Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Khrestomatiya.docx
Скачиваний:
0
Добавлен:
01.05.2025
Размер:
7 Мб
Скачать
☆

Pros and Cons of Different Types of Media

Type

Advantages

Disadvantages

Newspaper

  • Flexible

  • Timeless

  • Good local coverage

  • Short life

  • Poor reproduction quality

  • Good for some products only

Television

  • Sight, sound, motion

  • High attention

  • High reach

  • High cost

  • High clutter

Radio

  • Mass use

  • High geographic/democratic selection

  • Low cost

  • Audio only

  • Lower attention than TV

  • Non-standard rates

  • Minimum exposure

  • Passive listening

  • Difficult to document specific information

Oudoor

  • Flexible

  • High repeat exposure

  • Low cost

  • Low competition

  • No audience selection

  • Creative limitations

  • Difficult to document specific information

Magazines

  • High geographic/democratic selection

  • Credibility and Prestige

  • Long Shelf Life

  • Long ad purchase time

  • Some waste circulation

  • No guarantee of position in magazine

  • Rates expensive

Direct Mail

  • Directed to targeted customers

  • Lower waste than mass mediums

  • Expensive per unit

  • Can be easy lost in other mail culter

  1. Summarize the text.

Text 4 seven myths about media effects

By Douglas A. Gentile

Arturo Sesma Jr.20

Myth 1. Media effects are simple and direct.

Each of the examples above describes what appear to be simple and direct effects on children imitating what they have seen. Yet the effects of media are not simple; neither are they usually direct. Most media effects are cumulative and subtle, even when they are designed to influence behavior. This subtlety masks remarkable power and persuasiveness. For example, research on advertisements demonstrates that attitudes and purchase behavior can be altered by as few as two or three exposures to an advertisement (Woodward & Denton, 2000). Yet, as we watch or drive past advertisements we don’t feel our opinions changing. The effects of media usually happen at a level of which we are not consciously aware. Advertisements, for example, are designed to influence and are successful at influencing brand awareness, brand preferences, brand usage, and brand loyalty (e.g., Gentile, Walsh, Bloomgren, Atti, & Norman, 2001). We rarely notice that advertisements affect us (aside from the rare pizza commercial that immediately makes us crave pizza). This is because ads are generally presented as entertainment, so that viewers are less likely to notice any effect or to resist their messages. Research suggests that the more one participates in this charade, by claiming that advertisements don’t affect one’s self, the more likely one is to be affected (Greene, 1999). Thus, to the extent that we expect media effects to be simple and direct, we are probably failing to notice the strongest and most powerful media influences.

Myth 2. The effects of media violence are severe.

Each of the events mentioned at the beginning of this chapter is extreme, and it is certainly true that most people who watch media violence never seriously injure other people or themselves. Since media violence does not make them commit the same kinds of violence, many people draw the inference that it has no effect on them or on most other people. Potter (1999) described this issue clearly, stating that, “People know that others are committing violent acts, but they also know that they personally have never committed any atrocities. The problem with this reasoning is that people equate [media] effects with atrocities” (p. 122). Watching violent media can have many effects, and we should not expect that exposure to media violence will cause people to begin killing each other. For every child who picks up a gun and shoots someone, thankfully there are millions who do not. Incidents of violent behaviors in American schools, 1998. Adapted from W. Modzeleski (2002), United States Secret Service. tally, most seasoned educators will tell you that schoolchildren have become more disrespectful, more verbally aggressive, and more likely to push and shove each other over time. In fact, the largest effect of media violence is probably not illustrated by individual examples of violent behavior, but by the “culture of disrespect” it has fostered and nurtured (Walsh, 2001). Interpersonal violence is just the endpoint on a continuum of disrespectful behavior. As can be seen in Figure 2.1, for every single example of a school killing, there were over 7,000 serious injuries, 28,000 thefts, 44,000 physical fights, and 500,000 reports of bullying (W. Modzeleski, personal communication to the authors, January 9, 2003). Killing someone is just the most visible tip of the phenomenon—there is a great deal of aggressive behavior that is not so extreme. While media effects on aggression are most likely to arouse concerns, violent media affect us much more broadly. Any time that you have laughed, felt excited, become scared, or otherwise aroused while watching a violent movie, you have just been affected. Positive and negative emotional and physiological reactions to violent media are media effects. Clearly, many people seek out this type of stimulation. After all, who wants to watch a “boring” movie? Violent media have many effects, including emotional, physiological, cognitive, attitudinal, and behavioral effects (see chapters 4 and 7 for more details). To the extent that we expect media effects to be exhibited through atrocities, we may be missing opportunities to see the more typical effects of media.

Myth 3. Media effects are obvious.

In each of the examples at the beginning of this chapter it was obvious (usually from the perpetrator’s own admission) what media product had influenced the subsequent behavior. This leads many to expect that such links should usually be obvious, and thus they take the absence of a direct and obvious link as evidence that no media effects should be implicated. Because the effects of violent media are usually indirect, subtle, and cumulative (and thus not obvious), many people then argue that researchers and policymakers are trying to find an easy scapegoat to explain violent behaviors. Indeed, even when the link is obvious, many people make this argument. The following anonymous quote was posted in response to the Jackass copycat burning: “TV shows are not responsible for copycat attempts of dangerous stunts they portray… Blaming TV shows for the actions of minors is just passing the buck” (“Texas talkback,” n.d.). Because the effects tend to be subtle and cumulative, even if people notice that someone is becoming more aggressive over time, they may not infer that the gradual change could be due partly to watching violent media. Nevertheless, cause-effect relationships need not be obvious to be significant. Most people accept that smoking causes lung cancer, even though the effect is subtle and cumulative (for a description of the many parallels between smoking and media violence, see Bushman & Anderson, 2001). One cigarette does not change a person’s health in any particularly noticeable way, but years of smoking can have dire consequences (but, importantly, not for all people!). To the extent that we expect media effects to be exhibited in an obvious manner, we are missing opportunities to see other less obvious and perhaps more pervasive effects.

Myth 4. Violent media affect everyone in the same way.

Many people assume that, to be considered valid, media violence effects must be unidimensional—that is, that everyone must be affected by becoming more aggressive and violent. While that is one of the documented effects, it is not the only one. Meta-analyses (studies that analyze data presented across large numbers of studies) have shown that there are at least four main effects of watching a lot of violent media. These effects have been called the aggressor effect, the victim effect, the bystander effect, and the appetite effect (Donnerstein, Slaby, & Eron, 1994). The aggressor effect describes how children and adults who watch a lot of

violent entertainment tend to become meaner, more aggressive, and more violent.

The victim effect describes how children and adults who watch a lot of violent entertainment tend to see the world as a scarier place, become more scared, and initiate more self-protective behaviors (including going so far as to carry guns to school, which, ironically, increases one’s odds of being shot). The bystander effect describes how children and adults who watch a lot of violent entertainment tend to habituate to gradually increasing amounts of violence, thereby becoming desensitized, more callous, and less sympathetic to victims of violence (both in the media and in real life). The appetite effect describes how children and adults who watch a lot of violent entertainment tend to want to see more violent entertainment. Simply put, the more one watches, the more one wants to watch. These effects are well-documented in hundreds of studies. What is less well known is which people are more prone to which effects (although these effects are not mutually exclusive). In general, females tend to be more affected by the victim effect, whereas males tend to be more affected by the aggressor, bystander, and appetite effects. But it is still unclear how to predict exactly how any given individual will be affected by any given media violence presentation. However, the fact that we cannot yet make this prediction reliably should not be taken as evidence that there is no effect. Furthermore, that everyone is not affected in the same way does not mean that everyone is not affected. To understand where children learn their attitudes, values, and patterns of behavior, we can consider the effects of various proximal and distal sources of influence. The family is closest to children, and children clearly have their attitudes, values, and behavior patterns shaped and modified by their families. The behaviors defined as “normal” within each family affect the behaviors of the individuals within that family. Beyond the level of the family, the norms of the community affect the norms of families and individuals within it. Beyond the level of the community, the norms of society affect the norms of communities, families, and individuals within it. The media operate at this societal level, and media effects can be seen at all levels. Thus, the media can affect us not only one-on-one, when we are watching TV, for example, but they also affect us by affecting the norms, expectations, and patterns of behavior of our families and communities. This is another aspect of the media’s subtlety—they can affect us through multiple directions at once. Although this makes it likely that everyone will be affected by violent media in some way, it also makes it likely that the effects may not be identical for all people.

Myth 5. Causality means “necessary and sufficient.”

Determining if and when something “causes” something else is a problem that has plagued philosophers and scientists for centuries. In the social sciences, it is a surprisingly complex problem to solve. For many people, however, it has become oversimplified—something is a cause if it can be shown to be necessary and/or sufficient as a precursor. This position has been used to argue against the effects of media violence. Ferguson (2002), in a response to Bushman and Anderson’s (2001) meta-analyses of media violence and aggression, stated that: (a) because humans have always been violent, “violent media, then, are not a necessary precursor to violent behavior” (p. 446), and (b) because many people who are exposed to media violence never commit violent behavior, “violent media, then, are not sufficient to cause violent behavior” (p. 446). This argument seems, on its surface, to be reasonable. Yet this argument actually betrays a grossly oversimplified idea of causation. Consider, for example, a rock on the side of a hill. Assume that you give the rock a push and it begins rolling down the hill. Did you cause the rock to roll down the hill?

By the argument laid out above, you did not. Rocks have rolled down hills for centuries without someone coming along and pushing them. Therefore pushing it is not necessary. Furthermore, many rocks that are pushed do not roll down hills. Therefore, pushing it is not sufficient. Although pushing the rock was neither necessary nor sufficient to make it roll down the hill, that does not mean that it was not a cause of the rock’s beginning to roll. Most complex issues of interest (such as aggressive behavior) are multicausal. In the present example, many other issues interact to determine whether the push you gave to the rock caused it to roll down the hill: the force of gravity, the mass of the rock, the shape of the rock (round rocks require less of a push than square ones), the friction of the hill surface, the slope of the hill surface, the direction of the push, the force of the push, how deeply the rock is embedded into the ground, and so on—all interact to determine whether your push makes the rock begin to roll or not. Recognition that the issue is multicausal does not mean that your push is not one of the causes; in fact, it may have been a significant determiner or catalyst for the ultimate outcome, without which the other causes would not have been activated or sufficient. Aggressive behavior, too, is multicausal. Media violence is likely to be one of the pushes that interacts with other forces at work. In most situations, it is neither necessary nor sufficient. However, that does not mean that it is not a cause—it just means that it is one of the causes.

This conception of causality is similar to the idea of “proximate cause” in law, where the goal is to assign legal responsibility for an action. The proximate cause is the last action to set off a sequence of events that produces an injury. Yet, the goal of social science is not the same as that of law. Social science is concerned with all of the causes for some behavior, not only the necessary, sufficient, most recent, or largest causes. Because media violence has been shown to increase the likelihood of aggressive behavior, it can be a cause of aggressive behavior, even if it alone is not a necessary or sufficient cause.

Myth 6. Causality means immediacy.

Many people also expect that causality requires immediacy, as in a fall causing a broken bone. As noted in the smoking and cancer example, however, physical symptoms may become visible only after some threshold of disease process is attained, which may take a long time. With regard to media violence, many people assume that the effects must be seen in the short term in order to be caused by exposure. For example, Ferguson (2002, p. 447) states, “If media violence is a necessary and direct cause of violent behavior, a significant decline in violent crime should not be occurring unless violence in the media is also declining.” We have already seen that media violence can be a cause without being a “necessary” cause. The issue of whether it is a “direct” cause seems to be the relationship between the amount of media violence and the incidence of violence in society. From the 1950s until about 1993, both the amount of media violence and the number of aggravated assaults rose in the United States (Grossman, 1996). In the latter half of the 1990s, the aggravated-assault rate fell somewhat while the amount of media violence stayed constant or increased (especially in video games—see chapters 4 and 7). This was taken by many to be “evidence” that media violence does not cause aggressive behavior.

Yet many causes have long-term effects. Consider smoking and lung cancer. Or consider water, salt, and your car. Over many years, cars that are repeatedly exposed to salt rust at a higher rate than those that are not exposed. But if you pour saltwater on your car, will you see it rust? No, it is a long-term effect. Some researchers have presented evidence that the effects of media violence may be long term. For example, Centerwall (1989) has documented that the murder rate appears to double about 15 years after the initial introduction of television to communities or countries. It has been hypothesized that about 15 years must elapse before the full effect is revealed, as that is the time it takes for a generation to grow up with the violent media and to reach a prime crime-committing age. If this hypothesis is correct, then we shouldn’t expect to see immediate effects. To the extent that we expect causation to appear as immediate or short-term effects, we may miss a number of important long-term effects.

Myth 7. Effects must be “big” to be important.

Many people have agreed that the accumulated research shows that there is a systematic effect of violent media on aggressive behavior, yet they also insist that it is not a large enough effect to be important. These discussions often include a statistical approach. For example, Ferguson (2002) notes that the amount of variance in violent behavior explained by media violence in meta-analyses is somewhere between 1 and 10 percent. This means that if we drew a circle representing all the reasons why someone might act violently, media violence would account for between 1 and 10 percent of the pie. (It should be noted that some meta-analyses have reported larger numbers, and that there are a number of methodological reasons why these numbers may be underestimates; see Paik & Comstock, 1994, for a detailed explanation.) Ferguson (2002, p. 447) states that these effect sizes are “small and lack practical significance.” Ferguson is not alone in making this type of value judgment (e.g., Freedman, 2002), but it is unclear on what basis it is made. In epidemiological terms, if only 1 percent of the people watching a violent TV show become more aggressive, and one million people watch the program, then 10,000 people were made more aggressive. That does not seem to us to “lack practical significance.” Indeed, many (if not most) medical studies on the effects of drugs or diet are concerned with such small effects. Supplementing one’s diet with calcium can increase bone mass, but the effect is “only” about one percent (Bushman & Anderson, 2001). Hormone replacement therapy in women may increase the odds of breast cancer, but across the whole population, the effect is probably less than one percent. A daily aspirin may reduce the risk of heart attacks, but again, the effect is less than one percent (Hemphill, 2003). The medical profession regards these small effects as clearly important and having a great deal of practical significance. In fact, there are probably hundreds of reasons for any aggressive act (e.g., abuse, poverty, history, gang membership, drug use, etc.). If there are hundreds of reasons, then any single one of them should not account for much variance. That media violence consistently appears to account for at least 1 to 10 percent of the effect is actually surprisingly large!

Assignments

  1. Comment on the classification of media given below.

Table 3.2

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]