- •Preface
- •Acknowledgements
- •Introduction
- •Russian Imperial Archaeology (pre-1917)
- •Soviet Archaeology (1917–1991)
- •Marxist-Leninist Ideology
- •Intellectual Climate under Stalin
- •Archaeology in the Caucasus since PERESTROIKA (1991–present)
- •Post–World War II
- •‘Swings and Roundabouts’
- •PROBLEMS IN THE STUDY OF CAUCASIAN ARCHAEOLOGY
- •1 The Land and Its Languages
- •GEOGRAPHY AND RESOURCES
- •Physical Geography
- •Mineral Resources
- •VEGETATION AND CLIMATE
- •GEOMORPHOLOGY
- •THE LANGUAGES OF THE CAUCASUS AND DNA
- •HOMININ ARRIVALS IN THE LOWER PALAEOLITHIC
- •Characteristics of the Earliest Settlers
- •Lake Sites, Caves, and Scatters
- •Technological Trends
- •Acheulean Hand Axe Technology
- •Diet
- •Matuzka Cave and Mezmaiskaya Cave – Mousterian Sites
- •The Southern Caucasus
- •Ortvale Klde
- •Djruchula Klde
- •Other sites
- •The Demise of the Neanderthals and the End of the Middle Palaeolithic
- •NOVEL TECHNOLOGY AND NEW ARRIVALS: THE UPPER PALAEOLITHIC (35,000–10,000 BC?)
- •ROCK ART AND RITUAL
- •CONCLUSION
- •INTRODUCTION
- •THE FIRST FARMERS
- •A PRE-POTTERY NEOLITHIC?
- •Western Georgia
- •POTTERY NEOLITHIC: THE CENTRAL AND SOUTHERN CAUCASUS
- •Houses and Settlements
- •The Kura Corridor
- •The Ararat Plain
- •The Nakhichevan Region, Mil Plain, and the Mugan Steppes
- •Ditches
- •Burial and Human Body Representations
- •Materiality and Social Relations
- •Ceramic Vessels
- •Chipped and Ground Stone
- •Bone and Antler
- •Metals, Metallurgy and Other Crafts
- •THE CENTRAL AND NORTHERN CAUCASUS
- •CONTACT AND EXCHANGE: OBSIDIAN
- •Patterns of Procurement
- •CONCLUSION
- •The Pre-Maikop Horizon (ca. 4500–3800 BC)
- •The Maikop Culture
- •Distribution and Main Characteristics
- •The Chronology of the Maikop Culture
- •Villages and Households
- •Barrows and Burials
- •The Inequality of Maikop Society
- •Death as a Performance and the Persistence of Memory
- •The Crafts
- •THE SOUTHERN CAUCASUS
- •Ceramics and Metalwork
- •Houses and Settlements
- •The Treatment of the Dead
- •The Sioni Tradition (ca. 4800/4600–3200 BC)
- •Settlements and Subsistence
- •Sioni Cultural Tradition
- •Chipped Stone Tools and Other Technologies
- •CONCLUSIONS
- •BORDERS AND FRONTIERS
- •Georgia
- •Armenia
- •Azerbaijan
- •Eastern Anatolia
- •Iran
- •Amuq Plain and the Levantine Coastal Region
- •Cyprus
- •Early Settlements: Houses, Hearths, and Pits
- •Later Settlements: Diversity in Plan and Construction
- •Freestanding Wattle-and-Daub Structures
- •Villages of Circular Structures
- •Stone and Mud-brick Rectangular Houses
- •Terraced Settlements
- •Semi-Subterranean Structures
- •Burial customs
- •Sacred Spaces
- •Structures
- •Hearths
- •Early Ceramics
- •Monochrome Ware
- •Enduring Chaff-Face Wares
- •Burnished Wares
- •LATE CERAMICS
- •The Northern (Shida Kartli) Tradition
- •The Central (Tsalka) Tradition
- •The Southern (Armenian) Tradition
- •MINING FOR METAL AND ORE
- •STONE AND BONE TOOLS AND METALWORK
- •Trace Element Analyses
- •SALT AND SALT MINING
- •THE PROCESS OF MIGRATION
- •The Mobile and the Settled – The Economy of the Kura-Araxes
- •Animal Husbandry
- •Agricultural Practices
- •CONCLUSION
- •FUNERARY CUSTOMS AND BURIAL GOODS
- •MONUMENTALISM AND ITS MEANING IN THE WESTERN CAUCASUS
- •CHRONOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS
- •THE NATURE OF THE EVIDENCE
- •THE SOUTHERN CAUCASUS
- •EARLY BRONZE AGE IV/MIDDLE BRONZE AGE I (2500–2000 BC)
- •Sachkhere: A Bridging Site
- •Martkopi and Early Trialeti Barrows
- •Bedeni Barrows
- •Ananauri Barrow 3
- •Bedeni Barrows
- •Other Bedeni Barrows
- •Bedeni Settlements
- •Berikldeebi Village
- •Berikldeebi Pits
- •Other Bedeni Villages
- •Crafts and Technology
- •Ceramics
- •Woodworking
- •Flaked stone
- •Sacred Spaces
- •The Economic Subsistence
- •The Trialeti Complex (The Developed Stage)
- •Categorisation
- •Mound Types
- •Burial Customs and Tomb Architecture
- •Ritual Roads
- •Human Skeletal Material
- •The Zurtaketi Barrows
- •The Meskheti Barrows
- •The Atsquri Barrow
- •Ephemeral Settlements
- •Gold and Silver, Stone, and Clay
- •Silver Goblets: The Narratives
- •Silver Goblets: Interpretations
- •More Metal Containers
- •Gold Work
- •Tools and Weapons
- •Burial Ceramics
- •Settlement Ceramics
- •The Brili Cemetery
- •WAGONS AND CARTS
- •Origins and Distribution
- •The Caucasian Evidence
- •Late Bronze Age Vehicles
- •Burials and Animal Remains
- •THE MIDDLE BRONZE AGE III (CA. 1700–1450 BC)
- •The Karmirberd (Tazakend) Horizon
- •Sevan-Uzerlik Horizon
- •The Kizyl Vank Horizon
- •Apsheron Peninsula
- •THE NORTHERN CAUCASUS
- •The North Caucasian Culture
- •Catacomb Tombs
- •Stone Cist Tombs
- •Wooden Graves
- •CONCLUSIONS
- •THE CAUCASUS FROM 1500 TO 800 BC
- •Fortresses
- •Settlements
- •Burial Customs
- •Metalwork
- •Ceramics
- •Sacred Spaces
- •Menhirs
- •SAMTAVRO AND SHIDA KARTLI
- •Burial Types
- •Settlements
- •THE TALISH TRADITION
- •CONCLUSION
- •KOBAN AND COLCHIAN: ONE OR TWO TRADITIONS?
- •KOBAN: ITS PERIODISATION AND CONNECTIONS
- •SETTLEMENTS
- •Symmetrical and Linear Structures
- •TOMB TYPES AND BURIAL GROUNDS
- •THE KOBAN BURIAL GROUND
- •COSTUMES AND RANK
- •WARRIOR SYMBOLS
- •TLI AND THE CENTRAL REGION
- •WHY METALS MATTERED
- •KOBAN METALWORK
- •Jewellery and Costume Accessories
- •METAL VESSELS
- •CERAMICS
- •CONCLUSION
- •10 A World Apart: The Colchian Culture
- •SETTLEMENTS, DITCHES, AND CANALS
- •Pichori
- •HOARDS AND THE DESTRUCTION OF WEALTH
- •CERAMIC PRODUCTION
- •Tin in the Caucasus?
- •The Rise of Iron
- •Copper-Smelting through Iron Production
- •CONCLUSION
- •11 The Grand Challenges for the Archaeology of the Caucasus
- •References
- •Index
120 |
Transition to Settled Life |
Shomutepe, with one room containing 155 examples.104 A similar situation has been reported for the north-western Caucasus.105
Bone and Antler
Bone and antler tools are also very common in the south central and southern Caucasus, but their distribution is by no means homogenous (Figures 3.14 and 3.15). Antler hoes, for instance, so common at sites in Kvemo Kartli and also at Göytepe, are absent from Aratashen.106 The industry is highly developed at Imiris Gora, Khramis Didi Gora, Shomutepe, and Göytepe. The assemblage includes awls, borers, and socketed hoes (Figure 3.14). At Shomutepe we also have an eyed needle and a spoon, similar to those found at Kvemo-Kartli sites and at Aratashen.
Kiguradze defined several clear evolutionary stages in bone tool production for the Kvemo Kartli sites: Stage I (Shulaveri Gora IX–IV) yielded very few bone artefacts, mostly awls, borers, spoons, and antler hoes. The same set of tools is found in Stage II, which now also included a needle, a toggle pin, and a pendant made from the jaw of a dog. Many ‘polishers’, some incised, made from cattle bones are also part of the repertoire. These may have been used for burnishing leather, or even as netting spacers. From Imiris Gora come two projectile points. Hoes were particularly massive, comprising a perforated segment of a large antler crown.The bone tools from western Azerbaijan are not as clearly differentiated, though the number of hoes suggests some association with the upper levels at Imiris Gora.107
The general trend in bone production amongst the Shulaveri-Shomutepe sites, then, is an increase in quantity and diversity, especially in agricultural (and fishing) implements such as hoes and polishers (netting spacers or spacers for textiles generally), from the lower levels at Shulaveri Gora onwards. Curiously, however, neither bone nor clay spindle-whorls are amongst the Kvemo Kartli finds. Bone tools more than ceramics have affinities with neighbouring regions. Anatolian connections are seen in the finely carved spoons (Figure 3.15(9)), which are found as far away as Ilıpınar in the north-west, where they are particularly common.108 Shaft-hole hammers made from antler are part of the Tilkitepe Level III assemblage, and piercing tools and spatulae are also fairly ubiquitous.
The Ararat region also has a rich bone industry, particularly well represented at Aratashen. A vast number of items came from Level IIb, including awls, projectile points, spatulae, hoes, sickle handles, ‘dibbles’ (a small hand implement used to make holes in soil, especially for planting bulbs or seedlings),
104Narimanov 1965: 49.
105Formozov 1965: 58.
106Lyonnet and Guliyev 2010: 222; Badalyan et al. 2007.
107Korobkova 1979.
108Sagona and Zimansky 2009: fig. 4.21.
Figure 3.14. A selection of Neolithic bone tools from the southern Caucasus: (1–2, 5–6) Khramis Didi Gora (after Kiguradze 1986); (3) Aratashen (courtesy R. Badalyan);
(4) Shulaveris Gora (after Kiguradze 1986, photograph A. Sagona).
121
Figure 3.15. A selection of Neolithic bone tools: (1–2, 4, 6–8) Imiris Gora (after Kiguradze 1986); (5, 9, 11, 17) Aratashen (courtesy R. Badalyan); (3, 10, 12–16) Khramis Didi Gora (after Kigurade 1986, photographs A. Sagona).
122
Pottery Neolithic: The Central and Southern Caucasus |
123 |
and spoons.109 Of the Mil-Mugan group, Göytepe has a particularly rich bone assemblage – shovels, perforated antler hoes similar to those found at Kvemo Kartli sites, and hammers ornamented with incisions.110 Much the same repertoire is found at Kültepe,Alikemek Tepesi, and Tekhut, where a sickle haft was made from a cattle femur.
Metals, Metallurgy and Other Crafts
The late sixth and early fifth millennia BC ushered in metalworking in the southern Caucasus. Of considerable interest are a few metal objects of indeterminate purpose from Kültepe I, whose elemental constituents included arsenic (1.1–1.5 per cent) and nickel (1.6 per cent).111 Metal objects from Tekhut, including a couple of sections of a square-sectioned awl, also yielded high arsenic readings.112 From the uppermost horizon at Alikemek Tepesi came 150 beads, some made from copper. From Level IIb at Aratashen came a copper bracelet made from fifty-seven beads of rolled copper leaf with an average weight of less than half a gram each.There are comparable items from Kvemo Kartli (at Khramis Didi Gora, Gargalar Tepesi and Arukhlo), where several pieces of azurite have also been found at Arukhlo, but the strongest pulses in this fledgling metal industry came from Mil-Mugan steppes and the Ararat Plain.113
Special items and evidence of jewellery began to emerge.Two mace-heads from Arukhlo are significant small finds: one is knobbed and fashioned from basalt, and unknown within the Shulaveri-Shomutepe group, whereas the other is circular.114 At Kamiltepe, 3,766 shell fragments, the debris from bead production, point to an active bead workshop.115 Finally, we see the beginnings of far-flung connections with central Asia and its borderlands in a handful of turquoise and carnelian beads from several of the sites.116
Plants,Animals, and People
The earliest farmers of the southern Caucasus did not choose the alluvium of the Iori and Alazani valleys, the most fertile areas in the region, but preferred the light chestnut soils, where dry farming of cereals involves a considerable amount of risk. Proximity to stands of wild cereals and the general increase
109Badalyan et al. 2007: 49–50.
110Narimanov 1965: 50, 1987; Kiguradze 1976: 157–8; Lyonnet and Guliyev 2010: 222; Guliyev and Nishiaki 2012a, 2012b.
111Selimkhanov and Mareshal 1966: 146–7.
112Selimkhanov and Mareshal 1966: 145–6.
113Hansen and Mirtskhulava 2012: 84–5.
114Bastert-Lamprichs and Scholtzhauer 2011: fig. 48.
115Heit 2012: 48.
116Arukhlo (Neumann 2012: figs 124, 125).
124 |
Transition to Settled Life |
in precipitation at the beginning of the Neolithic no doubt played a role in determining the choice of site.117 These sedentary communities in the KuraAraxes basin appear on the scene with a broad spectrum of crops (emmer, hulled barley, lentil, grass pea, and bitter vetch) and domesticated animals, although regional variations occur.118 Interestingly, this diversity of crops is far greater than is found at early agricultural sites located on the eastern side of the Caspian Sea, in the Gorgan Plain of Iran and in south-western Turkmenistan, where pulses are absent.119 In terms of animal remains, recent systematic evidence from Aratashen, Aknashen-Khatunarkh, Kamiltepe, Mentesh Tepe, and Arukhlo I date the arrival of domesticated animals securely to the very beginning of the sixth millennium BC.120 Compared to neighbouring regions, subsistence strategies arrived late in the Caucasus. As Rémi Berthon aptly wrote, ‘The upper limit of the radiocarbon range at Arukhlo I is 2500 years later than the earliest sheep, goat and pig in the Upper Euphrates region and 1500 years later than the earliest domestic cattle in the same region’.121
In a study of the material from Neolithic sites of Aratashen and AknashenKhatunarkh, we learn that farmers cultivated naked barley and possibly naked (free-threshing) wheat, as well as emmer and hulled barley.122 Crop-processing residues found in remnants of pisé reveal two wild crucifers, Camelina microcarpa (false fl ax) and Alyssum desertorum (alyssum), possibly used as a source of oil. Other finds include pulses, Lens culinaris (small-seeded lentil), and Vicia ervilia (bitter vetch).
The community at Shulaveri Gora had a fully fledged economy based primarily on animal husbandry.They raised sheep, goats, pigs, and cattle, and supplemented their subsistence economy with hunting and fishing.123 According to some researchers, the southern Caucasus was one of seven centres of farming in the ancient Near East.124 One of its most remarkable features is the diversity of its wheat species, of which ten have been identified in Neolithic deposits: Triticum aestivum (T. vulgare), T. compactum, T. dicoccum, T. aegilopoides, T. spelta, T. sphaerococcum, T. durum, T. macha, T. carthlicum (T. persicum), and T. turgidum. Farmers also grew fl atand multi-line species of barley, sorghum, oats, lentils, the common pea, and probably millet. Other than T. turgidum, all these species were found at the Kvemo Kartli sites.
From a global perspective, however, it is the discovery of the earliest domesticated grape pips (Vitis vinifera vinifera) from Shulaveri Gora that has captured
117Lisitsina and Prishchepenko 1977; Lisitsina 1978; Connor and Sagona 2007.
118Hansen et al. 2006; Hovsepyan and Willcox 2008; Berthon 2014.
119Decaix and Tengberg 2015.
120Berthon 2014.
121Berthon 2014: 9.
122Hovsepyan and Willcox 2008.
123Tsitsishvili 1969: 27–35.
124Lisitsina and Prishchepenko 1977: 43.
