- •Rome and britain
- •In Rome, the authorities looked to rely on a system whereby the
- •Into effect. As we have noted, Julius Caesar saw the empire as
- •Increasingly similar to the legions, and Hadrian (ad 117–138)
- •Increased (and increasing) bureaucracy, though no dramatic
- •Indication of how it might be done.
- •The later years
- •In Britain not as an event, but as a process, extending over a
- •Internal to the empire – the political ‘muscle-flexing’ of the army,
- •Irregular oval encompassing a small hill-top. Some had bastions
- •It is often suggested that the second half of the third century
- •Villas reach a previously unknown level of development and opulence
- •It may be that it was due to changing military arrangements
- •In the west were maintained by coastal shipping; the
- •It is possible that the two separate commands given earlier in
- •In development and refurbishment, and much of what money
- •It is important that we divest ourselves of older notions of
- •View of Romano–British culture giving way in the face of a
It is important that we divest ourselves of older notions of
substantial ‘Roman’ emigration from Britain and, indeed, of
Britons who were glad to see an end to three-and-a-half centuries
of ‘servitude’. Whatever truth there may have been in Calgacus’
strictures in the first century ad, they had no relevance at the close
of the fourth. Indeed, it appears that the main issue was
not whether to defend Romano–British culture, but how best to
achieve this.
There is accumulating, though still geographically patchy, evidence
to suggest that there were differing responses to the crisis
facing Roman Britain in different parts of the province. Zosimus,
for example, provides evidence of conflict at the turn of the fourth
and fifth centuries when he alludes to groups who drove out their
Roman officials. At first sight, this appears to confirm the traditional
View of Romano–British culture giving way in the face of a
re-emerging Celtic nationalism. However, it has been suggested
that the reality may have been outbreaks of conflict between two
groups who, in their different ways, were equally committed to
the defence of Romano–British culture: one group – perhaps the
descendants of the old civitas-leaders – was anxious to maintain institutional links with the empire’s centre and thus to preserve
the old, ordered, certainties of life; the other, however, more
realistic in its outlook, appreciated that such institutional links
with the empire lay in the past and that the only way to defend its
Romano–British culture was to be ‘pro-active’, and take matters
into its own hands.
It is this latter attitude which, it has been suggested, sprang
from the Pelagian heresy (see above in Chapter 6). The principal
tenet of the heresy was to deny the act of Divine Grace, arguing
that man was the master of his own salvation. Translated into the
contemporary military and political realities of Roman Britain,
this heresy was an indication of the independence of thinking of
men who were prepared to defend their Romano–British identity
by their own vigorous actions. They drove out those who were
waiting for Rome to defend them and assumed the initiative for
this themselves. Importantly, the desire to defend Romano–
British culture was as great on the part of those who were being
attacked.
The evidence points to localised success on the part of both of
these groups with their different methods: the local success of the
civitas-leaders in St Albans is shown by St Germanus’ visit to
Britain in ad 429 in an effort to deal with Pelagianism. Similarly,
the influence of such men can be seen in the continuation of some
kind of Romanised life at Cirencester into the fifth century, and
their organisation of the defence of the community using the site of the amphitheatre just outside the town walls. At Wroxeter,
archaeology has shown attempts to keep the basilica of the bathbuilding
in some kind of repair, again well into the fifth century,
although the re-occupation of the hill-fort site at the Wrekin may
indicate that ultimately the more militarily minded members of
the community had their way, perhaps as it became clear that, for
a variety of reasons, the sites of Romano–British towns were not
capable of prolonged defence. Recent work at Silchester has
thrown the difference of attitude of these groups into sharp relief:
whilst many communities changed gradually and with time, the
Romano–British of Silchester strove to isolate themselves from
their neighbours and thus keep their culture intact. Evidently,
they went as far as cutting communications with their neighbours,
maintaining their isolation until they were eventually
overwhelmed. Their exclusiveness ultimately, therefore, proved
fatal to Romano–British Silchester.
In the north of Britain, recent excavations at the fort of
Birdoswald (on Hadrian’s Wall) have highlighted a similar
independence of spirit. It is suggested that, through the fourth
century, the growing size of the houses of fort-commanders in the
north points to subtle changes taking place in the status of such
men – that, in effect, they were becoming the leaders of local
militia-groups which perhaps occupied forts, together with the
survivors of the adjacent vicus-populations. Such groups increasingly
operated independently, no longer subject to any kind of
overall control.
At Birdoswald, it has been shown that successive phases of
hall-like structures stood, first on the demolished remains of the
southern granary, and latterly overlapping the site of the former
northern granary and part of the adjacent road. With no coherent
authority collecting taxes any longer in the hinterland of the fort,
the militia perhaps took payment in kind in return for providing
protection from bandits and marauders. In this way, the former
fort-commanders were being transformed into local ‘warlords’.
This appears to provide a reasonable interpretation of the evidence
from Birdoswald, but it has to be stressed that, whilst there are
possible indications of similar changes elsewhere (for example, at
Ravenglass and Bowness-on-Solway), they have yet to be established
with certainty.
However, names such as Vortigern (‘mighty leader’) and Arthur
(‘bear-man’) indicate that the more spirited Romano–British survivors
fought to defend their heritage; the ‘fort-villages’ of the
north may have provided centres for such activity. However,
although the formal power of Rome had certainly passed by the
early part of the fifth century – the time at which the watchtowers
of the Yorkshire coast apparently ceased to operate – the individualistic
efforts of the Romano–British within or without their
Romanised centres demonstrated that, in the minds of most, the
Roman peace was, despite increasing difficulties and growing
desperation, worth the effort to defend it. In the minds of the late
Romano–British, Roman Britain was not to be dismissed as a
passing interlude.
