- •Part one starting out
- •What is linguistics?
- •What is a linguist?
- •How does linguistics differ from traditional grammar?
- •The scope of linguistics
- •Questions
- •What is language?
- •Use of sound signals
- •The Need for Learning
- •Duality
- •Arbitrariness
- •Displacement
- •Creativity (Productivity)
- •Patterning
- •Structure dependence
- •Human language versus animal communication
- •Origin and functions of language
- •Questions
- •The study of language
- •Nineteenth century: historical linguistics
- •Early- to mid-20th century: descriptive linguistics
- •Generative linguistics and the search for universals
- •Questions
- •Deciding where to begin
- •Language as a game
- •Universal and particular
- •Questions
- •The inner circles
- •Sound patterns
- •Sorting out the basic sounds
- •The phonemes of English
- •Allophones
- •Sound combinations
- •Shared properties of phonemes
- •Metrical phonology
- •Questions
- •Words and pieces of words
- •Defining words
- •Morphemes
- •Recognition of morphemes
- •Types of morpheme
- •Allomorphs
- •Phonological conditioning
- •Word classes
- •Major word classes
- •Questions
- •Sentence patterns
- •Linking words together
- •Word order
- •Inflections
- •Function words
- •Constituent analysis
- •Tree diagrams
- •Rewrite rules
- •Identifying constituents
- •Adding in extra patterns
- •Layers of branches
- •Complex sentences
- •Questions
- •Meaning
- •Word meaning
- •Semantic fields
- •Coping with overlaps
- •Synonyms and opposites
- •Classification (inclusion)
- •The meaning of sentences
- •Questions
- •The outer rings
- •Using language
- •The cooperative principle
- •Speech acts
- •Remembered frameworks
- •Discourse analysis
- •Taking it in turns
- •Repairs
- •Politeness
- •Questions
- •Language and society
- •The notion of a language
- •Dialect and accent
- •Stylistic variation
- •Speech versus writing
- •The topic under discussion
- •The language of advertising
- •Change in language styles
- •Charting phonological variation
- •Phonological variation in British English
- •Social networks
- •Language and sex
- •Multilingual communities
- •Pidgins and Creoles
- •Questions
- •Language and mind
- •Psycholinguistic evidence
- •Acquiring language
- •The content-process controversy
- •The rule-governed nature of child language
- •Learning the meaning of words
- •Understanding syntax
- •Recognizing words
- •Speech production
- •Speech disorders
- •Language and the brain
- •Part four changes and comparisons
- •Language change
- •How language changes
- •Spread of change within a language
- •Causes of language change
- •Natural tendencies
- •Therapeutic changes
- •Changes which trigger one another off
- •Interacting changes
- •Reconstruction
- •Questions
- •Genetic similarities
- •Building a family tree
- •Reconstructing the parent language
- •Unreliability of reconstructions
- •Linguistic areas
- •Language types
- •Word order criteria
Classification (inclusion)
A further way of examining lexical structure is to note the ways in which a language classifies items. In English, for example, claret and hock are classified as 'wines'. Tea and coffee are referred to as 'beverages'. And wines and beverages both come under the heading of 'drinks'.
This indicates that the vocabulary of a language is partially hierarchically structured. In Figure 46 below, more general items come at the top, and more specific items are sub-divisions of these:
The vocabulary of English is classified in this way in Roget's Thesaurus. Each entry has under it a list of hyponyms (i.e. lexical items subsumed under it). Its main drawback is that it does not distinguish between the stylistic or social variables which control the choice of synonyms.
The advantage of looking at these different relationships is firstly, they enable us to understand the multiple links between different words. Second, they can all be expressed by means of logical notation, so allowing us to be explicit in our description. Indeed, some linguists have claimed that the entire meaning of a word can be expressed in terms of its logical relationships with other words.
Fuzziness and family resemblances
So far, we have assumed that words have an agreed-upon meaning which we can discover and describe. But this is true only of some lexical items. For others, it seems to be impossible to agree upon a 'proper meaning'.
Consider the words bachelor and tiger. As a first step, we can look up these words in the Concise Oxford Dictionary. Here a bachelor is
86 ––
defined as an 'unmarried man'. Both unmarriedness and maleness seem to be essential properties of the word bachelor. If someone said, 'I met a bachelor and he was married', the automatic response would be 'Then he isn't a bachelor'. Or if someone said 'I know a girl who is a bachelor', the normal response would be, That's impossible' (unless they happened to be talking about someone who possessed a Bachelor of Arts degree). It is therefore clear that bachelor contains the properties male and unmarRiEd. This word has proved easy to analyse.
Let us now look at the word tiger. A dictionary definition is 'large Asian yellow-brown black-striped carnivorous maneless feline'. Which of these are essential characteristics? Presumably 'carnivorous' is not really essential, because you could say, 'Harry's tiger is not carnivorous' without getting the response, That's impossible, it can't be a tiger'. But what about stripiness? Here people's reactions differ. If you said 'Harry's tiger isn't striped', people's reactions fall into two categories. Some might say, Then it's not a tiger', indicating that stripiness is an essential part of being a tiger. But others might make a comment such as 'Well I suppose you can get albino tigers just as you get albino blackbirds', or 'Since tabby cats don't always have tabby kittens, maybe you can get unstriped tigers'. To such people, stripiness is not an essential property of tigerhood.
In brief, with some words (such as bachelor), there is a relatively high level of agreement as to which properties constitute an essential part of their meaning, but with others (such as tiger), no such agreement is found.
Fuzziness is another problem. Words often have fuzzy edges. There is no absolute divide between a cup and a mug, a glass and a vase, or a plate and a saucer. They all merge into one another. People use them inconsistently, calling something a vase one day, and a glass the next. They might call it a vase if it held flowers, and г glass if it held orange-juice.
Family resemblances create further difficulties. Sometimes a word such as furniture covers a whole range of things, which share characteristics with one another, as do members of a family. Yet it may be impossible to think up a set of characteristics which describes them all.
These problems indicate that it is impossible to set down fixed meanings for all words. Humans, it turns out, understand one another not by learning fixed definitions, but by working from a prototype, or typical example. A prototypical bird is likely to be something like a robin, with a beak, wings, stick-like legs, and an ability to fly. A pen-
87 ––
guin or an emu is still sufficiently like a bird to be regarded as a bird, even though it is not such a 'normal' or prototypical bird. This flexibility allows a great number of things to be classified as birds, even a one-legged, one-winged parrot without a beak.
It is not yet clear how to write this type of flexibility into a linguistic description. We need to pretend things are cut and dried in order to write a useful description of them, on the other hand we have to be aware that they are not. Exactly where the balance should lie is still under discussion.
