Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
international fin. operations.doc
Скачиваний:
0
Добавлен:
01.04.2025
Размер:
6 Мб
Скачать
☆

International Long-Term Portfolio Investment

11.1 OVERVIEW

International long-term portfolio investment is investment in long-term secu­rities (bonds and equity) denominated in various currencies. The secondary equity markets of the world (also called stock markets or share markets) serve two purposes by providing marketability and equity valuation. Investors or traders who buy shares from the issuing firm in the primary market may not want to hold them indefinitely: the secondary market allows share owners to reduce their holdings of unwanted shares and purchasers to get the shares. Firms will have a difficult time attracting buyers in the primary market without the marketability provided through the secondary market. Competi­tive trading in the secondary market establishes fair market prices for existing issues.

International portfolio investment has, since the 1980s, been going through spectacular growth, which can be attributed to the following reasons:

  1. Deregulation of financial markets.

  2. The desire of international investors to improve performance, which can be accomplished via international diversification that enables them to obtain a better risk-return combination.

  3. The advent of floating exchange rates. While floating rates produce more risk, they also provide an opportunity for a better risk-return combination. The exchange rate factor can contribute significantly to the overall base currency rate of return.

  4. The incorporation of the academic literature on international portfolio diversification in the strategies of portfolio managers. Most of the academic research has become more concerned with practical issues, as academics strive to win consultancy work from financial institutions.

  5. Modernisation and increased competitiveness of stock exchanges. For example, the New York Stock Exchange switched from fixed to flexible

commissions in 1975. In London there was the Big Bang in the 1980s that made the London Stock Exchange truly international. In general, there has been competition between stock exchanges to attract listings.

  1. The development of technology and online trading has made it easier to buy and sell foreign securities .

  2. The trend towards more disclosure and provision of information.

  3. Expanded pool of liquidity. The growth of the Eurocurrency market and national money markets has led to an expanded international pool of liquidity that is available for international investors, enhancing their ability to finance portfolios.

A question may arise here as to why international investment would need such a diversified menu of factors to grow, in the sense that the diversification benefit of international portfolio investment could be adequate to propel growth. However, international portfolio investment is different from domestic portfolio investment in many respects. The following are some of these differences:

    1. Differences in risk and perceptions of risk, including business risk, economic risk and liquidity risk. Furthermore, international investment is subject to foreign exchange risk.

    2. Differences in market mechanisms, which can be an obstacle to investment. For example, some markets are illiquid, whereas others are characterised by a concentration of activity. Furthermore, some stock exchanges do not have a trading monopoly, and there are invariably differences in the settlement and how long it takes. Typically, there are some differences in transaction costs and government regulations.

    3. Differences in the availability and quality of available information, including disclosure.

    4. Differences in accounting standards, which arise from (i) lack of agreement on the objectives of financial standards; (ii) different requirements under the company laws of individual countries; (iii) differences in tax laws; and (iv) differences in the development of the local professional bodies. Specific differ­ences in accounting standards pertain to consolidation practices, disclosure, foreign exchange accounting, auditing and accounting for inflation.

11.2 INVESTMENT IN BONDS

The secondary bond market

The secondary bond market comprises market makers and brokers connected by an array of telecommunication equipment. Market makers stand ready to buy and sell for their own accounts by quoting two-way bid and ask (offer) prices. Market makers trade directly with one another, through a broker, or

with retail customers, but electronic trading (online trading) is making grounds at the expense of more traditional trading.

Market makers tend to be the same investment banks, merchant banks and commercial banks that serve as lead managers in an underwriting of bond issues. Brokers accept buy or sell orders from market makers, attempting to find a matching party for the other side (they may also trade for their accounts). Brokers charge a small commission for their services to the market maker that engages them. They do not deal directly with retail clients.

Secondary market transactions require a system for transferring ownership and payment from one party to another. A clearing system would have a group of depository banks that physically store bond certificates. When a transaction is conducted, book entries are made to transfer the ownership of the bond certificates from the seller to the buyer and transfer funds from the buyer's cash account to the seller's account. Physical transfer of the bond seldom takes place.

Bonds are fixed-income securities that are regarded to be attractive invest­ment vehicles by international investors. The following are some features of the bond market:

      1. The world bond market is larger than the world stock market, offering sought-after opportunities for large institutional investors.

      2. Bond markets are driven by a somewhat different mix of factors than stock markets. Therefore there are different timing patterns.

      3. Bond markets offer opportunities for selective risk reduction (currency risk, sectoral risk), as well as broader portfolio risk reduction.

      4. Investment in bonds can be combined with programmes aimed at currency risk neutralisation via currency derivatives.

      5. Bond markets offer investors favourable liquidity due to high volume.

Currency denomination of bond investments

Let us for simplicity of exposition assume that we are dealing with investment in zero coupon bonds. If a bond with a face value Vt+n and maturity of n years is bought at time t at a price Pt and held until maturity, then the bondholder will at year n receive the face value Vt+n. The annual compound rate of return, r, on this bond investment can be calculated from the equation

Pt (1 + r)n = Vt+ n (11.1)

in which case r is given by

(v ^1/n v t+ n

Pt 0

r =

-1 (11.2)

In general, if a base currency amount, K, is invested for n years in a domestic bond (or a domestic bond portfolio) offering an implicit rate of return, rx, then the value of the investment after n years is given by

Ix,t+ n = K(1 + )n (11.3)

We could derive a similar expression for a foreign currency bond investment. The base currency amount, K, is converted into the foreign currency at the spot exchange rate prevailing at time t, St, to obtain K/St units of the foreign currency. This amount is then used to buy foreign currency-denominated bonds offering an annual rate of return of ry. The foreign currency amount accumulated after n years is obtained by compounding the initial amount at ry to obtain K/St(1 + ry)n. The base currency value of this investment at year n, I*x t+n, is obtained by converting the foreign currency amount into the base currency at the spot exchange rate prevailing at year t + n, St+n, to obtain

St+ n St

n

(11.4)

Ix,t+ n = K(1 + ry )

We could express the ratio of the exchange rate at t + n to the exchange rate at year t, St+n/St, in terms of the average annual rate of change in the exchange

rate, S, as follows

S

= (1 + S)n (11.5)

St

Therefore

I*xft+ n = K(1 + ry )n(1 + S)n (11.6)

Now we are in a position to make a choice between investing in base currency- denominated bonds and foreign currency-denominated bonds. Assuming risk neutrality (in the sense that the investor is indifferent between the two invest­ments if they offer the same return) foreign currency-denominated bonds will be preferred if fx,t+ n > Ix,t+ n, or if

K(1 + ry )n(1 + S)n > K(1 + rx )n (11.7)

which can be approximated, by working out the expression and ignoring the small cross products, to

S > rx - ry (11.8)

Equation (11.8) says that investment in foreign currency-denominated bonds will be preferred if the foreign currency is expected to appreciate by more than the difference between the rates of return on base currency-denominated bonds and foreign currency-denominated bonds. The equation also implies that foreign currency-denominated bonds will be preferred even if they offer a lower rate of return than domestic currency-denominated bonds, provided that the foreign currency appreciates by more than the differential return, rx - ry.

It is important to bear in mind that the two rates of return (rx and ry) are known at time t if the bonds are held until maturity, since the coupon

payments and the face values are known in advance. However, the change in the exchange rate is not known in advance, in which case the investor has to act on the basis of the expected change in the exchange rate. At t + n, the value of the change in the exchange rate is realised, at which time the investor can determine, ex post, whether or not the right decision was made at time t.

The effect of taxes

We now compare the after-tax returns on domestic currency and foreign currency bond investments. Two kinds of taxes are relevant to the return on bond investment: income tax and capital gains tax. Income tax is applied to interest income, whereas capital gains tax is applied to capital gains. If the bonds are held until maturity, then the return on base currency-denominated bonds takes the form of interest income, which makes this return subject to income tax only. The return on foreign currency-denominated bonds consists of interest income and the appreciation of the foreign currency, which occurs when the exchange rate rises (St+n > St). Hence the return on foreign- currency denominated bonds is subject to capital gains tax in addition to income tax. The condition represented by (11.8) can be modified to take into account the effect of taxes, to the following:

(1 -tg)S > (1 -tn )rx -(1 -tn )ry (11.9)

where t g is the capital gains tax applicable to foreign exchange gains and t n is the income tax rate applicable to interest income. For the time being, we will assume that the domestic and foreign tax rates are identical. By manipulating equation (11.9) we obtain the following rule: foreign currency-denominated bonds will be preferred if

1 -t

s > —^ (rx - ry ) (11.10)

1 -t g y

If t g < t n, then (1 -1 n )/(1 -1 g) < 1, which means that the right-hand side of (11.10) is smaller than the right-hand side of (11.8). Thus, the condition required to prefer foreign currency-denominated bonds can be more easily satisfied on an after-tax basis. For given rates of return on base currency and foreign currency-denominated bonds, a lower rate of appreciation of the foreign currency is required to prefer foreign currency-denominated bonds on an after-tax basis than on a before-tax basis.

If, on the other hand, t g > t n, then (1 -1 n )/(1 -1 g) > 1, which means that, for given rates of return on base currency and foreign currency bonds, a higher rate of appreciation of the foreign currency is required to prefer foreign currency-denominated bonds on an after-tax basis than on a before-tax basis. The reason for this result is simple and intuitive. Foreign currency apprecia­tion is taxed at the capital gains tax rate, not at the income tax rate. Thus, a lower capital gains tax rate encourages investing in bonds denominated in currencies that are expected to appreciate.

Let us now consider the case when there are different tax rates and assume that tax is applied only in the country where the investment is undertaken. We will assume that there are two different income tax rates, but no capital gains tax. In this case, the interest income derived from base currency bonds is taxed at the domestic income tax rate, t n , whereas the interest income derived from foreign currency-denominated bonds is taxed at the foreign income tax rate, tn . Thus, the condition given by (11.9) will change to

S > (1 -1 n)rx -(1 - tn )ry (11.11)

which says that foreign currency denominated bonds will be preferred to domestic currency denominated bonds if the foreign currency is expected to appreciate by more than the after-tax rate of return differential.

11.3 INVESTMENT IN EQUITIES

An investor buying equities in a company becomes a shareholder of that company who is entitled to dividend payments. These payments, however, are not contractual in the sense that they may or may not be paid even if the company makes profit. The company may simply decide, at the discretion of the board of directors, not to distribute any dividends and opt for retained or undistributed profit to finance further expansion. But even with this in mind, investors buy shares in anticipation of making profit through capital apprecia­tion resulting from the rise in the price or the market value of the equity.

Investment in equity therefore provides returns in two forms: dividends and capital appreciation. Thus

R = d + a (11.12)

where R is the total rate of return on equity investment, d is the dividend yield and a is the rate of capital appreciation (the rate of change in equity prices), both of which are measured in percentage terms. If a base currency amount, K, is invested in domestic equities for n periods (years), and assuming that divi­dend payments can be reinvested at the same underlying rate of return, then the value of the invested capital at year t + n, Ix,t+n, will be given by

Ix,t+ n = K(1 + Rx )n (11.13)

or

Ix,t+ n = K(1 + dx + ax )n (11.14)

Let us now consider what happens if the same amount is invested in foreign equities. The amount K is converted at the spot exchange rate, St, to obtain K/St units of the foreign currency. The foreign currency value of the investment after n years is obtained by compounding the foreign currency amount invested at the rate of return on foreign equities. This amount is then re­

converted into the base currency at the exchange rate prevailing then, St+n. Thus, we obtain

I

x ,t+ n

KSt

Jt+ n

(1 + dy + ay )n (11.15)

S

where dy and ay are the dividend yield and the rate of capital appreciation asso­ciated with foreign equity investment. Equation (11.15) can be rewritten as

I*Xfi+ n = K(1 + S )(1 + dy + ay )n (11.16)

Assuming risk neutrality, foreign investment will be preferred if

Ix ,t+ n > Ix,t+ n , or if

K(1 + S)n(1 + dy + ay )n >K(1 + dx + ax)n (11.17)

which can be approximated by working out the expressions and ignoring the small cross product terms to obtain

S + dy + ay >dx + ax (11.18)

or

S > (d x - dy ) + (a x - ay ) (11.19)

which means that foreign equity investment would be preferred even if it offers lower dividend yield and rate of capital appreciation than domestic equity invest­ment. This would be the case if the foreign currency appreciates by more than the sum of the dividend yield differential and the capital appreciation rate differen­tial. Notice, however, that at the time when the decision concerning the choice is made, the values of these variables are unknown, so the decision should be made on their expected or ex ante values. At t + n, however, the values of the variables are realised, which enables the investor to find out whether or not the right deci­sion was made at time t.

The effect of taxes

We now compare the after-tax returns on domestic and foreign equity invest­ments. In this case, income tax is applied to dividends, whereas capital gains tax is applied to capital gains. In the presence of taxes, the after-tax rate of return on domestic equity investment is given by

Rx= (1 -1 n)d x + (1 -1 g)a x (11.20)

The after-tax rate of return on foreign equity investment is given by

Rx= (1 -1 n)dy + (1 -1 g )(ay + S) (11.21)

which shows that the capital gains tax applies to the appreciation component and the foreign exchange gains. Thus, foreign equity investment is preferred on an after-tax basis if Rx > Rx or if

(1 - tn )dy +(1 -1 g )(ay + S) >(1 -1 n)d x +(1 -1 g)a x (11.22)

which can be modified to 1 -t

S > 1 ~ (d x - dy ) + (a x - ay ) (11.23)

1 -t g x y x y

Let us now consider what happens if t g < t n .In this case, (1 -1 n )/(1 -1 g) < 1, so the right-hand side of equation (11.23) will be smaller than the right-hand side of equation (11.19). Thus, the condition required to prefer foreign equity investment can be more easily satisfied on an after-tax basis. For given domestic and foreign dividend yields and rates of capital appreciation, a lower rate of appreciation of the foreign currency is required to prefer foreign equity investment on an after-tax basis than on a before-tax basis. If, on the other hand, t g > t n , then a higher rate of appreciation of the foreign currency is required for the investor to prefer foreign equity on an after-tax basis.

Assume now that there are different income tax rates and that the capital gains tax applies to capital appreciation in the same currency only (that is, it does not apply to foreign exchange gains). Equation (11.21) becomes

Rx= (1 -1; )dy + (1 - tg)a y + S (11.24)

in which case, foreign equity investment is preferred if

(1 - tn )dy + (1 - tg)ay + S > (1 -1 n)d x + (1 -1 g)a x (11.25)

which can be rearranged to produce the condition

S >(1 -1 n)d x -(1 -1^ )dy + (1 -1 g)ax -(1 -tg)ay (11.26)

Equation (11.26) says that foreign equity investment is preferred to domestic equity investment if the foreign currency is expected to appreciate by more than the sum of the after tax dividend yield differential and the after-tax capital appreciation rate differential.

Investment vehicles and portfolio management styles

There are five alternative investment vehicles for foreign equity investment, which will be described in turn.

Direct purchase of securities in overseas markets

The firm carrying out the purchase or sale of foreign securities must have a branch or correspondent securities firm authorised to deal on the foreign stock exchange. When a firm buys individual foreign stocks, it would be exposed to four different kinds of risk: (i) country risk, which relates to economic and political events that have adverse effects on prices or the liquidity of the market; (ii) foreign exchange risk, which results from fluctua­tions in exchange rates; (iii) systematic risk, or market risk, which is the risk that cannot be eliminated via diversification; and (iv) unsystematic risk, which refers to the variability of the return on a single security.

The use of American Depository Receipts (ADRs)

An ADR is a receipt issued by a US bank certifying that the bank holds an equivalent number of shares issued by a foreign company. Securities brokers provide the market-making function in ADRs. The market price of an ADR (in US dollar terms) is the price of the underlying security in foreign currency terms multiplied by the exchange rate adjusted for the number of shares included in one ADR (say, ten). ADRs have two advantages over the direct purchase of equities: (i) avoidance of foreign exchange transaction costs; and (ii) ability to trade the foreign securities during regular stock market trading hours of the investor's stock market.

Single country funds

Single country funds trade the shares of companies of a single country. The majority of country funds have a closed end status. A closed end fund issues a given number of shares that are traded on the stock exchange as if the fund were an individual stock by itself. Unlike the shares of an open-end fund, shares of a closed-end country fund cannot be redeemed, and the underlying net asset value is set at the home market of the fund. The share value of a fund may very well diverge from the underlying net asset value in the fund's home market. The difference is known as the premium/discount.

International funds

International funds trade the shares of foreign companies belonging to several countries. The risk related to international funds is called "modified system­atic risk" (international diversification reduces risk below the level of risk experienced in most or all national markets).

Global funds

Unlike international funds, global funds also trade domestic shares. In the USA, international funds are defined to include no more than 24% in US secu­rities, whereas global funds have 50%. These funds are issued by large organi­sations. They tend to be cost-effective in that they sell and redeem shares at net asset value.

International portfolio management may be conducted by following one of three approaches. The first is passive indexation, whereby international fund managers concentrate on a large number of large capitalisation share issues belonging to leading market indices. The second is the tactical asset manage­ment strategy, which is based on a broad economic analysis of the leading market indices. The third is the global approach, which is based on measuring risk, return and correlation in terms of the investor's base currency.

Passive management has its theoretical support in the efficient market hypothesis. If the market has priced securities according to all available

11.4 INTERNATIONAL EQUITY RETURNS AND DIVERSIFICATION 303

information, and if the market responds to newly arriving information in a rational manner, then it may be difficult, if not impossible, to outperform the market. Active management, on the other hand, requires considerable anal­ysis and forecasting. The forecaster must provide detailed forecasts of the (i) national economic trends and their influence on each national market in terms of risk and return; and (ii) industrial trends on a worldwide basis, together with their implications for risk and return of specific company shares on a worldwide basis.

There is also modified active management, which requires a basic amount of forecasting for risk return and correlation of the securities or the national indices. Based on this information set, an efficient frontier can be estimated and used as a basis for portfolio selection and construction.

11.4 INTERNATIONAL EQUITY RETURNS AND DIVERSIFICATION

Returns on equity investment vary across markets because of cross-country differences, the first set of which pertain to macroeconomic factors. Solnik (1984) examined the effect on equity returns of exchange rate changes, interest rate differentials, the level of domestic interest rates, and changes in domestic inflationary expectations. He found that international monetary variables had only a weak influence on equity returns in comparison with domestic vari­ables. In another study, Asprem (1989) found that industrial production, employment, imports, interest rates and inflation explained only a small portion of the variability of equity returns for 10 European countries. However, he also found that substantially more of the variation was explained by an international market index.

The role of exchange rates is also important. Adler and Simon (1986) exam­ined the exposure of a sample of foreign equity and bond index returns to exchange rate changes. They found that changes in exchange rates generally explained a larger portion of the variability of foreign bond indexes than foreign equity indexes, but that some equity markets were more exposed to exchange rate changes than were the respective foreign bond markets. In another study, Eun and Resnick (1988) found that the cross-correlations among major stock markets and exchange markets are relatively low, but posi­tive. The result implies that exchange rate changes in a given country rein­force the stock market movements in that country as well as in the other countries examined.

Differences in industrial structures also play a role, although the studies examining this factor are inconclusive. Roll (1992) concluded that the indus­trial structure of a country is important in explaining a significant part of the correlation structure of international equity index returns. He also found that industry factors explained a larger portion of stock market variability than did exchange rate changes. In contrast, Eun and Resnick (1984) found, for a sample of 160 stocks from eight countries and 12 industries, that the pairwise correlation structure of international security returns could better be esti­mated from models that recognise country factors rather than industry factors. Similarly, using individual stock return data for 829 firms from 12 countries and representing seven broad industry groups, Heston and Rouwenhorst (1994) concluded that "industrial structure explains very little of the cross section differences in country return volatility". Overall, these empirical studies imply that there are unique country factors (the level of domestic interest rate and expected inflation) that explain national equity returns. Because of these unique factors there are benefits to be gained from international diversification.

International portfolio managers do not consider return only but also risk. It is a well-known principle in portfolio theory that diversification reduces risk if the rates of return on the assets from which a portfolio is composed are less than perfectly correlated. Because the economies of various countries differ in many respects, they are likely to be passing through different phases of the business cycle at the same point in time. The implication of these differences for the issue under discussion here is that rates of return in different countries are likely to be less positively correlated than those from different sectors within the same economy. This point has been established by Lessard (1976), Levy and Sarnat (1970) and Solnik (1974). Table 11.1 contains a correlation matrix of the quarterly rates of return on equity investment in the USA, Japan, the UK and Australia over the period January 1988-2001, with and without the exchange rate factor. When the exchange rate factor is taken into account the correlation matrix is reported from four national perspectives, in which case the national currency of the underlying country is taken to be the base currency of the investor. Although the rates of return are predominantly posi­tively correlated, the correlation coefficients are adequately low to allow for some benefits from diversification.

We could write the rate of return on foreign equity investment measured in base currency terms as

Rx= Ay + S (11.27)

where Ay = dy + Uy is the total rate of return in foreign currency terms. The variance of Rx is given by

s2 (Rx ) = s2 (Ay ) + s2 (S) + 2s(Ay , S) (11.28)

which means that the variance of the base currency rate of return can be decomposed into three components: the variance of the rate of return in foreign currency terms, the variance of the percentage change in the exchange rate and (twice) the covariance of these two components. Table 11.2 reports the results of this decomposition of the variance of quarterly base currency

11.4 INTERNATIONAL

EQUITY RETURNS AND

DIVERSIFICATION 305

TABLE 11.1 correlation matrix of rates of return on equity investments

(1988-2001).

USA

Japan UK

Australia

Without the FX factor

US 1

0.43 0.76

0.60

Japan

1.00 0.38

0.39

UK

1.00

0.56

Australia

1.00

US perspective

USA -

- -

-

Japan

1.00 0.22

0.38

UK

1.00

0.51

Australia

1.00

Japanese perspective

USA 1

0.75

-0.31

Japan -

- -

-

UK

1.00

-0.24

Australia

1.00

UK perspective

USA 1

0.48

0.67

Japan

1.00

0.49

UK -

- -

-

Australia

1.00

Australian perspective

USA 1

0.32 0.62

Japan

1.00 0.19

UK

1.00

Australia -

- -

-


rates of return on equity investment from various national perspectives over the period 1988-2001. It is obvious that in all cases the variability of the rate of return in foreign currency terms is a major contributor to the variability of the base currency rate of return.

Let us see what happens when we combine a domestic security or portfolio, which gives a rate of return R, with a foreign security or portfolio that gives a rate of return R*, both of which are measured in base currency terms (the subscript x is not shown for convenience). If the weights assigned to the two securities are w and w*, then the expected (or the average) value of the rate of return on the portfolio and its variance are given respectively by

foreign equity investment.

TABLE 11.2 Decomposition of the variances of base currency rates of return on

Ay

S

Rx

a2 (Ay)

a2 (S)

o2 (Rx )

a( Ay )

P( Ay

USA

USA

2.65

-

-

33.1

-

-

-

-

Japan

-1.09

0.31

-0.78

93.5

45.0

145.0

3.24

0.05

Germany

1.90

-0.28

1.61

49.3

23.5

49.0

-11.91

-0.35

UK

1.61

-0.97

0.63

39.3

21.8

74.0

6.44

0.22

Japan

USA

2.65

0.12

2.78

33.1

42.5

81.6

3.00

0.08

Japan

-1.09

-

-

93.5

-

-

-

-

Germany

1.90

-0.28

1.62

94.3

42.7

83.2

-4.59

-0.10

UK

1.61

0.30

1.91

39.3

45.0

89.3

2.52

0.06

UK

USA

2.65

0.52

3.17

33.1

25.2

76.2

8.95

0.31

Japan

-1.09

0.71

-0.37

93.5

45.6

169.1

15.02

0.23

Germany

1.90

-

-

94.3

-

-

-

-

UK

1.61

-0.49

1.11

39.3

37.6

97.7

10.38

0.27

Australia

USA

2.65

1.20

3.86

33.1

23.8

49.6

-3.65

-0.13

Japan

-1.09

1.47

0.38

93.5

61.2

141.1

-6.81

-0.09

Germany

1.90

0.87

2.77

94.3

38.8

67.1

-10.50

-0.42

UK

1.61

-

-

39.3

-

-

-

-

E(R p ) = wR + w* R* (11.29)

a2 (Rp ) = w2 a2 (R) + w*2 a2 (R* ) + 2ww* a(R)a(R* )p( R, R *) (11.30)

where p( R, R* ) is the correlation coefficient between the base currency and foreign currency rates of return. The measure of risk is the standard deviation of the rate of return, which is the square root of the variance. Hence

s(Rp) = ^w2 a2 (R) + w*2 a 2 (R*) + 2ww*a(R)a(R* )p(R, R* ) (11.31)

By using equation (11.31), we can demonstrate that the reduction in risk via diversification depends upon the correlation coefficient of the rates of return. If the rates of return are perfectly correlated (that is, p(R, R ) = 1), then the stan­dard deviation of the rate of return on the portfolio is given by

a(Rp) = ^[wa(R) + w*a(R* )]2 = wa(R) + w*a(R* ) (11.32)

which is a weighted average of the standard deviations of the individual secu­rities or portfolios. Hence diversification does not lead to a reduction in risk if

11.4 INTERNATIONAL EQUITY RETURNS AND DIVERSIFICATION

the rates of return are perfectly correlated. This case is unlikely to arise in prac­tice, even more so if one of the securities is domestic and the other is foreign. It is more likely the case that the rates of return are less than perfectly correlated (that is, p(R, R ) < 1). If the correlation coefficient is zero we have

a(Rp) = Vw 2 a2(R) + w*2 a2 (R*) < wa(R) + w* o(R*) (11.33)

which shows that the standard deviation of the rate of return on the portfolio is less than the weighted average of the two standard deviations. This means that the portfolio risk is lower when the securities are uncorrelated.

International diversification is most beneficial in terms of risk reduction if the domestic and foreign securities are negatively correlated. In the extreme case when they are perfectly negatively correlated (that is, pR, R*) = -1), the standard deviation of the rate of return on the portfolio is given by

a(Rp) = •N/[wa(R) -w*a(R* )]2 = wa(R)-w*a(R* ) (11.34)

which is the lowest value that can be assumed by the standard deviation of the rate of return on the portfolio.

For a given value of the correlation coefficient, it is possible to construct a large number of portfolios from the domestic and foreign securities by assigning different values to the weights w and w*. For each portfolio there is a combination of the expected rate of return as given by equation (11.29) and the standard deviation as given by equation (11.31). International diversifi­cation leads to a situation in which the same level of return can be achieved at a lower level of risk, or a higher rate of return can be achieved at the same level of risk. This is more so than what results from diversification within the same market.

Empirical evidence on international diversification

Various researchers have documented evidence on the extent to which port­folio investment is concentrated in domestic equities. These include French and Porteba (1991) and Cooper and Kaplains (1994). This runs counter to the strand of research that collectively established a strong case for international diversification (including Grubel (1968), Solnik (1974), Lessard (1976) and Eun and Resnick (1988)). Several explanations can be put forward to resolve this inconsistency, including the following:

  1. Domestic securities may provide investors with certain extra services, such as hedging against domestic inflation. This may not be convincing, given that equities are not a good inflation hedge (bonds may do a better job in this respect). Cooper and Kaplains (1994) rule out inflation hedging as a primary cause for home bias.

  2. 307

    There may be barriers, formal or informal, to investing in foreign securities. For example, there may be some restrictions on share holding by foreigners.

  1. Some investors may not invest more than a certain percentage of their funds in foreign securities.

  2. The presence of taxes and transaction/information costs.

  3. Investors tend not to hold securities with which they are not familiar.

Although the risk reduction available from international diversification in equity is well documented, much less research has been devoted to diversifi­cation in bonds. Levy and Lerman (1988) have investigated this issue in an attempt to answer three questions pertaining to: (i) the extent to which inter­national diversification among bonds can produce returns in excess of those available only in domestic bonds; (ii) the possibility of constructing interna­tional diversified portfolios, despite the relatively low mean returns of bonds compared equity; and (iii) the impact of diversification on portfolios made up of bonds and equities from various markets. They found that US bond inves­tors were in a position to improve their performance by 3 to 5 percentage points a year by diversifying internationally rather than restricting their investments to domestic bonds. This result is attributed to the low correlations between the bond markets in various countries compared with correlations among equity markets. They also found a very large potential for international diversification in equities and bonds.

Another related issue is diversification by including emerging equity markets. By using 24 years of data, Conover et al. (2002) suggest that emerging equity markets are a worthy addition to a US investor's portfolio of developed market equities. Specifically, they found that portfolio returns increased by approximately 1.5 percentage points a year when emerging country equities were included in the portfolio. They also found that the benefits of investing in emerging markets accrued almost exclusively during periods of restrictive US monetary policy (otherwise they were trivial). They further suggested that evaluating monetary conditions is a necessary prerequisite for identifying an optimal allocation of assets to international equities.

11.5 INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL

The conventional or domestic capital asset pricing model (CAPM) postulates that the expected return on an asset or portfolio is positively related to its systematic risk, the component of risk that cannot be eliminated by diversifica­tion. The relationship can be written as

Rj = i + b(Rm -i) (11.35)

where Rj is the equilibrium or required expected rate of return on a security or a portfolio j, i is the risk-free interest rate and Rm is the expected rate of return on the market portfolio, such as the portfolio implied by a stock market index. b can be calculated as a regression coefficient from the equation

a( Rj, R m)

b=-T- (11.36)

a 2(R m)

where a(Rj , Rm ) is the covariance of the rates of return on the portfolio and the market, whereas a2 (Rm ) is the variance of the rate of return on the market. Equation (11.35) tells us that the expected return on a security or a portfolio is equal to the risk-free rate plus a risk premium that is linearly related to a measure of systematic risk, b, the latter being the risk that the secu­rity or the portfolio contributes to the market as a whole. Investors are, there­fore, compensated for bearing systematic risk only. If the expected return is greater than is implied by this equation, the underlying security would be very attractive and investors would rush to buy it, raising its price and lowering its return.

From equation (11.35) we can see the following:

    1. A security with a zero b has a rate of return that is equal to the risk-free interest rate.

    2. A security with a b of less than one (less risky than the market portfolio) has an expected return higher than the risk-free rate but lower than the expected return on the market portfolio.

    3. A security with a systematic risk that is equal to that of the market portfolio ( b= 1) has an expected rate of return that is equal to the return on the market portfolio.

    4. If the security is more risky than the market portfolio (b > 1) then it will offer an expected rate of return that is higher than what is offered by the market portfolio.

The CAPM in a global setting

To apply the CAPM in a global setting, several issues arise. The first issue concerns the definition of the market portfolio: should it be the market port­folio in the base currency, the market portfolio in a foreign currency, a combi­nation of the two portfolios, or a global market portfolio? The second issue concerns changes in exchange rates: should these changes be included in the market portfolio's rate of return? Then there is the choice of the appropriate risk-free rate, which differs from one country to another. Finally, there is the issue of exposure to foreign exchange risk: should currency exposure be taken into account as a risk factor that requires an adjustment in the expected rate of return?

These issues have been addressed by the global asset pricing model (GAPM) (see for example, Dumas, 1993). This model is based on the idea of interna­tional diversification of portfolios, which is what is practised in reality. Given relatively thorough international diversification, the model is used to deter­mine the risk-adjusted required rate of return from the perspective of a certain currency. The model may be written as

kj = i + b g(k g-i) + b q ( k q-i) (11.37)

where bg is the measure of the sensitivity of the asset's rate of return relative to the rate of return on the global market portfolio, bq is the sensitivity to the rate of change in wealth-weighted index of exchange rates, kg is the expected rate of return on the global market portfolio measured in base currency terms and kq is the expected rate of change in the domestic currency value of the wealth-weighted portfolio of other currencies.

Equation (11.37) is applicable to any particular currency regardless of the currency denomination of the asset. This is because kj in this case is the expected rate of return expressed in base currency terms. The risk-free rate is the rate of return on base currency risk-free assets. There are two differences between equations (11.35) and (11.37). The first difference is that the market portfolio in equation (11.35) becomes the global market portfolio in equation (11.37). The second and more important difference is that equation (11.37) embodies two risk factors: one for market risk and the other for currency expo­sure risk. Thus, the GAPM shows that an asset has two betas, one measuring market risk and the other measuring currency risk. These two betas must be measured simultaneously by using multiple regression analysis.

As we have seen, the rate of return on a single asset in terms of a particular currency (that is different from the currency of denomination of the asset) consists of two components: the rate of return in terms of the currency of denomination and the rate of appreciation (or depreciation) of this currency against the base currency (the currency in which kj is measured). The global market portfolio is some sort of weighted average of these returns. In practice, the global rate of return is calculated from the value of a world stock index measured in a particular currency. Similarly, the rate of change in the base currency can be calculated from the effective exchange rate of the base currency. The GAPM can be used to calculate the expected rate of return on a foreign project. It can be used to find out the rate for either domestic currency or foreign currency analysis.

The GAPM can also be used to forecast the expected change of the exchange rate of the foreign currency in terms of the base currency. For two currencies, x and y, such that the base currency is x, we have

Se(x/y) = ix -iy + b g(kg -ix ) + bq(kq -ix ) (11.38)

Equation (11.38) says the following. The expected change in the exchange rate depends on three factors: (i) the interest rate differential, ix - iy; (ii) the differ­ence between the rate of return on the global market portfolio and the interest rate on currency x, kg - ix; and (iii) the difference between the rate of change in the index of the exchange rate (the effective exchange rate of currency x) and the interest rate on currency x, kq - ix. If b g = b = 0, then

S e(x/y) = ix -iy (11.39)

which is uncovered interest parity (UIP).

Sometimes, the basic CAPM representation of equation (11.35) is modified by including an exchange rate factor. The modified model can be written in a stochastic time series form as

Rj,t = b 0,j + b 1, jR m,t + b 2,j$t + e j,t (11.40)

in which case b2 j measures a firm's exposure to exchange rate movements after taking into account the overall market's exposure to changes in the underlying exchange rate. If b2 j = 0, this means that firm j has the same exchange rate exposure as the market portfolio. If b2 j ^ 0, then the conven­tional CAPM is misspecified. Dominguez and Tesar (2001) used this modified model to investigate exposure to foreign exchange risk. They obtained results that they found to be consistent with high degrees of exchange rate exposure at both the firm and industry level in eight countries.

Market segmentation

The implication of this analysis is that international diversification can produce abnormal returns if markets are segmented and the securities are priced according to the domestic CAPM using a domestic market portfolio as a benchmark. If, on the other hand, markets are integrated, securities are priced according to the international CAPM using an internationally diversified port­folio as a benchmark.

There are several reasons for market segmentation:

      1. Legal barriers to foreign investment. These barriers may take the form of an outright restriction on investment by foreigners, or other forms such as the imposition of higher tax rates on foreigners investing in domestic assets.

      2. The difficulty of finding and interpreting information about foreign securities, which may be due to the use of different accounting standards.

      3. Foreign exchange risk. The problem with foreign exchange risk is that it may not be possible to hedge, perhaps because of the unavailability of forward contracts with long maturities or in certain currencies. Moreover, foreign exchange risk does not conform to the positive risk-return trade­off. Bearing more foreign exchange risk does not necessarily mean expecting higher return.

      4. Purchasing power risk. Segmentation can arise because prices of what investors consume relative to the returns they earn change differently in different countries.

      5. Political and country risk. Political risk pertains to changes in the rules governing foreign investment by the host government. Country risk encompasses all of the factors that can adversely affect its economic performance.

      6. Transaction costs. These costs are higher when they involve foreign trans­actions. Some of these costs include the bid-offer spread in foreign

exchange, settlement costs and the custodial costs associated with buying and selling foreign securities.

      1. Taxation. In the absence of double taxation agreements, investment returns may be taxed twice in the foreign and home countries.

      2. Domestic regulations. Some countries impose restrictions on the ability of their citizens to invest in foreign securities. Recently, however, measures of financial deregulation have included the dismantling of these restrictions.

Two observations related to market segmentation may also be made here. First, although strong linkages have developed between the three largest equity markets (the USA, Japan and the UK), these linkages do not necessarily mean that they are fully integrated. They are at best partially integrated, primarily because of foreign exchange risk. The second observation is that leading bond markets display strong independent performance and vari­ability due to the tendency for interest rates in national markets to move according to domestic trends (for example, internal and external balances).

11.6 MANAGING FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK IN INTERNATIONAL PORTFOLIOS

International portfolio managers pay significant attention to the management of foreign exchange risk arising from investing in international portfolios. In this section we discuss issues related to the management of foreign exchange risk arising from international portfolio investment.

Approaches to hedging foreign exchange risk in international portfolios

Believing that international portfolio managers do not have sufficient exper­tise in the field of foreign exchange, some institutional investors have turned to specialised "overlay mangers" to manage the foreign exchange risk sepa­rately. In general, there are three approaches to the management of foreign exchange risk in securities portfolios. The first is joint or full-blown optimisa­tion over the assets and currencies. The second is partial optimisation over the currencies, given a predetermined position in the core portfolio. The third is separate optimisation over currencies. The first approach is based on the assumption that the portfolio manager has expertise in many asset classes and can structure a portfolio to account for correlations between asset prices and exchange rates. Approaches 2 and 3, on the other hand, are based on the assumption of foreign exchange risk management via an "overlay programme". In approach 2, currencies are managed separately from the core portfolio, but the manager still controls the total portfolio risk. In approach 3, currencies are managed completely independently of the rest of the portfolio,

and their performance is measured against a separate benchmark (for example, money market instruments).

In terms of mean-variance optimisation, investors choose portfolio weights that maximise an objective utility function, U(m,o2 ), where m and o2 are respectively the mean and the variance of the underlying rate of return (on an asset, a portfolio or a hedging instrument), such that dU/dm > 0 and dU/do2 < 0. In approach 1, positions in assets and currencies are determined simulta­neously in order to optimise the risk-return combination for the whole port­folio. Thus the decision problem can be written formally as

max [U(Rp, o2 (R_ ))] (11.41)

W[Wj

where Wi is the weight assigned to asset i, and Wj is the weight assigned to the hedging instrument in currency j. In this case the arguments of the utility function are the mean and variance of the overall rate of return on the port­folio, Rp. This would also be the case if the foreign exchange risk is not hedged.

Optimisation in approach 2 is conditioned on predetermined underlying asset positions. The asset weights are initially determined without regard to the hedging instrument, and then the currency weights of the hedging instru­ment are determined. Thus the two-step optimisation problem can be written as

(11.42)

max[U(Rp, s2 (Rp )|w ;)]

max[U(R a , s 2(Ra ))] V s 2 (Rp )

where Ra is the rate of return on the asset.

(11.43)

In the third approach of separate optimisation, the asset and hedge weights are determined independently of each other. The weights assigned to assets and hedging instruments are found by solving two independent optimisation problems given by

max[U( R a , s 2( Ra ))]

wi

max[U( Rh, s 2( Rh ))]

where Rh is the rate of return on the hedging instrument. Jorion (1994) uses this type of analysis to conclude that the overlay structure is inherently suboptimal because it ignores interactions between the asset prices and exchange rates. On the basis of historical data, he estimated the efficiency loss to be something like 40 basis points.

Matched hedging and basket hedging

Hedging the foreign exchange risk arising from internationally diversified portfolios can be done by taking opposite positions in hedging instruments

such as futures, forwards and options. Let us concentrate on forward contracts. The manager of an internationally diversified portfolio with a base currency x and long positions on securities denominated in currencies y1, y2, ..., yn can hedge his portfolio by selling these currencies forward against x in amounts determined by their weights in the portfolio. This operation would lock in the future base currency value of the securities. Hedging single currency exposures separately is called matched hedging. This hedging strategy would be effective if the portfolio is denominated in a few major currencies. If a large number of currencies are involved, this operation will be costly, particularly if some exotic currencies are involved. Forward contracts on these currencies are typically characterised by wide bid-offer spreads. The alternative would be basket hedging, which consists of selling a few major currencies that can adequately represent the movements of the exchange rates of all of the currencies in the portfolio. Tucker et al. (2001, p. 98) believe that selling three major currencies would be adequate. The objective would then be to determine the weights w\, W2 and W3 that minimise the variance of the exchange rate factor of the basket minus the exchange rate factor of the port­folio. Formally, the constrained optimisation problem is formulated as follows:

44

Minimise ZZ wiwjs(S i , Sj) (11.45)

i=1 j=1

subject to

3

Z Wi= 1 (11.46)

i= 1

w 4 =-1 (11.47)

where w4 is the weight of the portfolio. To solve this optimisation problem, we construct the Lagrange equation

44

L = ZZ WiWj o(Si , Sj) + 1 j(w! + w2 + w 3 -1) +12 (w 4 + 1) (11.48)

i= 1 j= 1

= 2wis2 (S 1) + 2s(Si, S2 )w2 + 2s(S 1, S3 )w3

Thus, we have

dL

dm 1 -1'—-1'-2'"2 --v-^"3 '-3 (1149)

= 2w 2 s 2 (S2 ) + 2ct( S2 , S3 )w 3 + 2ct(S2 , S4 )w4

+ 2ct(S 1, S 4)w 4 +1 1 = 0

dL

dw2 ' ■-- v-^-^-"4 (11.50)

+ 2s(S 1, S2)w 1 +1 1 = 0

= 2w3 s 2 (S3 ) + 2s(S 1 , S3 )w 1 + 2s(S2 , S3 )w2

dL dwA

dL d2 1

dL

dl T

(11.56)

B

+ 2s(S 3 , S4 )w 4 +2 1 = 0 = 2w4 s 2 (S4 ) + 2s(S 1 , S4 )w 1 + 2s(S 2 , S4 )w2 + 2s(S 3 , S4 )w 4 + 2 2 = 0

= w 1 + W2 + w 3 -1 = 0

= w 4 +1 = 0

which gives the matrix equation Bw = C

where

palgrave 1

palgrave 2

i 19

i 23

CHAPTER 3 44

Other Kinds of Arbitrage and Some Extensions 46

3.1 COMMODITY ARBITRAGE 46

Py ,t+ 1/Py ,t 55

3.2 ARBITRAGE UNDER THE GOLD STANDARD 61

3.3 ARBITRAGE BETWEEN EUROCURRENCY AND DOMESTIC INTEREST RATES 63

3.4 EUROCURRENCY-EUROBOND ARBITRAGE 74

3.5 ARBITRAGE BETWEEN CURRENCY FUTURES AND FORWARD CONTRACTS 52

3.6 REAL INTEREST ARBITRAGE 54

3.7 UNCOVERED ARBITRAGE WHEN THE CROSS RATES ARE STABLE 55

3.8 UNCOVERED INTEREST ARBITRAGE WHEN THE BASE CURRENCY IS PEGGED TO A BASKET 57

^ ^ 1=1 »j ^ j=1 and 57

E1= S 0 - S j (3.40) 57

3.9 MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT ARBITRAGE 83

CHAPTER 4 65

Hedging Exposure to Foreign Exchange Risk: The Basic Concepts 65

4.1 DEFINITION AND MEASUREMENT OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK 65

4.2 VALUE AT RISK 69

4.3 DEFINITION AND MEASUREMENT OF EXPOSURE TO FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK 74

4.4 TRANSACTION EXPOSURE 82

4.5 ECONOMIC AND OPERATING EXPOSURE 84

4.6 A FORMAL TREATMENT OF OPERATING EXPOSURE 95

dQ_py_ dPy Q 102

4.7 TRANSLATION EXPOSURE 123

Financial and Operational Hedging of Exposure to Foreign Exchange Risk 105

Fb,t - Sb,t 123

p - K(Fa,t - Sb,t+ 1 ) 133

Measuring the Hedge Ratio 158

, s(DPu,t, DPA,t If t-1) ,t t . 164

h = ^ ^ r" = P(X 1,t , X 2 ,t ) 164

s 2(DP A,t|f t-1 ) 164

DP u,t = t-1 + Z ai DP U,t-i +Z bi dPa ,t-i +x 1,t (6.33) 186

DP A,t =-bft-1 + Z ci DP U,t-i +Z d i DP A,t - i +X 2 ,t (6.34) 186

s(DPU,t, DPA,t If t-1, DPU,t-i, DPA,t-i) 186

s2 (APA,t If t-1' APU,t-i ' APA,t-i ) (6 35) 186

I,t ' X 2,t ) / s(X i,t ) ^ 186

= P(X 1't ' X 2 ,t ) 186

_ P(X 1,t , X 2 ,t)s(X 1,t)s(X 2 ,t) -2 (f t-11 AP U,t-i, APA,t-i) 187

s2 (X2 ,t ) + b2 s 2 (f t-11 APU,t-i, APA,t-i ) 187

Speculation in the Spot and Currency Derivative Markets 184

Sb,t 198

Sb,t 1 + m 198

Sb,t 1 + E(mt+1) 199

E( Sb,t+1 ), S 200

if the position in x is available. If the funds have to be borrowed, the condition changes to 201

Speculation: Generating Buy and 209

Sell Signals 209

St = f (Xt) 257

where the vector of variables varies according to the underlying fundamental model. The current level of the exchange rate may deviate from the equilib­rium level because of the effect of random shocks that tend to have a tempo­rary effect. Hence the current level of the exchange rate may be represented by 258

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]