Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Antonio Sagona, The Archaeology of the Caucasus From Earliest Settlements to the Iron Age .pdf
Скачиваний:
123
Добавлен:
28.12.2021
Размер:
96 Мб
Скачать
☆

The Maikop Culture (CA. 3800–2800 BC) and Its Predecessors

143

substance and highly symbolic. It is its ‘redness’, a visually stimulating colour, which is so appealing to humans. In many cultures extending back into the Palaeolithic, red ochre was often associated with blood, vigour, and life.27 The vast majority of burials at Nal’chik had no grave goods. Graves 46, 54, 55, 83, 86, and 92 did include grave goods, and the dead wore jewellery, mostly necklaces, comprising perforated animal teeth (wild boar, deer wolf, bear, and other beasts), and beads crafted from sea-shell (the limpet Helcion pectunculus) and stone. One individual in Grave 86 had a copper wire laid across the skull, and two stone bangles, one on each wrist (Figure 4.3(1)). From another grave came a stylised (seated?) human figurine carved from a soft stone, possibly marl. It has a constricted neck and waist, and is perforated at the base so it could be worn as a pendant. Pottery, agricultural, and domestic items were not placed in tombs.A stone statuette of a woman with exaggerated waist and legs, found near a globular mace, provides evidence for artistic endeavours, but we do not know from which burial it derives.

Munchaev dates Nal’chik to the second half of the fourth millennium BC, based on loose connections with the Near East, but – taking into account today’s evidence – a higher date is more likely.28 We only have a single radiocarbon date from Nal’chik, which might have been contaminated. Nevertheless, the reading tallies with similarities in material culture from Kamennonmost Cave,Level 2,stratified beneath Maikop-like material,and Staronizhesteblievsk, which would place Nal’chik in the region of 5000–4500 BC.29 Although the information from Nal’chik is insufficient to provide any sort of detailed picture of life and death in the northern Caucasus, the introduction of barrow burials, a mode of funerary construction that became popular centuries later, is important to note.

The Maikop Culture

Distribution and Main Characteristics

Turning to the Maikop culture, a term presciently coined by Evegnii Krupnov at a time when only a few sites were known, we are confronted with a distinctive north Caucasian tradition currently represented by about 300 barrow burials (kurgans) and more than thirty settlements (Figure 4.2).30 The complex came to the attention of antiquarian circles in 1897 when Nikolai Ivanovich Veselovskii excavated the Oshad kurgan, situated in the town of Maikop, still

27Sagona 1994a; Hovers et al. 2003.

28Munchaev 1982: 130.

29Korenevskii 2004: 65.The precise details of the date have not been published; Anthony 2007: 187.

30Krupnov 1957: 46–73. On current settlement and burial statistics, see the tables in Korenevskii 2004, and Korenevskii 2011: 9–12 on nomenclature.

144

Far-Flung Networks

the richest prehistoric find from the northern Caucasus.31 The site consisted of a large barrow, which rose almost 11 m above the plain and spread approximately 200 m across. Because a year later Veselovskii exposed two tombs at Novosvobodnaia (formerly known as Stanitsa Tsarskaia), today some scholars prefer the term Maikop-Novosvobodnaia community.32 Russian-led field projects and detailed studies, especially those published in the last couple of decades, have defined this intriguing tradition. Its broad characteristics are the adoption of barrow burials, ephemeral and shifting settlements, an abundance of metalwork, and widespread connections extending into the Near East and Europe.33

From its heartland in the Kuban region, in the modern republic of Adygea, whose capital is Maikop, this complex expanded obliquely in a south-easterly direction along plains and foothills to occupy much of the region stretching from the Taman Peninsula, in the north-west, to the border of Dagestan (Figure 4.1).34 Geographically, then, the Maikop culture comprised a relatively small area along the southern boundary of Western Eurasia. It was positioned between two worlds – the vast Eurasia steppe lands above it, and the Caucasus and Near Eastern lands to the south. Accordingly, the northern slope of the Caucasus Mountains was effectively the southern boundary of the Maikop culture. Communities favoured elevated positions on the foothills – terraces, rocky promontories, and natural spurs – overlooking a river valley, and on the whole they avoided the rugged highlands. In this respect, the Maikop settlement patterns differed markedly from those of the Kura-Araxes cultural tradition, which, as discussed later, sought the higher altitudes of the southern Caucasus. Maikop communities also rarely occupied caves, or rock shelters, such as the one at Meshoko.

Within the elongated Maikop culture province, the greatest concentration of sites occurs in the Krasnador region, in the north-west, where the Kuban River system held the greatest attraction.35 There we find, amongst others, the well-known large mounds of Maikop and Novosvobodnaia settlements. Moving eastward, Maikop sites are scattered in the southern areas of the Stavropol region, Kabardino-Balkaria, north Ossetia, and the lowlands of

31Veselovskii 1897. This fourth-millennium material, often referred to as the ‘Maikop Treasure’, should not be confused with items of a later date (medieval, Roman, and Scythian) likewise found in the Adygea region and also grouped under the heading ‘Maikop Treasure’.These later objects are now housed in Philadelphia, Berlin, and New York (Leskov 2008).

32Veselovskii 1901; Korenevskii 2004: 5; Rezepkin 2012.

33Early studies include Farmakovskii 1914; Rostovtzeff 1922: 17–34; Hančar 1937; Iessen 1935; 1950.Amongst the more current major Russian studies, see Munchaev 1975: 197– 335; 1994b; Korenevskii 1993, 2004, 2011; Rezepkin 2000, 2012. See also Häusler 1994; Govedarica 2002; Lyonnet 2007b; Kohl 2007: 72–86; 2009; Ivanova 2013: 50–129.

34Munchaev 1994b: 166–7; Chernykh 2011: fig. 1.

35For the westernmost extension of the Maikop culture, see Trifonov 2014.

The Maikop Culture (CA. 3800–2800 BC) and Its Predecessors

145

Chechnia and Ingushetia, where the frontier with the Kura-Araxes tradition can be drawn.The character of the sites, such as Lugovoe and SerzhenYurt in this interface region, show mixed influences, bearing affinities with both the Maikop and Kura-Araxes culture provinces.

Dagestan is different again. Whereas some researchers place it within the Maikop culture province proper, the general consensus is that Dagestan represents a highly distinctive version of the Kura-Araxes tradition.36 Another cultural boundary can be drawn within some areas of north Ossetia, Ingushetia, and Chechnia, where we have syncretistic elements combining both the Maikop and the steppe Pit Grave tradition.37 This region, as far as the mouth of the Terek River, appears to constitute the southern boundary of the Pit Grave tradition. Beyond this point, and to judge by the hundreds of Pit Grave burials in the Kalmykia region, we can say that the eastern half of the northern Caucasus, embracing the north-west Caspian region, belonged to the vast steppe culture of Eurasia. Even so, the cultural boundary is not always sharp, leading some to infer a transitional zone settled by the bearers of the ‘Maikop Steppe Culture’.38 Any precise comments on the distribution of barrows across the north Caucasian landscape must await the precise recording of sites using a Geographic Information System.

The striking and highly original character of the Maikop tradition is a combination of local ingenuity and skill, combined with a dynamism drawn from cultural influences reaching from central Asia, northern Iran, and Mesopotamia through the southern Caucasus and the northern Black Sea region to the Don River.39 There are several paradoxes that reflect on the social and economic aspects of the Maikop communities. First, there is a contrast between the dazzling assemblages of its few wealthy burial mounds, on the one hand, and the rather utilitarian appearance of grave goods from the vast majority of burials and settlements on the other. Most funerary assemblages have none of the magnificence, or inventiveness in techniques of tomb construction, displayed by the wealthy barrows. Early Maikop burials are for the most part simple, rectangular earthen pits sealed beneath a shallow tumulus. Metallurgy has its own peculiarities. Despite the quantity of metalwork associated with the Maikop culture, we have very little evidence of extractive mining or metallurgical workshops.This no doubt has to do with the history of research, which has targeted burial mounds, providing a somewhat lopsided picture of Maikop communities.

36See Magomedov 1991a, 1991b for the view that Dagestan belongs to the Maikop; for the counterargument, see Munchaev 1994b: 167.

37Krupnov and Merpert 1963; Shilov 1984; Derzhavin and Tikhonov 1980.

38Chernykh 2011: 158.

39For external connections see, for example, Munchaev 1994b and Andreeva 1977 (Mespotoamia); Häusler 1994 (central Europe); Korenevskii 2004 (eastern Europe); Hansen 2009 (Susiana); Ivanova 2012 (central Asia and northern Iran).

146

Far-Flung Networks

The Chronology of the Maikop Culture

The lifespan of the Maikop tradition and its external connections are problems that have been discussed for about a century and show no signs of abating. The culture has been internally divided and subdivided into phases, and shifted up and down a timeline ladder several times in attempts to link it to neighbouring regions. Intertwined with this are the issues of origins and ethnic affiliations, especially of the later Novosvobodnaia stage. Until the recent and steady stream of radiocarbon dates began to appear, chronology had been largely a typological and art historical pursuit. An underlying and erroneous assumption in these early deliberations, although not always explicitly stated, was the linear view that sophisticated and impressive Maikop artefacts were manufactured after comparable foreign objects whose features were thought to be more embryonic.The underrepresentation of settlements in the research has complicated matters even further.

In the span of a millennium,ranging from ca.4500 to 3000 BC, roughly covering the cultural periods of pre-Maikop and Maikop, the northern Caucasus came under the influence of two vastly different worlds: the north Pontic steppes, on the one hand, and the Near Eastern and central Asian lands on the other. Because no site has a sequence that covers this entire stretch of prehistory, the relative chronology of the region comprises a mosaic of disparate stratigraphies and imports.

A milestone in the study of the Maikop culture and north Caucasian archaeology generally is the work of A. A. Iessen. In dismissing the prevalent view of the 1940s that the large mounds of the Kuban were products of Scythian and Cimmerian cultures, he was the first to propose a twofold division into an Early Maikop (Maikop) and Late Maikop (Novosvobodnaia) phase, using the rich barrow assemblages.40 After some refinement, Iessen placed the Maikop culture within the period 2500–2300 BC based on assumed external parallels.

In the decades that followed, art historical analysis and foreign commodities provided the basis for the view that the Maikop repertoire was a local response to strong Mesopotamian impulses. Lapis lazuli, carnelian, and turquoise beads were clearly imports, given that the sources of these semi-precious stones are in central Asia.41 On the other hand, the fine metalwork is generally attributed to local craftsmen and Near Eastern artistic inspiration. Some have emphasised the Early Dynastic III influences, especially for items such as the transverse axe from Maikop, and the links with Troy II and Alaca Höyük displayed by animal figurines attached to poles.42 For them, the early Maikop cannot be placed

40Iessen 1950; 1951.Amongst those who proposed an eighth–seventh-century BC date for the early Kuban kurgans, see Artamonov 1948: 176–7.

41On the distribution of lapis lazuli and carnelian across the ancient Near East see, Casanova 2000.

42Glumac and Anthony 1992. For a rather extreme, indeed bizarre, view on foreign impact, see Safronov (1989), who maintains that the Maikop culture was essentially the product

The Maikop Culture (CA. 3800–2800 BC) and Its Predecessors

147

much earlier than 2600–2500 BC. Marina Andreeva, on the other hand, put forward a persuasive argument that pushed back Mesopotamian connections.43 Her study drew attention to art historical details and ceramics. The less eyecatching objects, such the round-bodied clay vessels, were connected to the chaff-tempered containers of the Amuq E/F and Gawra XII–IX repertoires, even though the Maikop vessels have a gritty, hard, and quite well-levigated fabric.

Rauf Munchaev developed this idea further.44 He compared a triangularheaded toggle-pin carved from bone (Figure 4.12(9)) from an early Maikop burial at Ust’-Dzheguta with a similarly shaped one from Arslantepe VIA. Likewise the cylinder and stamp seals from Krasnogvardeiskoe with an image of a deer and tree (Figure 4.4(5)) are associated with the Gawra horizon, including specific examples from Late Chalcolithic Değirmentepe in the Elazığ region of eastern Turkey.45 But perhaps the most insightful cultural parallel Munchaev draws is the ritual practice of depositing objects beneath floors. Under the pebble pavement of the large Maikop burial were found microlithic sickle blades and an edge-ground axe. According to Munchaev, this custom of burying objects beneath floors is totally foreign to the northern Caucasus and reflects the symbolic adoption of a Mesopotamian ritual performed when public buildings were erected.46

Whereas the foreign interplay between the early Maikop stage and the lands to the south is fairly clear, assessing the later Novosvobodnaia phase is a much more taxing and contentious task. Essentially, two primary views are current. One group maintains that Novosvobodnaia and its megalithic tomb structures are a local development, which quite possibly represents a hybrid expression combining a developed form of Maikop portable material culture with indigenous dolmen architecture that had started to emerge in the region (see Chapter 6), as well as in other areas such as the Crimea and the steppe lands.47 For others, most notably Alexei Rezepkin, the primary impetus and indeed the origins of the Novosvobodnaia stage are to be sought in the steppe-land cultures north of the Black Sea.48 For him, Novosvobodnaia, despite its parallels with the Maikop assemblage, is the easternmost expression of a province

of a community from Tell Hureyra, Syria, transplanted around 2400–2300 BC. Little better is the view of Miziev (1986), who argued that Maikop communities spoke a contrived Sumerian-Turkic language, thus extending the ancestry of contemporary north Caucasian Turkic peoples back into prehistory. For a critical review of these extreme migration theories, see Markovin 1990.

43Andreeva 1977.

44Munchaev 1994b: 169–70.

45Munchaev 1994b: 170.

46Munchaev 1991: 181. More recently Munchaev and Amirov 2014.

47Markovin 1990;Trifonov et al. 2012.

48Rezepkin 1989, 2012. Nikolayeva and Safronov appealed to an extreme view, now rejected, whereby migrations of peoples from central Europe established the late Maikop culture, as well as introducing the dolmen tradition. For a balanced central

148 Far-Flung Networks

that embraces the Funnel Beaker culture and, to a lesser extent, the Globular Amphora culture of central Europe. Although early discussions dealt mainly with polished black ceramics ornamented with incised designs, more recent discussions have included a wider range of artefacts, such as fl aked stone tools, bone projectile points, stone sceptres, and bone toggles.49

Rezepkin’s arguments have been criticised for lending too much weight to non-characteristic aspects of the Maikop culture.At the core of this debate is the scale of European influence. Certain Novosvobodnaia items, such as the beaker form, do – to be sure – bring to mind comparable examples further west. Marena Szmyt has pointed out that there is increasing evidence for Balkanic and central European influence in the territory of the northern Black Sea in the fourth millennium BC.50 Yet the cultural and, indeed, chronological relationship these regions had with the Novosvobodnaia is by no means clear, even though one study purports a genetic connection based on ancient DNA.51 Szmyt has correctly argued that more detailed and contextualised evidence, involving inter-disciplinary research, is needed to resolve this Novosvobodnaia question, rather than simply relying on typologies of select objects drawn from early fieldwork.

In the early 1990s, the first trickle of trustworthy radiocarbon readings was added to the fray. The samples were collected from the settlement at Galiugai, and then readings from Klady and barrows from north Ossetia followed.52 The growing number of radiocarbon readings, now more than 100 and mostly from the settlements at Galiugai and Svobodnoe, and from various barrows, places the beginning of Maikop around 3800 BC, or possibly even 4000 BC, which is much earlier than previously thought.53 By 3000 BC, the Maikop culture had petered out. Analyses were carried out at the Oxford and Saint Petersburg laboratories, and they are not without problems, with the Saint Petersburg dates consistently earlier than those from Oxford. Nonetheless, both suites of readings place the Maikop Culture before the Late Uruk expansion and, in eastern European terms, after Tripolye B1–2 and Cucuteni A2–4, and AB.54 This high chronology, then, sits uncomfortably with some of the early art historical affinities that have been drawn from north Syria and Mesopotamia.

European perspective, see Szmyt 2010: 167–88. For a critique of Rezepkin’s classification, see Trifonov 2001: 28–31.

49Rezepkin 2000: 11–21.

50Szmyt 2010.

51Nedoluzhko et al. 2014.

52Rezepkin 2000: 22; Korenevskii 2004: table XI. See also Chernykh 2011 for an appraisal.

53Chernykh 2011: fig. 8; for a 4000 BC beginning see Korenevskii 2011: 21–40. Both use the 95.8% probability to calibrate the readings. Ivanova (2007: Table 2), on the other hand, uses 68.4% probability that effectively lowers the beginning of the sequence. For matters that affect the interpretation of radiocarbon dates, see Introduction.

54This is equivalent to Parzinger’s (1993) Horizon 8 (b-c).