- •International Financial Operations
- •Imad a. Moosa
- •International Financial Operations
- •Imad a. Moosa
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •3.1 Commodity arbitrage
- •3.2 Arbitrage under the gold standard
- •3.3 Arbitrage between eurocurrency and domestic interest rates
- •3.4 Eurocurrency-eurobond arbitrage
- •3.5 Arbitrage between currency futures and forward contracts
- •3.6 Real interest arbitrage
- •3.7 Uncovered arbitrage when the cross rates are stable
- •3.8 Uncovered interest arbitrage when the base currency is pegged to a basket
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •I At the outset, a question should be answered concerning the motivation for hedging. It is often assumed that the motivation to hedge is risk reduction or
- •V No hedging
- •V Risk sharing
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •0.6 0.8 Hedge ratio
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •1 23456789 10 Actual Expected • Error
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
- •Interest rate.
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital
- •International Long-Term Portfolio Investment
- •International Short-Term Financing and Investment 251
- •International Long-Term Financing, Capital Structure and the Cost of Capital 284
3.8 Uncovered interest arbitrage when the base currency is pegged to a basket
In this section we deal with uncovered interest arbitrage when the base currency is pegged to a basket such that its exchange rate against a numeraire (normally the US dollar) is determined by the exchange rates of the component currencies against the numeraire. Let x be the base (pegged) currency, y0 the numeraire and yj any other currency, whether or not it is included in the basket. Define S0 = S(x/y0), Sj = S(yj/y0) and Ej = S(x/yj). If the basket contains n currencies, S0 is calculated as
n
S0= a 0 +Z a jS j (335)
j=1
where a0 reflects the weight of the numeraire and a j reflects the weight of currency j in the basket. For these coefficients to be exactly the weights, equation (3.35) must be written in a logarithmic form as
n
log S0 = a0 +Z a j log Sj (336)
j=1
We also have
S0
Ej = S0 (3-3 7)
Sj
If a short or a long position is taken on a portfolio of currencies against a short or a long position on the base currency, the foreign exchange profit/loss will be a weighted average of the gains and losses resulting from changes in the exchange rates S0 and Ej. In continuous time, the foreign currency profit/loss resulting from changes in the exchange rate S0 is defined as
1 dS
C(S0) = 7^-rf = S0 (3.38)
S0 dt
a
_idSi
Sn
dt
h
1
S;
dt
£a
= Z a 1 = h a iS j (3-39)
^ ^ 1=1 »j ^ j=1 and
E1= S 0 - S j (3.40)
Assume now that there is a foreign currency portfolio consisting of some currencies that are included in the basket and others that are not, such that j =
2, ..., m, m + 1, ..., n, n + 1, n + 2, ..., k. Currencies included in the basket and the portfolio are 1, 2, ..., m; currencies included in the basket but not in the portfolio are m + 1, ..., n; and those included in the portfolio only are n + 1, n +
..., k. Hence
C = b 0 S0 + b 1E1 + b 2 E2 +••• (3.41)
+ b mE m + b n+ 1E n+ 1 + b n+ 2 En+ 2 + ••• + b kEk
where b0 is the weight assigned to currency yo and bj is the weight assigned to currency yj in the portfolio for j = 1, 2, ..., m and j = n, n + 1, n + 2, ..., k. This gives
C = b 0 S0 + b 1(S0 - S 1) + b 2 ( S0 - S2 ) + ••• + b m (S0 - S m ) + b n+ 1(SS0 - S n+ 1) + b n+ 2 (S0 - Sn+ 2 ) + ••• + b k (S0 - Sk )
Since
mk
£ b j + z b j = 1 (3.43)
j=0 j=n+ 1
it follows that
C = S0 -(b 1S1 + b2 S2 +•+ bmSm + b n+ 1S'n+ 1 + • + b kS k) (3.44)
Since
n m n
S 0 = Z a jS j = Z a jS j + Z a jS j (3.45)
j=1 j=1 j=m + 1
C
=
Z
ajSj
+
Z
a
jSj-Z
b
jSj
-
Z
b
jSj (3.46)
(3.42)
m n ^ m ^ k
Z ajS j + Z ajSj -Z bjS j- Z
j=1 j=m + 1 j=1 j=n+ 1
or
C = Z (a j - b j )S j + Z a jSj - Z b jSj (3.47)
j=1 j=m + 1 j=n+ 1
The objective of arbitrage is to utilise the interest rate differential while eliminating foreign exchange risk. For simplicity we will ignore the bid-offer spread on interest rates and assume that the borrowing and lending rates for each currency are equal. Let the interest rate on the base currency be ix, and on
foreign currency j be ij (j = 1, 2, ..., k). Thus, the effective interest rate on the foreign currency portfolio is S1 b jij. Let us also start with the general case where there are currencies that are included in the basket and in the portfolio, others that are included in the basket only, and those included in the portfolio only. If a short (long) position is taken on the base currency while a long (short) position is taken on the portfolio then the uncovered margin, p, is given by
km n k
p = £ bjij -ix + £(a j -bj )Sj + £ ajSj - £ bjS j (3.48)
j=1 j=1 j=m +1 j=n+1
If the objective is to eliminate foreign exchange risk while gaining the interest rate differential, the following conditions must be satisfied: k = n and a j = b j for j = 1, 2, ..., m. These two conditions imply the following: (i) the currencies in the portfolio are equal in number and identical to those in the basket; and (ii) the weight assigned to a particular currency in the portfolio is equal to its weight in the basket. If these conditions are satisfied, equation (3.48) reduces to
n
p = £ bjij -ix (3.49)
j=1
because
m n n
X (a j - b j )S j + X a jS j = I (a j - b j )S j = 0 (3.50)
j=1 j=m +1 j=1
and
k
X b jS j = 0 (3.51)
j=n+1
Equation (3.49) obviously indicates the possibility of obtaining risk-free profit because all interest rates are known in advance. It also implies that there is no possibility for arbitrage if
n
ix= X b jij (3.52)
j=1
which means that if the interest rate on the base (pegged) currency is calculated as a weighted average of the interest rates on the components of the basket, arbitrage will not be profitable. If, however, condition (3.52) is not satisfied, then the following can be done. If ix < Sb jij, a short position should be taken on the base currency and a long position on the portfolio. If, on the other hand, ix >Sbjij, then the opposite positions should be taken.
60 ) INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL OPERATIONS An illustration
This kind of arbitrage operation does not work when the base currency is a composite currency like the former European currency unit (ECU) or the IMF's special drawing rights (SDR) because the interest rates on composite currencies like these two are calculated as a weighted average as in equation (3.52). However, there are other pegged currencies (such as the Kuwaiti dinar, KWD) for which equation (3.52) is not satisfied, which makes arbitrage along the lines suggested earlier a profitable operation. Perhaps this is why the structure of the basket to which the Kuwaiti dinar is pegged is not publicly known, unlike the case for the ECU and the SDR. If the structure of the basket is unknown then the a j s are not known, so the arbitrager would not know in advance whether or not the condition a j = b j is satisfied. However, the a js can be estimated empirically from equation (3.36) based on observed data.
In this illustration, we use the KWD as the base currency and monthly data covering the period March 1993-June 1999. Previous research has revealed that the basket to which the KWD is pegged contains the currencies of the top four exporters to Kuwait: the US, Japan, Germany and the UK. Moosa (2001a) has estimated the weights of the four currencies in the KWD basket to be 0.824, 0.05796, 0.05606 and 0.06554 respectively. Figure 3.6(a) shows that during the 1990s the interest rate on the KWD (ix in the model) was higher than the weighted average interest rate on the component currencies. The differential was almost five percentage points in early 1993, as shown in Figure 3.6(b). Arbitrage would in this case require taking short positions on the four currencies in exactly the same percentages as the weights stated above, and an equivalent long position on the KWD. Figure 3.6(c) shows that the exchange rate factor, C, resulting from such an operation seems to be negligible and zero towards the end of the sample period. This observation confirms the predictions of the model. Figure 3.6(d) shows the uncovered margin (net profit) that would have resulted from an operation like this in the 1990s, as calculated from equation (3.48). Obviously, an operation like this would have been rather lucrative in early 1990s. Towards the end of the 1990s, the profitability of the operation would have been lower owing to the convergence of the KWD interest rate on the weighted average interest rate of the basket component currencies.
3.9 MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT ARBITRAGE
Arbitrage is commonly defined as "the act of simultaneously buying and selling the same or equivalent assets or commodities for the purpose of making certain, guaranteed profits" (Eun and Resnick, 1998, p 104). The Palgrave Dictionary defines an arbitrage opportunity as "an investment strategy that guarantees a positive payoff in some contingency with no possibility of a negative payoff and with no net investment" (Dybvic and Ross,
(a)
One month interest rates
(b)
The interest rate differential (KWD-basket)
FIGURE
3.6
Uncovered arbitrage when the base currency is pegged to a basket
(continued
overleaf).
1993). These two definitions and several of their variants give arbitrage its perceived characteristics: (i) that it is a riskless operation, (ii) that it does not require net investment or the use of own capital, and (iii) the simultaneity of the buy and sell transactions. It is argued here that these assertions are questionable and that the definitions are misrepresentations that cannot be generalised.
Let us start by examining some types of arbitrage to see if they fit the generic definitions stated earlier. Consider first two-point arbitrage in the foreign exchange market. In this case arbitragers buy a currency in a financial centre where it is cheap and sell it simultaneously where it is more expensive. The simultaneity of the buy and sell transactions is obvious in the description of this operation, but it is not clear whether or not the condition of not using own capital is satisfied. Since the settlement of foreign exchange transactions takes
(c)
The exchange rate factor
(d)
Annualised uncovered margin
two business days, not using own capital requires the arbitrager to transfer the funds received from the selling of the currency to the counterparty from whom it was bought. Thus, not using own capital requires the arbitrager to make the payment for the buy transaction only after receiving the proceeds from the sell transaction. A problem could arise here when the two financial centres involved in the operation are in two different far-away time zones (for example, Tokyo and New York). This task will be even more difficult in the case of three-point arbitrage, which entails selling a currency and then buying it back by going through another two currencies and three separate sell-buy transactions.
To emphasise the point that risk is involved in this kind of operation, consider the origin of the concept of "Herstatt risk". In 1974, a small bank in
Germany, Bankhaus Herstatt, was closed by the authorities in the middle of the day. The bank was insolvent, so it was unable to pay the dollars it owed on its foreign exchange deals. Even now banks continue to be exposed to Herstatt risk because of different time zones. This is because banks in New York do not receive dollars for the yens they paid in the morning or the euros they paid in the afternoon. Thus arbitrage operations are subject to Herstatt risk.
Consider now covered interest arbitrage, which consists of taking a short position on one currency and a long position on another currency while covering the long position in the forward market. Not using own funds is possible only if the arbitrager can borrow funds. However, the textbook exposition of covered interest arbitrage invariably starts by assuming that an agent (investor) has a certain amount of capital that may be invested in the domestic or foreign markets. This exposition eventually leads to the derivation of the covered interest parity (no-arbitrage) condition. Thus the derivation of this condition, which precludes arbitrage, is typically based on the assumption of using own funds. However, it remains true that the same condition can be derived by assuming that the arbitrager initially borrows funds, as is done in this book. But borrowing funds is not the same as not using own funds in the case of two-point arbitrage, where no borrowing is required.
The no-risk condition is satisfied in the case of covered interest arbitrage, since all of the decision variables (interest and exchange rates) are known in advance. This is not so for uncovered interest arbitrage, in which the long position is not covered in the forward market. Uncovered interest arbitrage is risky because one of the decision variables is the expected spot exchange rate. Hence uncovered arbitrage is a speculative activity that does not satisfy the no-risk condition. Moreover, a significant length of time elapses between the buy and sell transactions. Simultaneity is far from being the case here. The same arguments is valid for intertemporal commodity arbitrage
Finally, consider arbitrage in the spot and forward commodity markets. In this case arbitrage is triggered by the violation of the cost of carry relationship (see, for example, Moosa and Al-Loughani (1995) and Moosa (2000b)). If the spot price of a commodity plus the cost of carry is lower than the forward selling price then arbitragers will make profit by buying spot and selling forward. Otherwise, they will make profit by buying forward and short selling spot. While simultaneity is obvious, and so is the absence of price risk, non-use of own capital does not seem to be the case.
Shleifer and Vishny (1997) present a strong critique of the textbook definition of arbitrage, particularly the propositions that it requires no capital and entails no risk. They argue that almost all arbitrage operations require capital and that it is typically risky. They further argue that arbitrage is invariably conducted by a relatively small number of highly specialised investors using other people's capital. They present some examples to demonstrate the proposition that the textbook definition of arbitrage does not describe realistic trades and that the discrepancies (price anomalies) become particularly important when arbitragers manage other people's funds. They further point out, by referring to the futures markets, that arbitragers can in reality incur losses because two futures contracts traded on two different exchanges have somewhat different trading hours, settlement dates and delivery terms. If the prices move rapidly, the value of assets an arbitrager delivers and the value of assets delivered to him may differ, exposing him to additional risk of losses.
So, is there after all a generic definition of arbitrage? Although the term "arbitrage" is used to describe a number of different operations, it may still be possible to come up with a generic definition. Such a definition would be based on two characteristics that are common to all of the operations described earlier. The first is that these operations aim at exploiting price anomalies in one or more markets. The second is that each operation is triggered by the violation of a pricing equilibrium condition. This condition is the equality of the exchange rates across financial centres in the case of two-point arbitrage; the consistency of cross rates in the case of three-point arbitrage; the equality of the forward spread and the interest rate differential (covered interest parity) in the case of covered interest arbitrage; and the equality of the expected change in the exchange rate and the interest rate differential (uncovered interest parity) in the case of uncovered interest arbitrage. In all cases, arbitrage restores the equilibrium condition by changing the forces of supply and demand in the underlying markets. Hence a plausible generic definition of arbitrage is the following. Arbitrage is a profit-seeking operation aimed at exploiting price anomalies arising from the violation of a pricing equilibrium condition. This definition says nothing about the absence of risk, the use of own capital or the simultaneity of buy and sell transactions. It is the closest thing to a valid generic definition of arbitrage.
CHAPTER 4
Hedging Exposure to Foreign Exchange Risk: The Basic Concepts
4.1 DEFINITION AND MEASUREMENT OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK
Foreign exchange risk arises because of uncertainty about the exchange rate prevailing in the future (after a decision involving exchange rate expectations has been taken, such that the outcome depends on the materialisation or otherwise of the expectations). It refers to the variability of the base currency value of assets, liabilities and cash flows (contractual or otherwise) resulting from the variability of the exchange rate. Therefore foreign exchange risk arises when a firm indulges in international operations involving currencies other than the base currency, including importing, exporting, investing and financing. As a result, the firm will be exposed to assets, liabilities and cash flows denominated in currencies other than the base currency. We have to remember that foreign exchange risk is associated with unanticipated changes in exchange rates, since anticipated changes are discounted and reflected in the value of the firm.
The concept of foreign exchange risk will be illustrated by referring to an investment decision. Assume that an investor with a base currency x takes up an investment in a y-denominated asset at time t, maturing at time t + 1. If Vx and Vy are the x and y values of the asset respectively, then
Vx = S(x/y)Vy (4.1)
In what follows, we will for simplicity drop (x/y) from the symbol representing the spot exchange rate, but it is crucial to bear in mind that the exchange rate in this analysis is measured as the x price of one unit of y. The rate of return on the asset between t and t + 1 in terms of x is given by
palgrave 1
palgrave 2
i 19
i 23
CHAPTER 3 44
Other Kinds of Arbitrage and Some Extensions 46
3.1 COMMODITY ARBITRAGE 46
Py ,t+ 1/Py ,t 55
3.2 ARBITRAGE UNDER THE GOLD STANDARD 61
3.3 ARBITRAGE BETWEEN EUROCURRENCY AND DOMESTIC INTEREST RATES 63
3.4 EUROCURRENCY-EUROBOND ARBITRAGE 74
3.5 ARBITRAGE BETWEEN CURRENCY FUTURES AND FORWARD CONTRACTS 52
3.6 REAL INTEREST ARBITRAGE 54
3.7 UNCOVERED ARBITRAGE WHEN THE CROSS RATES ARE STABLE 55
3.8 UNCOVERED INTEREST ARBITRAGE WHEN THE BASE CURRENCY IS PEGGED TO A BASKET 57
^ ^ 1=1 »j ^ j=1 and 57
E1= S 0 - S j (3.40) 57
3.9 MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT ARBITRAGE 83
CHAPTER 4 65
Hedging Exposure to Foreign Exchange Risk: The Basic Concepts 65
4.1 DEFINITION AND MEASUREMENT OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK 65
4.2 VALUE AT RISK 69
4.3 DEFINITION AND MEASUREMENT OF EXPOSURE TO FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK 74
4.4 TRANSACTION EXPOSURE 82
4.5 ECONOMIC AND OPERATING EXPOSURE 84
4.6 A FORMAL TREATMENT OF OPERATING EXPOSURE 95
dQ_py_ dPy Q 102
4.7 TRANSLATION EXPOSURE 123
Financial and Operational Hedging of Exposure to Foreign Exchange Risk 105
Fb,t - Sb,t 123
p - K(Fa,t - Sb,t+ 1 ) 133
Measuring the Hedge Ratio 158
, s(DPu,t, DPA,t If t-1) ,t t . 164
h = ^ ^ r" = P(X 1,t , X 2 ,t ) 164
s 2(DP A,t|f t-1 ) 164
DP u,t = t-1 + Z ai DP U,t-i +Z bi dPa ,t-i +x 1,t (6.33) 186
DP A,t =-bft-1 + Z ci DP U,t-i +Z d i DP A,t - i +X 2 ,t (6.34) 186
s(DPU,t, DPA,t If t-1, DPU,t-i, DPA,t-i) 186
s2 (APA,t If t-1' APU,t-i ' APA,t-i ) (6 35) 186
I,t ' X 2,t ) / s(X i,t ) ^ 186
= P(X 1't ' X 2 ,t ) 186
_ P(X 1,t , X 2 ,t)s(X 1,t)s(X 2 ,t) -2 (f t-11 AP U,t-i, APA,t-i) 187
s2 (X2 ,t ) + b2 s 2 (f t-11 APU,t-i, APA,t-i ) 187
Speculation in the Spot and Currency Derivative Markets 184
Sb,t 198
Sb,t 1 + m 198
Sb,t 1 + E(mt+1) 199
E( Sb,t+1 ), S 200
if the position in x is available. If the funds have to be borrowed, the condition changes to 201
Speculation: Generating Buy and 209
Sell Signals 209
St = f (Xt) 257
where the vector of variables varies according to the underlying fundamental model. The current level of the exchange rate may deviate from the equilibrium level because of the effect of random shocks that tend to have a temporary effect. Hence the current level of the exchange rate may be represented by 258
