- •Unit 1. The need for law
- •Vocabulary:
- •Vocabulary:
- •Кодекс Хаммурапи
- •Vocabulary:
- •Solon (b. 630 — d. 560 b.C.)
- •Драконт
- •Vocabulary:
- •Vocabulary:
- •Великая Хартия Вольностей
- •Unit 2: origins of the jury
- •Unit 3. Jury duty
- •The fear of jury duty
- •Jury service — an important job and a rewarding experience
- •Selection of the trial jury
- •1) Litigation — судебный процесс, спор, тяжба
- •2) Lawsuit — судебный процесс, судебное дело, иск, тяжба, правовой спор, судебный спор, судебное разбирательство
- •3) Suit — судебный процесс, иск, преследование по суду, судебное дело, судебная тяжба, судопроизводство
- •Присяга
- •The Jury in Britain
- •Unit 4. In the courtroom
- •Do's and don'ts for jurors
- •Unit 5. Steps of the trial
- •What happens during the trial
- •Прения сторон
- •Verdict
- •Unit 6. The value of juries
- •Words of Wisdom About Jury Service
- •Jury system reform defeaed in parliament
- •Unit 7: constitutional law of the united states and the united kingdom
- •"Outlines of constitutional law"
- •Constitution of the united states
- •Unit 8: police work in the united states and the united kingdom
- •Inspection Division
- •Police force in the united states
- •The work of militia
- •Unit 9: criminal justice process in the united states and the united kingdom
- •Probable cause and other levels of proof
- •Additional texts
- •The bells of the old baily
- •Criminal policy of the future
- •Unit 10: physical evidence
- •The Plot
- •The Suspects
- •1. Colonel Adams.
- •2. Miss Blake
- •Mr. Clarke
- •Trace evidence
- •Fingerprints
- •Crime scene and duties of a police officer at a crime scene
- •Fingerprints
- •Latent prints
- •Unit 11. The study of crime
- •Criminology
- •Cesare lombroso (1836—1909)
- •Преступниками рождаются или становятся? Преступность: врожденное и приобретенное.
- •Unit 12. Crimes and criminals Law Breakers
- •The causes of crime
- •Преступность и ее причины
- •Unit 13. Punishment
- •1) Связанный с применением наказания
- •2) Карательный, штрафной
- •From the History of Punishment
- •Unit 14. The purpose of state punishment
- •Treatment of criminals
- •Manslaughter
- •Crime of Passion
- •Assault
- •Shop-lifting
- •Unit 15. Capital punishment
- •Capital punishment: history
- •Financial Costs
- •Inevitability of Error
- •Barbarity
- •Deterrence
- •Тексты для дополнительного чтения и перевода Содержание:
- •Part I. Text 1: a glimpse of british political history
- •Text 2: the english political heritage
- •Text 3: the ideas of john locke*
- •Text 4: the legal heritage of france
- •Text 5: the roots of american government
- •Text 6: the indian self-government in north america
- •Text 7: government in the colonies
- •Text 8: colonial legislatures
- •Text 9: colonial self-government
- •Text 10: democracy
- •Text 11: elements of democracy
- •Text 12: characteristics of democracy
- •Text 13: the soil of democracy
- •Text 14: oligarchy
- •Text 15: autocracy
- •Text 16: the american civil service
- •Text 17: the origins of the civil service system
- •Text 18: the concept of bicameral legislature
- •Text 19: us congress rules
- •Text 20: lawmaking in the senate
- •Text 21: congress and the president
- •Text 22: voting in the usa
- •Text 24: rights and responsibilities of american citizens
- •Text 23: parties and party systems
- •Text 25: protecting the rights of the accused
- •Text 26: cruel and unusual punishment
- •Text 27: freedom of the press
- •Text 28: free press and fair trial
- •Text 29: freedom of speech
- •Text 30: freedom of religion
- •Text 31: mass media in a democratic society
- •Text 32: the pentagon papers*
- •Text 33: watergate
- •Text 34: legal and constitutional developments in britain
- •Text 35: charles I and the civil war
- •Text 36: the royalists and the parliamentarians
- •Text 37: the end of the civil war
- •Text 38: the history of speakership in britain
- •Text 39: the speaker of the house of commons
- •Text 40: the speaker's duties
- •Text 41: debate in the house of commons
- •Text 42: unparliamentary language
- •Part II: famous legal documents throughout history (extracts) text 1: Hammurabi's Code of Laws (1758 b.C.)
- •Text 2: The Laws of William the Conqueror (1066—1087)
- •Text 3: The Magna Carta (1215)
- •Text 4: The Petition of Rights (1628)
- •Text 5: The English Bill of Rights (1689)
- •Text 6: The u.S. Declaration of Independence (1776)
- •Text 7: The u.S. Bill of Rights (1791)
- •Text 8: European Prison Rules (1990s)
- •Part II. Philosophers of law text 9: Sir Thomas More, 1478—1535
- •Text 10: John Locke, 1632—1704
- •Text 11: Charles-Louis de Secondat Montesquieu, 1689—1755
- •Text 12: Voltaire, 1694—1778
- •Text 13: Jeremy Bentham, 1748—1832
- •Part III. Notorious criminals text 14: Cain
- •Text 15: Marcus Junius Brutus, 85—42 b.C., Gaius Longinus Cassius, d. 42 b.C.
- •Text 16: Caligula, a.D. 12—41
- •Text 17: Colonia Agrippina, a.D. 16—59
- •Text 18: Guy Fawkes, 1570—1606
- •Text 19: Captain William Kidd, 1645—1701
- •Text 20: Alessandro Cagliostro, 1743—1795
- •Text 21: Billy the Kid (William Bonny), 1860—1881
- •Text 22: Jack the Ripper
- •Text 23: Roy Bean, d. 1903
- •Text 24: Butch Cassidy, 1866—1910 and the Sundance Kid, d. 1910
- •Text 25: Mata Hari (born Gertruda Margarete Zelle), 1876—1917
- •Text 26: Captain Alfred Dreyfus, 1859—1935
- •Text 27: Lizzie Borden, 1860—1927
- •Text 28: Dr. Hawley Harvey Crippen, 1882—1910
- •Text 29: Bonnie and Clyde (Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow), d. 1934
- •Text 30: 'Ma' Barker, d. 1935
- •Text 31: Bruno Hauptmann, d. 1936
- •Text 32: Hans Van Meegeren, 1889—1947
- •Text 33: Alphonse Capone, 1899—1947
- •Text 34: 'Lucky Luciano', 1897—1962
- •Text 35: Frank Costello, 1891—1973
- •Text 36: George Blake, b. 1922
- •Text 37: Lee Harvey Oswald, 1940—1963
- •Part IV. Famous detectives text 38: Father Brown
- •Text 39: Sherlock Holmes
- •Text 40: Ellery Queen
- •Text 41: Hercules Poirot
- •Text 42: Inspector Jules Maigret
- •Text 43: Perry Mason
- •Text 44: Bank Bobbers
- •Text 45: Muggers
- •Text 46: Thieves
- •Text 47: Escape Artists
- •Text 48: Shop-Lifters
- •Text 49: Robbers
- •Text 50: Burglars
- •Text 51: 'Miscellaneous' Crooks
- •Text 52: Outrageous Lawsuits
- •Список использованной литературы
Jury system reform defeaed in parliament
MAGISTRATES (Justices of the Peace or JPs) are judicial officers who judge cases in lower courts. They are usually unpaid and have no formal legal qualifications, but they are respectable people who are given some training.
In 1999 the UK Home Secretary Jack Straw unveiled plans to limit the right to trial by jury. In the UK defendants in certain cases can choose whether they want a trial by magistrates or by judge and jury. The Home Secretary said, "England and Wales has the only jurisdiction system where defendants have the right to choose their court. In addition, trial by jury is a more expensive process than a hearing by magistrates." Defending the proposed legislation, Mr. Straw said that it would streamline the criminal justice system, save 128 million pounds a year and prevent some defendants from "working the system".
The jury trial in its modern form stems back to 1855. Serious crimes are automatically heard by a jury as well as a wide range of middle-ranking offences such as theft and handling stolen goods. There were plans to abolish jury trials for complex fraud, cases. The Home Office pointed out the huge cost of such cases to the taxpayers and the strain on judges, juries and defendants. The government argued that some defendants abuse the current system delaying their trial by pleading not guilty in order to get a trial by jury, then changing their plea at the last moment in order to get a more lenient sentence.
In both chambers of Parliament, however, the legislation was condemned as unjust, and the bill described as "one of the worst pieces of legislation to come for many years". The majority of the MPs in the House of Commons voted against the proposals to allow magistrates to decide whether defendants accused of lesser offences should be entitled to jury trial. The Lords also condemned the bill as bringing in a two-tier system in which the rich would be able to defend their reputation but the poor would not.
Opponents of the bill believe it would have restricted a fundamental right to jury trial by one's peers and would erode public confidence in the criminal justice system. The legal profession, civil liberties groups, opposition parties and the Lords rejected Jack Straw's policy.
Exercise 2: Translate the following quotations:
The new bill is considered to be the beginning of the end for Britain's ancient jury system. The members of the public were asked a question "Do you believe it is the fairest system available or is it old-fashioned and in need of reform?"
It's clear that the system is far from ideal. Juries of ordinary people are by their very nature more influenced by emotion than facts because they aren't trained to deal with these. That being said, magistrates are probably not that much better placed to do so.
John Cahill, UK
The right for a suspect to have a jury has been welded into English law for hundreds of years. What right has Straw to deny people this basic right?
Nick, England
Flawed as the jury system is, the right to be judged by one's peers is not something that should be tossed aside lightly, and certainly not on the grounds of expense.
Kit, UK
As a retired Cop I can tell you that the rule is this: if you are guilty get a good lawyer and a jury. If you are innocent you would have a better chance with a judge only.
Ty Northcutt, USA
In real life it doesn't make much difference whether you opt for trial by jury or trial by magistrates. In the Netherlands there is no trial by jury whatsoever, still I cannot see any signs of a despotic police state looming above the horizon, democracy going to pot, or personal freedom going down the drain.
Frank Drop, The Netherlands
If a defendant is tried by a true 'jury of his peers', then a jury trial would perhaps result in justice. If, as is currently true in the United States, and possibly also in the UK, a jury is selected from people who are not peers of the defendant, who know nothing of the case, and have nothing better to do with their time then a jury trial becomes a two-ring circus. The ring which produces the best performance wins. Justice is incidental. It becomes all about winning.
Jim, USA
The idea of 12 good men/women is flawed. The jury system is a lottery and you have no guarantee that the people have an adequate grasp of the concepts involved. The courtroom is a forum for a display of semantics by lawyers and too many people are misled by it.
Lucas, UK
Trial by jury is part of what the English-speaking nations of the world understand by democracy. The ordinary people don't only decide who shall write the laws, by electing the MPs, they also decide, by serving on juries, against whom those laws shall be applied. If you argue that they are incompetent to do the latter, then by the same token you are in fact arguing that they are incompetent to do the former.
T. D. Erikson, UK
Although a jury by one's peers may have its flaws, I can think of no better or less flawed system available. Sure, it may be expensive, but since when has there been a price tag on justice? If somebody can come up with a better non-biased judicial system then please feel free. But until then, I see no better alternative.
Frederick Seal, USA
There seems to be a continual erosion of our judicial system. It's another step towards justice by decree. Magistrates are essentially illegitimate: they are not elected, nor randomly chosen; they are appointees of the State. Their use should be restricted to very minor cases. The right to be judged by one's peers is ancient and fundamental. Justice dispensed by 'experts' or officials is abhorrent.
Mark Parker, UK
The people need to be involved in the justice system. No juries, only appointed judges? I don't think so.
Joyce Cross, USA
Having worked as a Barrister's Clerk for some time I have come to the conclusion that jury trials do not always result in justice. Most criminals are accomplished liars, resulting in many juries being lead astray from the truth. As a result justice is not reached.
Hannah Bell, England
Ask many innocent victims of this flawed system. The law is a complex business and best left to those who have devoted their lives to studying it. Replace juries drawn from ordinary people with teams of professional jurors trained and qualified to perform the function.
John, England
