Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Person-Centered Psychotherapies - Cain, David J...rtf
Скачиваний:
1
Добавлен:
01.07.2025
Размер:
566 Кб
Скачать
☆

Unconditional Positive Regard

Twenty-four relatively recent studies address therapists’ “affirmation” of clients, a concept that includes acceptance, nonpossessive warmth, and unconditional positive regard. A large majority of the studies showed a positive correlation between affirmation and client outcomes, while some findings were neutral and only one was negative (Orlinsky, Grawe, & Parks, 1994). Combining the findings of Orlinsky, Grawe, and Park with studies from Orlinsky and Howard’s earlier (1986) review, Farber and Lane (2002) note that the authors

summarized the results of 154 findings . . . drawn from a total of 76 studies. They found that 56% of the findings were positive, and that, again, the findings based on the patients’ . . . sense of the therapist’s positive regard yielded even a higher rate of positive therapeutic outcomes, 65%. (p. 184)

In sum, 87 findings showed a statistically significant positive relationship between therapist affirmation and positive outcomes, 63 findings showed no relationship, and 4 showed a negative relationship. Thus, the research evidence for therapist unconditional positive regard is substantial. Further, while therapist unconditional positive regard may, at times, show no demonstrable effect on client outcome, it is rarely negatively related to outcome. Clinical observation and everyday experience suggest that most persons/clients find another’s regard or affirmation to be supportive and therapeutic. Conversely, therapist responses that impair therapy include: boredom; rote and impersonal responses; lack of compassion, understanding, and respect; coldness or arrogance; and irritation or anger—all in clear contrast to acceptance and regard (Feifel & Eels, 1963; Glass & Arnkoff, 2000).

Congruence

The research on the impact of therapist congruence has been more ambiguous and contradictory. Of 77 results reviewed, only 34% showed a positive correlation with positive outcomes, while two thirds showed no correlation. No negative relationships between therapist congruence and outcome were found. When clients rated their therapists, results were somewhat more positive (Klein, Kolden, Michels, & Chisholm-Stockard, 2002). These authors conclude that “there is both empirical and theoretical justification for congruence as a central component of a complex conception of the therapy process” (p. 396). Studies that ask clients to identify the most important aspects of their therapy in relationship to outcome find that therapist openness, realness, or genuineness are rarely cited (Burckell & Goldfried, 2006; Feifel & Eels, 1963). However, it is interesting to note that therapist trustworthiness does emerge as an important characteristic identified by clients in good outcomes (Burckell & Goldfried, 2006; Conte, Ratto, Clutz, & Karasu, 1995). It is likely that therapist trustworthiness lends credibility to therapist empathy and unconditional positive regard.

It is difficult to make sense of these inconsistent findings. Kirschenbaum (1979) believes, as I do, that congruence was the least clearly defined and understood of Rogers’s core conditions. In sum, because congruence remains “the most difficult of the core conditions for therapists to get right” (Kirschenbaum & Jourdan, 2005, p. 43), conceptual clarity about the meaning of congruence is needed as well as research to understand better how and when congruence can be communicated therapeutically and without harm.

RESEARCH ON OTHER PERSON-CENTERED PSYCHOTHERAPIES

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]