- •Part one starting out
- •What is linguistics?
- •What is a linguist?
- •How does linguistics differ from traditional grammar?
- •The scope of linguistics
- •Questions
- •What is language?
- •Use of sound signals
- •The Need for Learning
- •Duality
- •Arbitrariness
- •Displacement
- •Creativity (Productivity)
- •Patterning
- •Structure dependence
- •Human language versus animal communication
- •Origin and functions of language
- •Questions
- •The study of language
- •Nineteenth century: historical linguistics
- •Early- to mid-20th century: descriptive linguistics
- •Generative linguistics and the search for universals
- •Questions
- •Deciding where to begin
- •Language as a game
- •Universal and particular
- •Questions
- •The inner circles
- •Sound patterns
- •Sorting out the basic sounds
- •The phonemes of English
- •Allophones
- •Sound combinations
- •Shared properties of phonemes
- •Metrical phonology
- •Questions
- •Words and pieces of words
- •Defining words
- •Morphemes
- •Recognition of morphemes
- •Types of morpheme
- •Allomorphs
- •Phonological conditioning
- •Word classes
- •Major word classes
- •Questions
- •Sentence patterns
- •Linking words together
- •Word order
- •Inflections
- •Function words
- •Constituent analysis
- •Tree diagrams
- •Rewrite rules
- •Identifying constituents
- •Adding in extra patterns
- •Layers of branches
- •Complex sentences
- •Questions
- •Meaning
- •Word meaning
- •Semantic fields
- •Coping with overlaps
- •Synonyms and opposites
- •Classification (inclusion)
- •The meaning of sentences
- •Questions
- •The outer rings
- •Using language
- •The cooperative principle
- •Speech acts
- •Remembered frameworks
- •Discourse analysis
- •Taking it in turns
- •Repairs
- •Politeness
- •Questions
- •Language and society
- •The notion of a language
- •Dialect and accent
- •Stylistic variation
- •Speech versus writing
- •The topic under discussion
- •The language of advertising
- •Change in language styles
- •Charting phonological variation
- •Phonological variation in British English
- •Social networks
- •Language and sex
- •Multilingual communities
- •Pidgins and Creoles
- •Questions
- •Language and mind
- •Psycholinguistic evidence
- •Acquiring language
- •The content-process controversy
- •The rule-governed nature of child language
- •Learning the meaning of words
- •Understanding syntax
- •Recognizing words
- •Speech production
- •Speech disorders
- •Language and the brain
- •Part four changes and comparisons
- •Language change
- •How language changes
- •Spread of change within a language
- •Causes of language change
- •Natural tendencies
- •Therapeutic changes
- •Changes which trigger one another off
- •Interacting changes
- •Reconstruction
- •Questions
- •Genetic similarities
- •Building a family tree
- •Reconstructing the parent language
- •Unreliability of reconstructions
- •Linguistic areas
- •Language types
- •Word order criteria
Adding in extra patterns
So far, our rewrite rules have dealt with only one structure, the pattern underlying The duck bit the burglar. Let us now add in some others. Consider the sentence: The duck slept in the bath.
69 —
This has the same basic division into NP VP as The duck bit the burglar. But the structure of the VP differs. In The duck slept in the bath, the verb is followed by a preposition phrase (PP) (Figure 34).
The extra rewrite rules required for this are:
VP->V PP
PP->P NP
However, the PP is not an essential part of the structure. It is an optional extra, since The duck slept is a well-formed sentence by itself. This can be shown by putting brackets round the PP in the rewrite rule, indicating that it is optional:
VP->V (PP)
The rewrite rule above therefore underlies both The duck slept in the bath, and The duck slept. In the first, the optional PP has been selected. In the second, it has been omitted. Let us now consider another sentence:
The burglar put the duck in a sack.
This differs from the previous structures discussed in that it is essential to have both an NP and a PP after the V (Figure 35, page 71). If either were omitted, the sentence would be ill-formed:
*The burglar put the duck.
*The burglar put in a sack.
–– 70 ––
The rewrite rule in this case is:
VP->V NP PP
So far, then, we have three different rewrite rules for English VPs:
VP -> V NP (The duck bit the burglar).
VP ->V (PP) (The duck slept, The duck slept in the bath).
VP->V NP IT (The burglar put the duck in a sack).
It would be useful to combine these three separate rules. As a first suggestion, one might simply number the types of verb (VI for a verb such as bit, V2 for slept, V3 for put), and enclose them in another type of bracket { } which is used to denote alternative possibilities:
PP]
This means: 'Rewrite the VP as either VI NP, or V2 (PP), or V3 NP PP'. However, if we wanted to include the full range of alternatives available in an English VP, the rewrite rules would become extremely long and complicated. A neater solution is to keep the rewrite rules fairly simple, and to use them in conjunction with a lexicon (dictionary) which specifies the structure associated with each V:
Bit V [–NP]
Slept V [–(PP)]
Put V [–NP PP]
First, the item in question is listed, then the fact that it is a verb (V). In the square brackets come the structures associated with it. The long dash |—] indicates the place where the verb is inserted, so (— NP]
71 ––
says "The verb in question must be followed by an NP'.
With these lexical entries, we need only one rewrite rule for the three types of verb:
VP->V (NP) (PP)
This rule says:' A VP consists of a V optionally followed by an NP and/or a PP'. It accounts for all the possibilities discussed above, since one can slot in a verb only if it fits the structure chosen. For example, suppose we had chosen both the optional items, NP and PP, we must then slot in a verb followed by NP PP, in this case put. Similarly, if we had chosen V alone, the only V which fits in this case is sleep.
With a detailed lexicon of this type, which can be expanded to include other word classes also, we no longer need substitution rules such as: V -> bit, N -> burglar.
Let us therefore summarize the rewrite rules and lexical entries for:
The duck bit the burglar.
The duck slept.
Tiie duck slept in the bath.
The burglar put the duck in a sack.
–– 72 ––
Of course, if more data had been considered, the rules and the lexicon would have to be complicated further. For example, if we had included a proper name such as Donald, the lexicon would have to specify which nouns are found with a determiner (D), as in the duck, a sack, and which not, as in Donald not *a Donald. However, we set out to write rules for the sentence patterns in question, and we have done this as economically as possible.
