- •Innovation
- •Innovation
- •A Fight to the Photo-Finish
- •Strategy Innovation Goes Beyond Product Innovation
- •Strategy Innovation as a Strategic Advantage
- •Strategy Innovation as a Source of Corporate Renewal
- •Summary
- •The Corporate Dilemma of the Current Business vs. The Future Business
- •Future Incompetence
- •Assumptions About the Future
- •Industry Turbulence
- •3. The future is not one-size-fits-all, it is proprietary.
- •Future Business Opportunities Will Drive a New Corporate Strategy
- •Portfolio of New Business Opportunities: a Valuable, Intangible Strategic Asset
- •Who Is Minding the Future?
- •Summary
- •Market-Centric
- •Heuristic
- •Strategic Planning Process Strategy Innovation Process
- •Strategy Innovation and then Strategic Planning
- •Chapter Summary
- •What Is the Discovery Process?
- •Size of Company
- •Size of Industry
- •Type of Industry
- •Strategic Frontier
- •Degree of Innovation Required
- •Strategy Innovation by Degrees: Strategic Opportunity Spectrum
- •Key Elements for Strategy Innovation
- •Risks Involved in the Discovery Process
- •Type of Company to Benefit from Strategy Innovation
- •Summary
Strategy Innovation as a Source of Corporate Renewal
Strategy innovation is often considered the calling card of startup companies looking to enter already-existing markets. However, established companies also use strategy innovation to their advantage, if they have the instinct for it. We recognize this instinct as a strong, internal emphasis on corporate ‘‘renewal.’’ The instinct for renewal is something beyond a cultural norm; it seems to be embedded in the organization’s DNA, what it sees when it looks in the mirror. These companies are never completely satisfied with who they are today, but are more interested in who they are becoming.
Companies such as Procter & Gamble, IBM, and Nokia have not experienced their sustained success by merely evolving. They have taken bold, strategically innovative steps at critical points in their histories to redefine who they were. How else does one explain the radical shift in the business of these companies from their origins? Procter & Gamble was once exclusively a soap manufacturer. At one point in their history, IBM made scales and cheese slicers. Before Nokia was in mobile phones, they were a paper products company. These companies are more concerned with their future than their past. They are proactive. They believe that corporate renewal is healthy, if not critical to their ongoing survival and success. All have confidence that they will still be in business in 2050 without believing it will be the same business they are in today.
Companies with an instinct for renewal as part of their corporate DNA are not on a treadmill. They are vigilant in the examination of their business peripheries, expecting the boundaries to change as the marketplace changes. And, when more radical opportunities present themselves, they are poised to respond. That is how a soap manufacturer becomes successful in the pet food business, how a producer of cheese slicers wins Nobel Prizes for physics, and how a paper products company becomes a world-beater in wireless communications. They expect to renew through strategy innovation and, in the process, be more vital tomorrow than they are today.
Summary
_ Strategy innovation is shifting a corporation’s business strategy in order to create new value for both the customer and the corporation.
_ Strategy innovation is a process of applying innovative thinking to the entire business model of a company, not just to its products or inventions.
_ Strategy innovation is the process of finding a way to ‘‘change the rules of the game’’ so that your company’s products, competencies, and assets provide you with a competitive advantage in the marketplace.
_ While strategy innovation may be critical for success (or survival) in dynamic markets, it can also be a source of competitive advantage in more stable markets.
_ Established companies with an instinct for corporate renewal use strategy innovation to remain vital and relevant over time.
_ Strategy innovation can provide new growth prospects for companies in any marketplace and should be a capability, if not a core competence, of every company hoping to survive in the dynamic business world of the twenty-first century.
Chapter 2
S TRATEGY INNOVATION I S MANAGING THE FUTURE
There are always two parties—the party of the Past and the party of the Future; the Establishment and the Movement.
—RALPHWALDO EMERSON
When do you know that you need strategy innovation? In most cases, it is when the projection of revenues for future products and services does not add up to the company’s growth targets. When this happens, business leaders scramble around to find ways to address this ‘‘delta,’’ the difference between the revenues they expect to generate and the revenues they need to generate (see Figure 2-1).
The Dreaded Delta and the Spiral of Incrementalism
The knee-jerk reaction to this revenue-target dichotomy is to pull together a team of people to brainstorm some new product ideas or acquisition targets to fill the dreaded revenue delta. Over the years, creativity in the form of brainstorming events has earned its reputation as a viable method of creating incremental new product and service ideas in corporations. However, the problem with many brainstorming efforts is that they are done within the context of the base brand or current business and tend to produce only line extension opportunities or incremental product improvements. They take current products and make them slightly more powerful, slightly more colorful, or slightly longer-lasting (at a slightly higher price). Often, these slightly better line-extension products can help fill the revenue delta, as long as the delta is not too big.
Figure 2-1. The dreaded delta.
After years of creating line extensions to fill revenue gaps, corporations often evolve into ‘‘institutions of incrementalism.’’ This is particularly true in companies that have had a successful product or brand on the market for many years. Whenever additional revenue is needed, a new line extension of the current product is introduced. With a strong brand, it is not too difficult to introduce a successful line-extension product. The line extension can usually use the same manufacturing facilities, the same distribution system, and the same sales force as the base brand, minimizing incremental costs. Because it leverages a known brand name, market acceptance is likely, and additional revenues (from the slightly higher price) are almost certain. Because it is similar to other products produced by this business system, the process for getting it to market is relatively easy, fast, and problem-free. A downside to leveraging the base brand through line extensions is the relatively low incremental revenue that results, as cannibalization of the base brand will account for some of the additional revenue.
Meanwhile, the business systems of the company adapt to this strategy of growth through incrementalism. We worked with a company once that had become a victim of its line-extension success. Its operations had become more efficient around dealing with line extensions, but less flexible in their abilities to accommodate new and unique products. Financial controls and hurdle rates for new products were set to the attractive level of line extensions, making it difficult for new products requiring additional costs or investment spending to be approved for development. The corporate culture, which rewarded people who quickly brought new line extensions to market, was less patient when nonincremental products had a longer time frame or required more attention or problem solving to develop. When this happened, the company became caught in a spiral of incrementalism. It had become very efficient at developing low-volume, high-profit line extensions, and the internal systems prevented it from identifying, developing, or introducing significantly new products and services to the market. The company had lost its ability to significantly grow the business.
As long as the base brand remains vibrant with growth potential in the marketplace, the spiral of incrementalism can be an efficient and profitable way to run the business. If the brand saturates the market, the market undergoes some change, or the brand loses some of its previous vitality, growth slows, and the dreaded delta appears. Richard Foster and Sarah Kaplan, in their book Creative Destruction, write, ‘‘The reason IBM stumbled was that something was wrong with John Akers’s view of the world—with his mental model. Akers believed in continuity in gradual, incremental change. But the world had become discontinuous.’’1 When this happens, it is time to find a new growth platform for the company, a new ‘‘engine’’ to drive future revenues and profits. Akers’s successor at IBM, Lou Gerstner, was successful in doing that and, as a result, was able to save the computing giant from break-up or collapse. By refocusing the company’s expertise on computing services and its patents on technology licensing, Gerstner created significant new business platforms that will continue to drive growth in IBM’s future.
