The Policy Evaluation Process
Elites receive feedback regarding the effects of government policies along the same paths outlined in our top-down policymaking model (see figure 1.1, p. 5). The policy evaluation process is finding out about the effects, if any, of public policy. It is determining whether these effects are those intended and whether the effects are worth the costs of the policy. Governments themselves sometimes undertake policy evaluation. But top-down policy evaluation occurs when elites themselves directly discern policy effects from the information they receive from the institutions they themselves control; or when they receive reports about the effectiveness of government policies from the interest groups, think tanks, and foundations they sponsor; or when the mass media reports on policy effectiveness, or more likely its ineffectiveness, waste, inefficiency, or corruption.
The Bottom-Up Policy Process Model
The top-down policy model stands in sharp contrast to traditional descriptions of the policymaking process. The prevailing model of policymaking in American political science is a popularly driven, "bottom-up" portrait of decision making. This "democratic-pluralist" model assumes that in an open society such as ours any problem can be identified by individuals or groups and brought into the political process for discussion, debate, and resolution. Citizens can define their own interests, organize themselves, persuade others to support their cause, gain access to government officials, influence decision making, and watch over the implementation of government policies and programs.
A variety of democratic institutions are said to facilitate this upward flow of citizen influence. Interest groups, political parties, candidates seeking election to office, and the mass media are all portrayed as responding to popular concerns (see figure 1.2).
Most Americans are skeptical of the bottom-up process. They do not believe that the government pays much attention to their policy views or that it understands their problems very well. They believe that "the government is run by a few big interests looking out for themselves." And they believe that members of Congress should pay more attention to public opinion polls. Nevertheless, we want to briefly describe the bottom-up model for the purposes of comparing with the top-down model.
POLICY OUTCOMES |
|||||||
Welfare |
Health |
Education |
Defense |
Trade |
Immigration |
Law Enforcement |
Taxation |
GOVERNMENT Implementation and Evaluation Legitimation Formulation Agenda Setting Problem Identification |
Interest Groups |
Political Parties |
Candidates Election |
Mass Media |
CITIZENS AND VOTERS |
Figure 1.2 Bottom-Up Policymaking
