locomotor activity of an insect. She also reported results of exciting experiments in which cockroaches were made arhythmic in continuous light and then joined back-to-back in parabiosis with rhythmic cockroaches. The arhythmic member of the pair was mobile but the legs of the upper rhythmic member were removed. The locomotor activity of the mobile animal was then said to follow the circadian rhythm of the upper cockroach. She maintained that the pacemaking oscillator in the roach was housed in the sub-oesophageal gland. If she cooled the organ in situ for 4 h the clock was delayed for 4 h at all phases. Enthusiastic efforts by Shephard Roberts, a Ph.D. student of Pittendrigh at Princeton, failed to confirm Harker’s findings. The uneasy relationship between Harker and Pittendrigh is reflected in the discussion that followed her presentation in the Cold Spring Harbor Symposium of 1960. In her 1960 paper (Harker 1960) Harker referred to the work of just two other authors on biological rhythms; oddly, she did not cite her own review of 1958, among the earliest on diurnal rhythms (Harker, 1957). She did not straightaway endear herself to Pittendrigh by posing the question: can one can speak of a biological clock when one worked on eclosion rhythms in populations of pupae (as Pittendrigh did)? This was an unnecessary caveat since Pittendrigh had beautifully demonstrated the precision of the process of gating of the eclosion rhythm in D. pseudoobscura, which showed that the rhythms in individual flies were in synchrony. She also believed that her 4 h of delay at all phases of the rhythm of the roach was an “argument against regarding the rhythm as being dependent on a relaxation oscillator”. Many of Harkers findings have not been confirmed even though research on cockroach rhythms has flourished and is still in progress. Later Nishiitsutsuji-Uwo and Pittendrigh (1968) reported that the locus of the driving oscillation might be the optic lobe, a finding that has since been repeatedly confirmed.
The names of F A Brown Jr and J Harker were hardly ever mentioned even in passing in the weekly seminars of Bünning’s Botanisches Institut in Wilhelmstrasse in the period 1964-67 when I worked there. In fact even the views of A D Lees, who had demonstrated for the aphid Megoura viciae that the photoperiodic time measurement was being mediated by something much like an “hourglass”, were seldom critically discussed in Tubingen. This could have been the result of Bunning’s own attitude towards controversies, to steer clear of them. Like Medawar he preferred to avoid controversies of any kind. The organisers of an international meeting on Circadian Rhythmicity at Wageningen had invited both Lees and Bunning and were hoping there would be animated discussion between those who subscribed to the ‘hourglass’ hypothesis and the others who subscribed to the ‘endogenous oscillations’ hypothesis. Lees spoke reverentially of Professor Bunning’s hypothesis but concluded that the aphids may be in a separate class in themselves. Bunning had earlier given the chairman’s address and sat impassively in the front row. The chairman of this session, de Wilde, asked, “Does Professor Bünning have anything to say?”. Bunning replied “I have extensively written and spoken about the role of circadian rhythms in photoperiodism. As for Lees’ findings, I believe them, and nature has certainly more ways than just one, to solve problems.” Interestingly, it was Lees who displayed a slide of the Bunning model—not Bunning—showing the phase relationships of the hypothetical rhythm of light sensitivity under long and short day conditions (Lees 1971).
