Development
Once more, a critical success factor is scale, expressed most importantly as the ability to view development as a program rather than as a series of independent projects. As a program, companies can install continuous improvement mechanisms to learn from successes and failures and take on controlled experiments that would not be possible for a single project. Process discipline is very important, particularly in assuring proper front end loading and in having the "right people doing the right things". Supply chain management is a vital contributor to lower costs, but win-win partnership models are proving elusive.
Chevron's experience in Indonesia has been that the primary lever to help control costs has been to leverage scale at every level by working with the Indonesian government to combine three projects into an investment program, allowing standard design and better contracting leverage with suppliers. For example, this will allow the company to take on one rig for four years, mobilize it only once and work on continuous improvement through repeatable ongoing programs. The drillers will come to know all the well procedures, lowering risk of mishaps and improving safety. It will also allow some experimentation with the knowledge that successes can be applied to up to twenty future wells while failures will themselves provide learnings. In this way, three separate projects are turned into a single program, allowing relationships with suppliers and internal collaborators to mature and develop.
A second lever is good process discipline especially proper front end loading, making sure the reservoir is fully understood before designing the drilling and facilities programs to be sure that the right platforms are built with optimized design to handle the likely volumes. It can be very expensive to end up with an oversized or undersized platform. Front end loading also reduces the risk of expensive change orders.
A third lever coming from the CHPDP1 process is its feature of allocating QA/QC reviews to peer groups of technical experts with no stake in the outcome, allowing the leader to focus on strategic issues and relationships. It also assures structured decision making and information transparency. The process alone is not sufficient however. There is also a "premium on quality project management" to make the most of the structure and transparency.
A fourth lever is the development of advantaged relationships with suppliers. As projects can be disaggregated into "information, decisions and relationships", well structured, long-term supplier relationships are a key to capturing and retaining the scale benefits. Relationship strategies are ideally formed at corporate levels, or at least across regions that correspond to coherent market areas for the industry. Finally, it is important to develop options: Plan A must be worked up in detail, but alternative routes - commercial as well as technical - must also be investigated in case Plan A is blocked.
Cobalt plans to be in a position to move on to development when this maximizes the value of the asset, but using the same model as for exploration of a small team of outstanding people, in this case a few world class project managers who can draw from a world class network of suppliers based on personal experience and relationships. They will be in a position to identify and insist on the suppliers' "A teams". The fact is that a few great people will attract other high performers, both inside and outside the company. With world class project managers, sub-surface professionals, standard and repeatable development solutions and hand picked suppliers, the chances of errors in design and execution will be much reduced.
HighMount finds that development is where the real heavy lifting takes place that determines the success of a resource play. The key is to settle on a suite of technologies early so they can be employed routinely and repeatably albeit with an ongoing focus on allowing for innovative opportunities to create additional value through evolving and new technologies. Management rigorously measures results and creates opportunities to reduce cycle time and cost reductions through learning-based continuous improvement. This requires new and different thinking and metrics -e.g. monitoring the time to move rigs wouldn't normally be a focus but becomes important when considering total program productivity. Further, the company deliberately tries new ideas on about 3 percent of its wells to test theories of better ways to drill and complete wells and fracture the formation. The aim is to optimize the whole system around continuous adjustment of drilling techniques and schedules and to try to reframe the relationship with suppliers to allow win-win opportunities to align both parties around continuous improvement of the whole system.
This requires a supplier infrastructure to be in place and also competition among suppliers. In the Rockies, this infrastructure is weak, as well as the physical infrastructure to deliver the gas to market. Currently the relationship between operators and suppliers is not ideal and tends to be particularly adversarial in drilling. Both suppliers and users tend to view relationships as "win/lose" and it is quite difficult to change attitudes to secure a proper "win-win" outcomes. HighMount has not been as successful as desired to date in establishing appropriate performance contracts. Yet current plans call for a continuous drilling program in Sonora for at least 25 years, so it is vital to establish a shared understanding of what the operator is trying to do, to align goals, and address performance issues to enable continuous improvement of all processes. For unconventional gas, the critical competence is really program management rather than project management, thinking of the exploitation program as a system that must be continuously tuned and improved for success.
ConocoPhillips also highlights the need for different thinking and metrics in the evolving oil sands program and believes that innovation will play a key role in determining the ultimate economic success of the oil sands. Fort McMurray, the center of the oil sands industry, is land locked and lacks a local population base to provide skilled workers. Consequently, costs for similar investments can be two to three times the levels found in more mature
Chevron Process for Development Projects (CHPDP)
industry centers. Much of the investment required to monetize oil sands is for above ground facilities. Steam generation and water treatment are major investments during the development phase, followed by the necessary infrastructure to import diluent or build upgraders to produce a synthetic crude diluent. Then export infrastructure has to be built to transport the bitumen blend to distant refineries where the blend is converted into finished products salable into liquid commodity markets. Because of the inability to benefit from sea-lift of heavy equipment, there are some limits to the scale economies found by conventional process plants in established industry centers and there may be benefits in designing repeatable, modular smaller units rather than huge single trains. Similarly, there will be opportunities for continuous improvement of drilling programs as each 30KBD SAGD2 project will require 40-50 wells and the industry in aggregate is projecting up to 3 MMBD of insitu production.
For all facilities located in Fort McMurray there will remain a serious shortage of skilled labor that will require continuing use of temporary labor forces. Some companies have been more successful than others in bringing in temporary labor from diverse international sources and integrating them with the more permanent work force on site.
SAGD2 operations will be very different by 2025 as new technologies such as solvents being injected with the steam lower the steam-oil ratio and improve the recovery; perhaps new sources for steam will appear on the horizon such as geothermal or even nuclear energy being deployed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. With this backdrop in place ConocoPhillips has stepped up its research effort in areas such as carbon capture and sequestration, as well as expanding its heavy oil research capabilties by building a world class thermal PVT lab at their R&D center in Bartlesville. The lab will provide a platform for a myriad of experiments aimed at optimizing the steam flood and maximizing the recovery. The most promising ideas will then be piloted and field tested in existing oil sands operations.
