- •10 Generating Concepts
- •I. Chapter road map
- •II. Concept generation process
- •III. Basic methods: information gathering and brainstorming
- •Information Gathering: Conventional Aids
- •Traditional Brainstorming
- •Brain-Ball
- •Systematic Search with Physical Principles
- •Idea Generators for Intuitive Techniques
- •IV. Advanced methods: directed search
- •Systematic Search with Classifying Schemes
- •Theory of Inventive Problem Solving
- •V. Morphological analysis
- •Develop Concepts for Each Product Function
- •VI combining solution principles (concept variants) Product Application: Bilge Water Removal Product
- •Product Application: Smart Spoon to Assist Persons with Disabilities
- •VII. Summary and «golden nuggets"
Idea Generators for Intuitive Techniques
Any intuitive method can become stalled by biases in the direction that ideas are being pursued (Adams; DeBono; Gordon). Such methods can also stall due to the working environment or the personality types of the individuals creating the ideas. To overcome any stagnant times during concept generation, idea generators may be applied to redirect the search for ideas. Table 10.3 lists a number of idea generators that may be used with any of the intuitive methods. They may also be used by a group or an individual. These idea generators help to break down conceptual blocks by refocusing the group or individual along a different train of thought. To apply the generators, a keyword or activity is stated, followed by a questioning period about the keyword or activity. New ideas are pursued using the same procedure and guidelines for the intuitive method. When ideas become exhausted for a given generator, a new one is stated, and the process repeats.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yAidvTKX6xM
IV. Advanced methods: directed search
Directed-search or logical concept generation methods are used to develop ideas in a deliberate, step-by-step, comprehensive fashion. Direction is provided by design or physical principles that are previously known. These principles, in conjunction with knowledge of physical effects and technology, drive the process toward particular types of solutions. Let's consider three directed-search approaches: generating ideas from physical principles, using classifying schemes, and implementing the Theory of Inventive Problem Solving (TIPS or TRIZ).
Systematic Search with Physical Principles
For a given functional model of a product, product functions are connected by flows of materials, energies, and signals (information). Each function transforms a flow or set of flows to a new state. This transformation represents a physical process that is governed by physical principles.
Instead of relying on intuitive methods exclusively, we can state possible physical principles that can govern a product function or set of functions. Suppose we have a known physical effect described by a known equation. Then we know the number and type of independent variables. These variables can be studied closely to generate concepts based on variation of each parameter in a methodical way.
E
xample
Consider the function of "sense rotational speed" for a product application. A possible physical effect that can apply is a capacitive parallel plate system, governed by the relationship:
Figure 10.9 illustrates a systematic search of the variables that can change the capacitance. A change of voltage will result from any of the variable changes. The magnitude of this change represents the detected quantity by the product function.
Three variants are considered. The first varies the distance, d, between the plates. This displacement is inversely proportional to the capacitance, C. By considering this change, we arrive at solutions that are equivalent to microphone transducers. The second variable is the material property, B, between the two plates. If we gradually introduce a solid between the two plates (Figure 10.9), the voltage, e, changes, as detected by a change in capacitance. This change is equivalent to slot effect transducers. The third variable is the incident area, A, of the plates. By moving one plate relative to the other, the area changes, resulting in a voltage change. This change can represent reciprocating or rotational changes of the input on the upper plate (Figure 10.9). We then have an idea for a rotational detection device to satisfy the product function. This device is a capacitive tachometer (when combined with a processor that records and calculates the change as a function of time).
