Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
PA&M Unit 1 new (2).docx
Скачиваний:
1
Добавлен:
01.07.2025
Размер:
99 Кб
Скачать
☆

Wilson and Political Control

In the traditional model of public administration, the rules linking the political leadership with the bureaucracy are clear, at least in theory. Woodrow Wilson – a Professor at Princeton for many years before becoming United States President – argued that there should be a strict separation of politics from the administration; of policy from the strictly administrative task of carrying it out. As he argued in 1886:

Administration lies outside the proper sphere of politics. Administrative questions are not political questions. …Public administration is detailed and systematic execution of public law. Every particular application of general law is an act of administration. The assessment and raising of taxes, for instance, the hanging of a criminal, the transportation and delivery of the mails, the equipment and recruiting of the army and navy, etc., are all obviously acts of administration, but the general laws which direct these things to be done are obviously outside of and above administration. The broad plans of governmental action are not administrative; the detailed execution of such plans is administrative.

Wilson believed that the evils of the spoils system resulted from the linking of administrative questions with political ones. If administrators act in an overtly political manner, whether due to the process by which they were appointed, or their continuing role within the party organization, corruption is likely to result and arbitrary decisions almost certain. Separation of the political sphere, where policy derives, from the administrative sphere, where policies are administered, could address many evils of the spoils system.

Traditional public administration elevated the distinction between administrative and political matters to its guiding principle – that of politics/administration dichotomy. The dichotomy between politics and administration allowed room for a new criterion for public action, based on the insertion of professionalization, expertise, and merit values into the active direction of government affairs.

The traditional system of administration in parliamentary countries similarly aimed for a separation of policy from administration. There are three main facets to political control in the traditional model of administration, most notably in Westminster systems1. First, there is a clear relationship between accountability and responsibility. A department or agency has two basic roles: to advise the political leadership on the development, review and implementation of policy, and to manage its own resources so that policy may be implemented. Each public servant is technically accountable, through the hierarchical structure of the department, to the Cabinet, and eventually to the people. Second, there should be a strict separation between matters of policy, which are formally the province of politicians, and matters of administration, which are left to the public service. Third, the administration is presumed to be anonymous and neutral, that is, not personally associated with any decisions or policies that are carried out only in the name of the minister; and non-partisan in the party-political sense and able to serve equally to any political leader. Westminster systems added the formal system of ministerial responsibility. If ministers accept personal responsibility for all the activities of their departments, public servants should remain anonymous and not publicly identified with the advice they give to ministers. In return for serving ministers from whatever party to the best of their ability, that is, for acting impersonally and objectively, public servants receive certain benefits in their conditions of service, such as security of employment, despite changes of government, and a decent pension.

In the traditional model of administration, the worlds of the politician and the public official were to be separate. Although the theory of separation – of dichotomy – between politics and administration was a major part of the traditional model of administration, it was, for many years, widely regarded as a myth, especially useful for the evasion of responsibility. In reality, the two are effectively ‘fused with politicians performing administrative duties and administrators assuming political responsibilities’ (Caiden, 1982). It was a fantasy to assume that politicians and administrators could be separate, but bureaucratic structures were constructed as though the myth was reality.

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]