Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Volume_1.docx
Скачиваний:
2
Добавлен:
01.07.2025
Размер:
348 Кб
Скачать
☆

The Systemic Vision as a Delegation of Authority

The vision of international law as a legal system creates a space within which decision makers can reach conclusions about specific outcomes using the rhetoric of law, rather than the rhetoric of what is just or efficient. Judges, bureaucrats, politicians and private claimants engage in deliberations about legal principles and the legitimate conclusions these principles stipulate. They use the traditional lawyers’ tools of interpretation, deduction and inference to justify specific rules they articulate. This legal discourse empowers primarily judges, whose province is not to promote the good and the efficient, but rather to proclaim what is legal. Their authorization to assert what the law is requires them to use the lawyers’ tools to reach specific conclusions. The vision of international law as a legal system rather than a mix of discrete treaties allows them to interpret, deduct, draw inferences and resolve conflicts not only by resorting to the specific treaties at hand but also by relying on the basic principles of the system and its underlying norms.

As a result of this implicit authorization, perhaps the most significant political outcome of the vision of international law as a legal system is the empowerment of courts to develop international law beyond the intention of governments. The systemic or constitutional conception of international law supplies relatively independent bureaucracies and judiciaries with doctrines that enable them to expand their authority while maintaining coherence and consistency through broad interpretation of treaties and the development of customary international law. Whereas governments tend to prefer rules on treaty interpretation that look back to the historical intention of the negotiators, thereby maximizing governments’ influence on the outcomes of the interpretation process, international tribunals have developed alternative interpretative approaches, such as “evolutionary interpretation,” which are inspired by systemic goals such as coherence and efficiency. Recourse to the doctrines of customary international law, jus cogens, and erga omnes obligations, allow judges considerable discretion to make new law while couching it in existing practices or fundamental norms. Indeed, international tribunals exercise considerable discretion in both “identifying” state practice and in determining whether following that practice reveals a state’s acknowledgment of its binding quality, making it a customary international law norm. Moreover, international tribunals have promoted what Lauterpacht referred to as “the principle of effectiveness” in treaty interpretation to ensure that the treaties effectively achieve their goals, even reading into the texts additional obligations if necessary. If a treaty establishes institutions, the courts will bolster those institutions, strengthening their authority internally and externally. At the internal level of that institution, the court will reinforce an institution’s authority and impact vis-?-vis state parties beyond what the negotiators intended. At the external level, the court will recognize the institution’s status as a “subject” of international law that must be treated and recognized as such by nonmember states.

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]