Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
предрассудки и суеверия.doc
Скачиваний:
3
Добавлен:
01.07.2025
Размер:
477 Кб
Скачать
☆

XXII. Debating the Issue:

You are going to take part in a panel discussion entitled ‘Near Death Experiences – Fact or Fiction?’

      1. Preparation for the Debate:

a Write down a list of points either for or against the idea of Near Death Experiences. Use the suggested ideas to help you.

b Try to anticipate the arguments the other group are going to come up with and think of an answer to them.

c Think of as many ways of giving opinions and agreeing and disagreeing as you can. Look at the Useful Language. Which expressions do you think are the most and least strong?

d Include in your arguments evidence from a ‘real life witness’, - one of your group can pretend to have had an NDE.

Work in groups. One Group (Group A) is going to defend the motion and the other Group (Group B) is going to attack it.

      1. Procedure

  1. A chairperson from the whole group will open the panel discussion and invite representatives from each side to speak. Give each side a time limit.

  2. Invite questions and comments from the rest of the group.

  3. Take a vote on which side was most convincing.

  4. The chairperson should make a few concluding remarks.

3.In pairs write a plan for an essay “Do Near Death Experiences Really Exist?”

  1. Introduction (background) – what they are, and why they’re important.

  2. The case for.

  3. The case against.

  4. Your opinion and conclusion.

Group A: Ideas.

- Take a list of all the reasons you can think of as to why the experiences should be taken seriously.

- Decide in what order you should make the points.

- Have “a real life witness” to give his /her experience as convincingly as possible.

- Think of questions which you will ask the other group, or points you will make, to try to defeat their argument.

- Appoint two “spokespeople” to present the case, as well as the “witness /witnesses”.

Useful Language

Giving Opinions:

In my opinion… I think /I believe…

It is clear /obvious that….

There is no doubt that….

Agreeing:

Exactly! I couldn’t agree any more…

(I agree ) absolutely. You’ve got a point, but… .

Possibly, but… (see also p. 27-28)

Disagreeing:

Do you really think so?

I’m sorry, but I just can’t accept that.

That’s ridiculous /impossible.

You can’t be serious. (see also p. 27-28)

Group B: Ideas.

-Think of as many reasons as you can why these experiences cannot really be valid and try to suggest other explanations for them. Make a list of these reasons.

Example: The out of body sensation is really a trick of the mind and really the floating is based on memory and imagination. The dark tunnels are the visual cells which are not working well, as people are dying. It could be due to lack of oxygen.

-One of you should invent a “negative” experience that you had, which you think disproves the other experiences you heard or read about above. Argue for it being the effect of drugs, etc. when you are very ill.

-Decide in what order you will make the points.

-Think of questions to ask the other group or points to put to them which may defeat their argument.

-Decide on two “spokespeople” from your group as well as a “witness” who will present your case.

XXIII. Write an imaginary letter to Steve Redmond, the producer of the radio programme, telling him about your / or someone you know “Out of the Body” or “Near Death Experiences”.