- •English for senior students of economics Издание 2-е, исправленное и дополненное
- •Coherence in the Text 10
- •The Art of Writing Précis and Abstract 20
- •Panel Power 62
- •Transition economies: Analytical Reading, Writing and Discussion
- •Investment (n)
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Important Steps for Précis Writing
- •Thematic areas
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Institutions in a market economy
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Vocabulary Check-up
- •By Bill Hennefrund
- •Part II
- •Building a financial system:
- •Creative Writing
- •And Report Making
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Vocabulary Box
- •Edit Your words for clarity, simplicity and brevity
- •Incorporating source material into your paper
- •Ias is not a cure
- •Glossary II
- •Pattern 2
- •Pattern 9
- •Pattern 10 Econometric Society Monographs
- •Pattern 11
- •It takes two
- •Pattern 13
- •Pattern 14
- •Working Wisdom
- •Clichés
- •Protectionism and World Welfare
- •Pattern 16 Capital Markets and Financial Intermediation
- •Pattern 17 The Cooperative Nature of the Firm
- •Pattern 18
- •Pattern 21
- •Pattern 22
- •Supplement II
- •115407, Москва, Судостроительная ул., 59
By Bill Hennefrund
Plan ahead, be prepared for anything,
and you're sure to be a successful panelist.
“There’s a version of Murphy’s Law that applies to a panel discussion”, says Dr. Paul Kerschner, a veteran public speaker. “It goes like this: ‘If something can go wrong in public, it will go wrong in a panel discussion.’ ”
This is a simple truth that speakers are discovering as the panel discussion format becomes more popular. They find to their dismay that any and all of the following things can happen:
The panel organizer has planned the event for months. But while you're waiting for your turn to speak, another panelist covers essentially the same points you planned to cover.
Without notifying the other panelists, the organizer has added a new person to the panel. That individual delivers a 20-minute speech — twice as much time as anyone else has been given. When its your turn, the moderator asks you to please pare your comments to five minutes.
At the last minute, a new panel moderator has been named. This person is well acquainted with the other three panelists and directs all questions to them. You are simply ignored.
Planning can help a speaker avoid most mishaps. But the speaker who really wants to put on a winning performance aspires to do much more than simply stay out of trouble. Such a speaker should reach for two goals: to give an effective presentation and contribute to the success of the panel. Following are some steps to help you achieve “Panel Power”:
Nail down your subject.
The panel organizer — if he or she does the job right — will assign an aspect of the main topic to each panel member. But all too often, the assignment is left to the last minute and several speakers end up covering the same material.
So a good first step when you are invited to be a panelist is to get in touch with the other panelists as far in advance as possible, and to stake out the area of your subject. Don't wait for the panel organizer to contact you: that day may never come.
Reduce your message to one sentence.
Theories abound as to the best way to organize a formal speech, but when it comes to a panel discussion it's best to settle for a single point. (I'm assuming that each panelist has been asked to speak for 10 minutes, then answer questions after the others have made their presentations.)
Novice panelists often make the mistake of trying to reduce a 20- or 30-minute speech to the allotted 10 or 12 minutes. The result is a breathless presentation that covers four or five points without any elaboration. This only spells confusion.
Try reducing your 10-minute presentation to a single sentence: “Health costs are higher than you think”; “Consumers need more information”; “Mass transit is in peril.” Anything that isn't directly related to the single point, of course, doesn't belong in your opening remarks.
Consider “showing” as well as “telling.”
For some strange reason, many speakers overlook the possibility of dramatizing a short presentation. The device needn't be anything elaborate; a simple attention-getter will do.
S
cout
the audience.
Experienced speakers often acquire the uncanny knack of rapidly sizing up an audience; they can dispense with elaborate investigation. But if you don’t belong in this class, you'll find it helpful to ask some questions about the audience in advance.
Know your fellow panelists.
There's something awkward about a panel composed of people who obviously have never met before. The tone of such a panel is all wrong, and the audience senses it. Awkwardness can be avoided if the panelists briefly meet and relax with each other before the discussion starts.
Learn how to field questions.
Many program organizers see the question period following a presentation as the “heart” of the panel format. It therefore makes sense to prepare as much for the question period as for your formal remarks.
From your knowledge of your topic, you can anticipate the kinds of questions your audience may ask. Complete a list of such questions, and work out the answers. Again, don't try to cover too much ground; make it simple.
At some point, be sure to ask the panel organizer whether questions will be asked from the floor or if the audience will be instructed to write them on cards that will be collected by the moderator. If the questions are written, that will give you extra time to prepare your answers.
Stay strictly within your allotted time.
Many panelists, accustomed to giving longer speeches, is tempted to stray from the point of the talk. This tacks more time onto the presentation. And if every speaker on the panel exceeds the time limit, the whole program will be out of killer.
Get your share of questions.
The question period is no time to turn shy. If you aren't getting your share of questions, don't hesitate to jump in at the end of another panelist's answer.
Pick it up quickly and smoothly: “I'll just add a thought to what Jane just said, and it’s simply this...” Or: “What Jim just said fits exactly with my experience, but I would like to add one thought...”
On the other hand, if you seem to be getting more than your share of questions, refer some of them to other panel members. Say something like: “Well, that question gets into an area where Jane is really more knowledgeable than I am. Jane, would you like to take over that one?”
What if there are no questions? That's unlikely. But if the question period is slow in starting, and the moderator can't seem to get things rolling, jump in with a question of your own: “I'm sure a lot of people in our audience are wondering about the statement Jane made about the rate of inflation. I know I was, so I’ll just ask it myself...”
Learn from every panel experience.
Speakers learn something every time they participate in a panel discussion. And every time something goes wrong, they tuck that information back in their heads to make sure it doesn't happen again.
Using the quotes below as a springboard, organize a round-table discussion.
“The recent experience of unemployment in eastern Europe and the states of the former Soviet Union has been diverse and prospects are mixed. Understanding the dynamics and nature of unemployment in these economies is essential for the developing policies that are consistent with furthering reform.” 1 |
-
Time to Rethink Privatization in Transition Economies
“Privatization has won the day in transition countries … or has it? Where have privatization efforts — particularly those in central and Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union — succeeded, where have they failed, and how can these countries best pursue further privatization?” 2
A Decade of Transition An Overview of The Achievements And Challenges “Yet the challenges that remain are enormous. We are clearly far from the end of the road... Now, most countries can turn to the much more difficult and time-consuming task of implementing second-generation reforms.” He highlighted one specific task for the future: “enforcing the rule of law and fostering a culture that respects and, indeed, welcomes a framework of law, regulation, and codes of good practice.” 3 |
-
Transition
and
The Changing Role
of Government“Over the past decade, many centrally planned economies have set out to transform themselves into market economies. To be successful, they need to develop the necessary institutions and ensure a proper role for government.” 4
From Centralized to Decentralized Governance “Decentralization can foster political stability and economic development — if transfers of resources and responsibilities are carefully coordinated and intergovernmental relationships are clearly defined.” 5 |
-
Cleaning up
“The global economy has made money laundering easier and less detectable.”
“If you are in the business of trying to hide needles,
you look for large haystacks.” 6
The Russian Economy: Prospects and Retrospects “Over the course of time, we can see Russia increasingly taking its role as a major country in the international system, helping lead the IMF and helping develop the international system. Russia and the IMF would also cooperate to solve problems that we have in common, for example the difficulties of the Central Asian republics.” 7 |
R
eferences:
1 Oliver Blanchard, Simon Commander, and Fabrizio Coricelli. F&D, December, 1994.
2 John Nellis. F&D, June, 1999.
3 Saleh M. Nsouli. F&D, June, 1999.
4 Vito Tanzi. F&D, June, 1999.
5 William Dillinger and Marianne Fay. F&D, December, 1999.
6 John William. Financial Times. September, 2001.
7 Stanley Fisher. F&D, June, 2001.

Hard
Realities